Honestly, if you go back and watch Avengers: Age of Ultron today, it feels like a fever dream compared to the rest of the MCU. It’s messy. It’s loud. But the thing that usually gets the most heated debates going at 2 AM on Reddit is how the movie handled Black Widow.
Natasha Romanoff was already a fan favorite by 2015. We'd seen her kick serious butt in Iron Man 2 and basically co-lead The Winter Soldier. She was cool, collected, and arguably the most competent person in the room. Then black widow avengers 2 happened, and suddenly, Joss Whedon decided she needed a romance with Bruce Banner and a tragic backstory that involved "monsters."
The "Lullaby" and that Controversial Romance
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room. Or rather, the big green guy in the room.
The movie starts with Natasha doing this "lullaby" thing to calm the Hulk down. It’s intimate. It’s soft. And it caught everyone off guard because, in the first Avengers movie, she was literally terrified of him. Remember her shaking on the floor of the Helicarrier? Yeah, we all do.
The jump from "he might kill me" to "I’m in love with this nerdy scientist" felt jarring for a lot of people. Some fans argue it was a beautiful look at two broken people finding each other. They’re both "monsters" in their own eyes. Bruce has the Hulk; Natasha has the Red Room.
But others? They hated it. They felt like Natasha was being "reduced" to a love interest. It’s a valid point. For the only female Avenger at the time (before Wanda fully joined), seeing her pining over a guy felt like a step backward after her powerhouse performance in Captain America: The Winter Soldier.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
That "Monster" Line Everyone Misinterpreted
There’s a specific scene at Clint’s farmhouse—the one where everyone is just kind of hiding out—that still leaves a bad taste in people's mouths. Natasha tells Bruce about her graduation ceremony in the Red Room. She reveals that they sterilized the young girls so they’d have "one less thing to worry about" during missions.
Then she says: "You still think you're the only monster on the team?"
Oof.
For years, people took this to mean she thought she was a monster because she couldn't have kids. That would be a pretty terrible message, right? Joss Whedon eventually came out and said that wasn't the intent. He meant she was a monster because she was a trained assassin who had killed countless people. The sterilization was just the final piece of her being turned into a tool.
Still, the phrasing was clumsy. In a movie about a killer robot trying to wipe out humanity, having your lead female character call herself a monster because of her forced medical history felt... heavy. And maybe a bit tone-deaf.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
What Really Happened in the Red Room
We actually got some pretty cool (and creepy) visuals of the Red Room in this movie, thanks to Wanda’s mind games. We saw:
- Young Natasha doing ballet (a nod to the comics).
- Target practice on human-shaped figures.
- Madame B, the cold instructor played by Julie Delpy.
- The "graduation" ceremony that changed her forever.
These glimpses were the first real "deep dive" we got into where Natasha came from. It added a layer of tragedy that explained why she was so desperate to "wipe the red out of her ledger." She wasn't just a spy; she was a survivor of state-sponsored child abuse. That’s dark for a Disney movie.
The Ending Nobody Saw Coming
By the time the dust settles in Sokovia, the romance is basically dead. Bruce realizes he’s too dangerous and flies away in a cloaked Quinjet, leaving Natasha behind.
It’s a bittersweet ending. On one hand, she gets to be the "hero" and help lead the New Avengers (with War Machine, Falcon, Vision, and Wanda). On the other, the movie spent so much time on her relationship only to have it vanish into the Pacific Ocean.
Most fans were actually relieved when Civil War came around and basically ignored the Bruce/Natasha thing. It felt like the characters went back to their "factory settings." But black widow avengers 2 remains this weird, experimental chapter for the character. It tried to give her depth through vulnerability, even if it didn't quite stick the landing.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Looking Back: Was it Really That Bad?
Looking back from 2026, black widow avengers 2 is better than people remember, but worse than it could have been. Scarlett Johansson's performance is great. She does a lot with the material she's given. She makes you feel Natasha's weariness.
If you're revisiting the MCU or just curious about why people still argue about this movie, keep an eye on how Natasha moves. She’s the tactical heart of the team. She’s the one who gets the cradle. She’s the one who stays on mission when everyone else is falling apart.
She was a hero long before she was an Avenger.
What you should do next:
If you want to see how this character arc actually pays off, skip the "Hulk" scenes and re-watch the opening mission in Sokovia. Notice how she uses her environment. Then, go straight to the first 20 minutes of Captain America: Civil War. You'll see a much more consistent version of the Natasha Romanoff we eventually see in her solo film and Endgame.