Let’s be real for a second. If you grew up in the mid-2000s, you probably remember the sheer, unadulterated hype surrounding the book Eldest Christopher Paolini released as the follow-up to his massive debut, Eragon. People were obsessed. I'm talking midnight release parties, people wearing cardboard dragon wings, the whole nine yards. But looking back on it now, especially with the 2023 release of Murtagh breathing new life into the World of Eragon, the second book in the Inheritance Cycle remains a bit of a black sheep for some.
It’s a massive book. Over 700 pages of dense elven lore, excruciating physical therapy (seriously), and a cousin who suddenly decides to become the Alagaësia version of a guerrilla warfare leader.
Some people love it. Others find it a slog. Honestly? It's probably the most important book in the series because it’s where Paolini stops writing a "simple" hero's journey and starts actually building a world with consequences.
The Story Most People Forget (or Skip)
The book Eldest Christopher Paolini crafted doesn't just pick up where the first one left off; it shatters the status quo within the first twenty pages. We start in the aftermath of the Battle under Farthen Dûr. Eragon is a mess. He’s got a giant, magical scar on his back that gives him seizures, and his mentor figure, Ajihad, gets killed almost immediately.
Then the story splits. This was a huge deal at the time.
- Eragon and Saphira head north to the elven forest, Du Weldenvarden.
- Roran, Eragon’s cousin, stays behind in Carvahall and basically turns into a legend.
- Nasuada takes over the Varden and learns that politics is way bloodier than sword fighting.
Most of the "Eldest is boring" complaints come from the middle section. Eragon spends a long time learning how to meditate and listen to ants. If you’re here for dragon fire and decapitations, the chapters where he's learning elven etiquette might feel like watching paint dry. But there's a reason for it. Paolini was obsessed with the idea that magic shouldn't be free. It should cost something. It should require discipline.
📖 Related: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
Why Roran is Secretly the Best Part
If you ask a hardcore fan what they remember most about the book Eldest Christopher Paolini wrote, they won't say the elves. They’ll say Roran Stronghammer.
While Eragon is off getting magical plastic surgery from a giant spectral dragon (the Agaetí Blödhren ceremony), Roran is dealing with the Ra'zac back in their home village. He doesn't have a dragon. He doesn't have a magic sword. He just has a hammer and a really intense desire to save his fiancée, Katrina.
The Roran chapters are gritty. They’re about a normal guy leading a whole village across a mountain range and then stealing a fleet of ships. It’s a total shift in tone from the high-fantasy elven stuff. It grounds the series. It reminds you that while Eragon is out here becoming a demi-god, the rest of the world is suffering under Galbatorix’s thumb in a very real, very dirty way.
The Big Reveal: That "Star Wars" Comparison
Okay, we have to talk about the ending. You know the one. The Battle of the Burning Plains.
This is where Eragon meets a new Dragon Rider. It’s Murtagh. But he’s not the friend Eragon remember; he's been forced into a blood oath with Galbatorix and he's riding a red dragon named Thorn. Then comes the bombshell: Murtagh reveals they are brothers.
👉 See also: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
"We are the sons of Morzan!"
At the time, people lost their minds. Critics basically screamed, "This is just The Empire Strikes Back!" And yeah, the parallels are there. Mysterious mentor? Check. Training in a remote forest? Check. The "I am your brother/father" reveal? Check.
But Paolini has always been pretty open about his influences. He was a teenager when he started these books. He was playing with the archetypes he loved. What makes the book Eldest Christopher Paolini penned stand out isn't the "twist" itself, but how it breaks Eragon. He loses his sword, Zar'roc. He loses his sense of identity. He realizes his "inheritance" is a legacy of betrayal.
E-E-A-T: Is Eldest Actually Good?
From a literary standpoint, the prose in Eldest is a significant step up from Eragon. You can see Paolini growing as a writer in real-time. The descriptions of Ellesméra are lush—houses grown from trees, singing to plants, the whole "life is a song" vibe.
However, there are legitimate critiques.
✨ Don't miss: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
- Pacing: The middle 300 pages could probably have been 150.
- The Romance: Eragon’s infatuation with Arya is... a lot. It’s very "teenage boy who doesn't know how to handle rejection," which is realistic, but it can be a bit painful to read as an adult.
- The Deus Ex Machina: Some fans feel the Agaetí Blödhren (the ceremony that turns Eragon into a human-elf hybrid) was a "cheat code" to fix his back injury and make him powerful enough to win.
Still, the book won the Quill Award in 2006 for a reason. It expanded the scope of Alagaësia. It introduced Oromis and Glaedr, the "Cripple Who Is Whole" and the golden dragon, who added a much-needed layer of history and tragedy to the lore.
What to Do if You're Revisiting Alagaësia
If you’re thinking about picking up the book Eldest Christopher Paolini wrote after years away, or maybe for the first time, don't rush the training sequences.
The value of this book is in the philosophy. It’s about how to live with a chronic injury. It’s about the ethics of eating meat (the elves are vegetarians, which causes a whole thing for Eragon). It’s about whether you can truly change who you are.
Pro-tip for 2026 readers: If you finish Eldest and find yourself obsessed with the Murtagh/Thorn dynamic, go straight to the 2023 novel Murtagh. It recontextualizes everything that happens at the end of Eldest and makes the "villain" reveal so much more heartbreaking.
Basically, Eldest isn't just a bridge between the beginning and the end. It's the heart of the series. It’s where the farm boy dies and the Rider is actually born.
To get the most out of your re-read, I’d suggest grabbing a map of Alagaësia and actually tracking Roran’s path. It makes the geography of the final battle much more satisfying when you realize just how far those villagers traveled on foot and by sea just to have a chance at freedom.
Check out the Deluxe Edition if you can find it. It has some great bonus content on the Ancient Language that helps explain why the magic system is so rigid (and cool).