Everything felt like it was falling apart for the Red Sox about a week ago. Alex Bregman, the guy who was supposed to be the bridge to the future, just walked out the door for a $175 million bag from the Cubs. Red Sox fans were essentially ready to riot. Then, Craig Breslow actually did something. He didn’t just tinker with the margins; he went out and dropped $130 million on Ranger Suárez.
This isn't your typical Boston Red Sox news and rumors cycle. Usually, we’re talking about "financial flexibility" or "full throttle" comments that never materialize. But right now, the Red Sox have a pitching rotation that actually looks… scary?
The Ranger Suárez Splash and a "Frightening" Rotation
Suárez is the headline. The five-year deal is the first major free-agent contract the Red Sox have handed out this winter, and it comes at a 3.38 career ERA price tag. Honestly, it was a desperate move, but the good kind of desperate.
If you look at the projected 2026 rotation, it’s arguably the deepest in the American League:
- Garrett Crochet (The ace who almost won the Cy Young last year)
- Ranger Suárez (The proven postseason stabilizer)
- Sonny Gray (Acquired via trade from St. Louis)
- Brayan Bello (The homegrown arm with the sinker from hell)
- Johan Oviedo (Another trade acquisition who avoids arbitration)
Wait, there’s more. Most teams struggle to find five starters. Boston has ten.
Kutter Crawford, who would be a mid-rotation guy on a dozen other teams, is currently sitting at number six on the depth chart. Then you have Patrick Sandoval, Kyle Harrison, and young guys like Payton Tolle and Connelly Early. It’s an embarrassment of riches on the mound, which is a weird sentence to write about the Red Sox in 2026.
📖 Related: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
Why the Rafael Devers Trade Still Stings
We have to talk about the elephant in the room. You can't mention Boston Red Sox news and rumors without the name Rafael Devers coming up, even if he’s wearing a San Francisco Giants jersey now.
The trade back in June 2025 was supposed to be about "culture" and "defense." The front office basically told Devers they weren't replacing him, then they signed Bregman and told Devers to move to first base. He said no. He got shipped out. Now, Bregman is in Chicago, and the Red Sox have a gaping hole at third base.
It feels like a massive self-inflicted wound. The Giants are reportedly planning to play Devers at first base anyway, which makes the whole "he wouldn't move" narrative even more frustrating for fans in New England.
Who is the Next Target? Bo Bichette or Nico Hoerner?
With the rotation solidified, the rumor mill is spinning toward the infield. Bo Bichette is the name everyone wants. He’s the star power this lineup lacks now that Devers and Bregman are gone. But the latest buzz from insiders like Jen McCaffrey suggests it’s a long shot. Bichette wants $200 million, and the Phillies are currently looking like the highest bidder.
So, where does that leave Boston?
👉 See also: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
The trade market is the most likely path. Since the Red Sox have about five extra starting pitchers, they have the capital to make a deal. Nico Hoerner from the Cubs is the name that makes the most sense.
Think about it. The Cubs just signed Bregman. They have a surplus of infielders. Hoerner is a Gold Glover who hit .297 last year and put up over 6.0 bWAR. He doesn’t have the "wow" factor of Bichette, but he’s exactly the kind of high-floor player this roster needs. The only catch? He’s in his final year of control, so Breslow would probably want an extension tucked into the deal.
The Willson Contreras Factor
Don't forget that the Red Sox already snagged Willson Contreras from the Cardinals in December. They gave up Hunter Dobbins and some right-handed depth to get him. He’s 33, he’s expensive, but he’s a leader.
But a catcher and a bunch of pitchers don't win a World Series alone. You need runs. Right now, the lineup is leaning heavily on Jarren Duran and Triston Casas (who is finally healthy after that patellar tendon rupture).
What the Front Office is Actually Thinking
The vibes in the front office have shifted. Craig Breslow seems to be operating with a "win now" mandate that wasn't there twelve months ago. Signing Suárez was a pivot away from the Max Fried debacle—where the Yankees outbid Boston by about $28 million.
✨ Don't miss: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
The strategy is clear: Build a pitching staff so deep that even if two guys go down with Tommy John, the season isn't over. It’s a smart way to build, but it's risky if the offense stays this thin.
Real-World Action Steps for the Front Office
If the Red Sox want to actually win the AL East in 2026, they can't stop at Suárez. Here is the realistic checklist for the next three weeks:
- Trade from the pitching surplus immediately. You don't need ten starters. Flip Kutter Crawford or Johan Oviedo for a right-handed bat.
- Engage the Phillies on Alec Bohm. If Philly actually lands Bo Bichette, Bohm becomes available. He’s the perfect replacement for the Bregman/Devers hole at third.
- Stop the lefty obsession. The team is reportedly looking specifically for right-handed hitters. That's why Brendan Donovan is "bottom of the list" despite being a great player. Focus on guys like Isaac Paredes or even a reunion with a veteran like Eugenio Suárez on a short-term deal.
- Finalize the bullpen. While the rotation is deep, the high-leverage relief spots are still a bit shaky after non-tendering Josh Winckowski.
The 2026 Red Sox are going to be a fascinating experiment. They’ve gone from a team that couldn't find a starter to a team that has too many, all while losing the face of the franchise and his supposed replacement in the span of six months. It’s chaotic, it’s expensive, and it’s very Boston.
Keep an eye on the trade market as we head toward February. The Suárez signing was just the first domino. The real move—the one that defines the 2026 season—is likely still sitting in another team’s dugout right now.