You've seen the look. It's everywhere. You're driving through a new subdivision or scrolling through a designer’s portfolio on Instagram, and there it is—that crisp, textured contrast of vertical lines meeting traditional laps. Mixing these two isn't just a trend anymore. It’s basically the gold standard for "modern farmhouse" or "mountain modern" aesthetics. But here is the thing: most people just slap board and batten mixed with horizontal siding together without thinking about the visual weight, and that is exactly how a high-end renovation starts to look like a DIY disaster.
It's about shadow lines.
When you look at a house, your eye looks for a place to rest. If you have busy horizontal laps competing with narrow vertical battens, your brain gets a little overwhelmed. Designers like Joanna Gaines or the folks over at James Hardie have popularized this multi-texture approach because it breaks up the "big box" feel of a two-story home. It adds architectural interest where there usually isn't any. But if you don't get the ratios right, the house looks like it’s wearing two different outfits at the same time.
The Secret to Nailing the Proportions
Most people think you just pick a floor and switch the direction. Easy, right? Not really. If you put board and batten on the bottom and horizontal siding on the top, you risk making the house look "top-heavy." Traditionally, the heavier-looking material stays low. Because horizontal siding (like standard 4-inch or 6-inch laps) feels more grounded and "stable" to the human eye, it usually performs best as the primary base.
Then you use the board and batten as the accent.
Think gables. Think entryways. Think bump-outs.
If you have a massive gable end staring at the street, filling that entire triangle with horizontal siding can look... well, boring. It’s a flat sea of lines. By switching to board and batten in that specific area, you draw the eye upward and create a sense of height. It’s a trick architects use to make small homes feel more imposing. But honestly, if you do a 50/50 split right down the middle of the house, it often looks like the home was built in two different eras by two different people who didn't talk to each other. Aim for a 70/30 or 60/40 split.
Let the horizontal siding do the heavy lifting. Let the board and batten be the "jewelry" that catches the light.
💡 You might also like: Cooper City FL Zip Codes: What Moving Here Is Actually Like
Why Materials Actually Matter for This Look
You can't just talk about the "look" without talking about what the boards are actually made of. Wood is beautiful, sure, but the maintenance is a nightmare. Most modern pros are leaning heavily into fiber cement or engineered wood like LP SmartSide.
Why? Because of the seams.
If you're using vinyl for your board and batten mixed with horizontal siding, you’re going to see those J-channels where the two styles meet. It’s a dead giveaway that the material is plastic. Fiber cement, like the HardiePanel or HardiePlank systems, allows for much tighter transitions. You can use a simple metal flashing or a "belly band" (a thick horizontal trim board) to separate the two styles. That trim board is the "bridge" between the two worlds. Without a substantial trim piece between the horizontal and vertical sections, the transition looks flimsy. It looks cheap. You want that transition to look intentional, like a structural element of the home.
I’ve seen houses where they tried to skip the trim board and just butt the vertical boards against the horizontal laps. Don't do that. It leaks. It rots. It looks like garbage after three seasons.
The Color Trap
Let’s talk about the "all-white" trend. White board and batten with white horizontal siding is the "Modern Farmhouse" starter pack. It works because the shadows do all the work. On a sunny day, the vertical battens cast long, slim shadows, while the horizontal laps create tight, rhythmic shadows. Even though the color is the same, the texture is different.
But what if you want color?
This is where it gets tricky. If you choose a dark color—let’s say Iron Gray or a deep Navy—the texture of the board and batten becomes less visible from the street. Dark colors absorb shadow. If you’re going dark, you might want to increase the spacing between your battens. Usually, battens are placed 12 inches apart. For a dark-colored house, stretching that to 16 inches can keep the look from feeling too "busy" or cramped.
📖 Related: Why People That Died on Their Birthday Are More Common Than You Think
- Pro Tip: If you're mixing colors and textures, keep the darker color on the bottom. It anchors the house.
- The Exception: A dark accent gable can work, but only if the rest of the house has enough "visual weight" to support it.
Common Mistakes That Kill Curb Appeal
One of the biggest blunders I see is "orphan" siding. This is when a homeowner puts board and batten on just the front facade of the house but leaves the sides and back as 100% horizontal lap. It looks like a movie set. It’s a "stage front" house. If you’re going to mix board and batten with horizontal siding, the transition needs to make sense from a 3/4 view.
You should carry the vertical element around at least one corner, or use a natural architectural break—like an inside corner or a chimney—to stop the pattern.
Another mistake? Batten spacing. If your horizontal siding has a 4-inch reveal, and your battens are only 6 inches apart, the house is going to look like a barcode. You need contrast in scale. If your horizontal siding is narrow, make your board and batten wide. If you have wide-lap siding (like an 8-inch reveal), you can get away with tighter battens. You're looking for a "vibe" balance, not a mathematical match.
Real-World Performance and Durability
Let's get practical. Water is the enemy of any siding job. When you mix styles, you're creating more "termination points"—places where a board ends and another begins.
Horizontal siding is naturally shed-ready. Water hits it and runs down. Board and batten is a bit more complex because the horizontal trim at the bottom (the water table) or the transition band in the middle can catch water. You must ensure your contractor uses "Z-flashing." This is a piece of metal shaped like the letter Z that tucks behind the upper siding and over the top of the lower trim. It directs water out and away from the wall.
If your "expert" says they can just caulk that joint? Fire them. Caulk fails. Metal flashing is forever.
Actionable Steps for Your Siding Project
If you are currently staring at a stack of siding samples and trying to figure out how to pull this off, stop overthinking the "rules" and start looking at the structure of your specific house.
👉 See also: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
1. Identify your focal points. Does your house have a prominent gable or a protruding entryway? That is your candidate for board and batten. The "recessed" parts of the house should usually stay horizontal.
2. Choose your "Belly Band" carefully. Don't go thin. A 1x6 or even a 1x8 trim board between the two styles provides a bold, clear separation that makes the design look architectural rather than accidental.
3. Test the spacing. Take three pieces of batten and tape them to your wall at different widths—10 inches, 12 inches, and 16 inches. Step back to the sidewalk. You'll be surprised how much the "feel" of the house changes just by moving a piece of wood four inches to the left.
4. Watch the corners. Use wide corner boards. If you’re mixing textures, thin corner trim makes the whole house look like it’s made of paper. Heavy 4-inch or 6-inch corner posts give the transition a place to "land" solidly.
5. Match the "sheen." If your horizontal siding is a wood-grain texture (cedar mill), your board and batten should probably have that same texture. Mixing "smooth" vertical panels with "grainy" horizontal laps can look mismatched under direct sunlight.
Mixing these two styles is a high-reward design move, but it requires a bit of restraint. When in doubt, lean toward the horizontal. Use the vertical to tell a story about the height and the bones of the home. Get the flashing right, respect the shadow lines, and you'll have a house that looks custom without the custom-architect price tag.