Bridgehampton is weird. It’s got that specific, high-velocity Hamptons energy where a $40 million farmhouse sits next to a tractor supply store, and everyone is pretending they aren't looking at the celebrity ordering a black coffee. In the middle of this chaos sits Bobby Van’s restaurant Bridgehampton. It’s been there since 1969. That’s an eternity in restaurant years.
Honestly, most places out here last about three summers before they’re replaced by a "concept" eatery that serves deconstructed kale for $60. But Bobby Van’s doesn't do that. It’s a steakhouse. A real one. It smells like wood, expensive bourbon, and the kind of history you can’t buy with a marketing budget.
If you walk in today, you’re stepping into a space that was once the living room for the most famous writers in American history. Truman Capote used to roll up in a pink Cadillac. He’d have a white poodle under one arm and a thirst for something strong. He wasn't the only one.
The Piano Player and the Literary Mob
Bobby Van himself wasn't just a name on a sign. He was a classically trained pianist who studied at Juilliard. He’d cook the steaks and then jump on the Steinway to play Chopin or Gershwin until the sun started thinking about coming up.
It was a "gin mill." That’s what Marina Van, Bobby’s former wife, called it. It wasn't some polished corporate chain back then. It was a dark, smoke-filled room where Willie Morris, James Jones, and John Knowles argued about syntax and war.
- Truman Capote: Rumor has it he finished In Cold Blood while hanging out here.
- The 1975 Photo: There’s a famous shot of Jones, Capote, Morris, and Knowles standing out front. They look young, slightly tipsy, and completely at home.
- The Move: In 1979, the restaurant moved across the street to its current spot at 2393 Montauk Highway. People were worried it would lose its soul. It didn't.
When Bobby eventually sold the place in the late 80s, it could have easily become a memory. Instead, it became the flagship for a brand that now spans New York City and D.C. But the Bridgehampton location remains the "mothership."
What You’re Actually Eating
Let’s talk about the food. You aren't going to Bobby Van’s restaurant Bridgehampton for a light snack. You’re going for the beef.
In 1996, Robert Dicker joined the team. He’s the great-nephew of Peter Luger. Yes, that Peter Luger. He brought the dry-aging secrets with him. They have a humidity-controlled room where the USDA Prime beef sits for up to 28 days. This isn't just "aging"; it's a transformation. The enzymes break down the fibers, the water evaporates, and you’re left with a steak that tastes like a concentrated version of itself.
🔗 Read more: Exactly How Many Weeks Until March 15 2025: Why This Specific Date Matters
The Heavy Hitters
The Porterhouse is the move. It’s served for two, three, or four people. It comes out sizzling, sliced, and swimming in its own juices. You don't need sauce. If you use the sauce, you’re missing the point of the dry-aging process.
But it’s not just a steakhouse anymore. The menu has drifted toward the coast, which makes sense since the Atlantic is basically down the street. The Linguini with Shellfish is surprisingly good for a place known for red meat. It’s loaded with local littleneck clams and mussels.
If you’re there for lunch, get the Bobby Van’s Burger. It’s $26.09 (as of late 2025/early 2026 pricing), which is "Hamptons cheap." It’s a massive 10-ounce patty that actually tastes like steak.
The "Widows' Table" and Modern Magic
There’s a specific table in the bar area that has more history than most museums. It’s often called the "widows' table." For years, the wives of the great writers who frequented the joint—Gloria Jones and Elaine Steinbeck among them—would gather there.
That’s the thing about Bobby Van’s. It’s a bridge. On one side, you have the ghosts of 20th-century literature. On the other, you have Wall Street traders and families in flip-flops.
💡 You might also like: Fall garland for front door: Why your porch looks flat and how to fix it
Why the Service is Polarizing
If you read reviews, you’ll see people complaining about the service. "They were rude," or "The host was short with me."
Kinda.
Bobby Van’s isn't a "customer is always right" kind of place in the way a modern chain is. It’s an old-school New York institution. The servers are pros. They’ve seen everything. If you treat the place like your personal playground, they might give you a look. But if you’re there to eat a good steak and have a drink, they’re the best in the business.
Surviving the "New Hamptons"
Since 2020, the Hamptons has changed. It became a year-round residence for the ultra-wealthy. This put a lot of pressure on local staples. Some sold out. Others closed.
Bobby Van’s restaurant Bridgehampton survived because it didn't try to change. They kept the white tablecloths. They kept the wood-fired pizzas for the kids. They kept the bar stocked with the good stuff.
It’s expensive. A Bone-in Ribeye is over $75. A side of Lobster Truffle Mac & Cheese will set you back nearly $30. But you aren't just paying for the calories. You’re paying for the fact that you’re sitting in the same room where John Lennon and Bob Dylan once jammed on harmonicas while Bobby played the piano.
Practical Steps for Your Visit
If you’re planning to head over, don't just wing it.
- Reservations: Between Memorial Day and Labor Day, you’re not getting in without one. Use their website or call (631) 537-0590.
- The Bar Scene: If the dining room feels too stuffy, the bar is where the life is. It’s open until 11:00 PM most nights.
- Lunch is the Secret: You get the same quality of meat for a fraction of the dinner rush stress. The French Dip is a sleeper hit.
- Check the Art: Look at the photos on the walls. It’s a visual history of Bridgehampton before it became a brand.
Bobby Van’s isn't trying to be the trendiest spot in the 631 area code. It doesn't need to be. It’s the anchor. Whether you're there for a celebratory Porterhouse or just a gin and tonic at the bar where Truman Capote used to hold court, you're participating in a piece of New York history that refuses to fade away.
📖 Related: Thing 1 and Thing 2 Images: Why We Are Still Obsessed With These Chaos Muppets
To get the most out of the experience, aim for a late Sunday lunch in the "off-season." The light hits the dining room just right, the crowd is mostly locals, and you can actually hear the echoes of the old piano bar. Order the Thick Cut Bacon with the maple balsamic glaze as an appetizer—it’s the best $20 you’ll spend in Bridgehampton.