Black Souls Stuck Ending A: What Most People Get Wrong

You've spent hours grinding through the nightmare fuel that is the first Black Souls. You’ve survived the twisted fairy tales, dodged the insta-death traps, and finally, you're standing at the threshold of the end. But then it happens. You hit a wall. You're aiming for the "Alice" ending—the one everyone calls Ending A—and you’re realizing it’s not as simple as just killing the final boss. Honestly, it’s one of the most frustrating "stuck" points in the entire RPG Maker horror scene.

Most players think they can just stroll into the final encounter and get the "good" (or at least, the most iconic) conclusion. Nope. This game is cruel. If you don't have your ducks in a row, you’ll get dumped into Ending B or C before you can even blink.

The Brutal Requirements for the Black Souls Stuck Ending A

If you feel like you’re hitting a dead end, it’s usually because you missed one of the three "golden rules" the game doesn't explicitly tell you. To trigger the true interaction with Alice after the Cinderella fight, you have to be essentially perfect.

1. The 0 Sin Requirement: This is the big one. If you’ve been "making love" to every NPC you meet or killing indiscriminately, your Sin count is likely too high. To get Ending A, your Sin must be exactly 0. You can check this at the statues or via certain NPCs, but if you’ve slipped up even once, you’re locked out.
2. The Companion Checklist: You need every single heroine as a companion. We’re talking about the heavy hitters like Dorothy, Elma, Victoria, and the rest of the gang. If even one is missing from your roster when you touch that final fog, the game assumes you haven't "saved" the world's fragments.
3. The Fog Solo Walk: Here is where it gets weird. After you defeat Cinderella, you have to approach the fog alone. If you have a companion actively following you, it can trigger the "Companion" endings instead of the core Ending A.

It’s a lot. Most people get "stuck" because they realize 20 hours in that they killed a random NPC for a loot drop and now their Sin is at 1. In Black Souls, that 1 is as good as 1,000 when it comes to Alice.

Why Everyone Struggles with "Where is Alice?"

So, you meet the requirements. You defeat Dinah or Cinderella (depending on your pathing), you talk to Alice, and you get the scene. Then the screen fades to black and the text "Where is Alice?" appears.

📖 Related: The PS3 Release Date: What Sony Got Right (and Very Wrong)

Is it a glitch? Did you get the bad ending?

Actually, no. That is Ending A. It’s meant to be jarring. The game is basically telling you that the Alice you’ve been chasing doesn't exist in the way you thought. You’re "stuck" in a cycle of searching. It’s a narrative gut-punch that leads directly into the sequel, Black Souls 2.

Common Pitfalls and Misconceptions

Kinda funny how many people think they need the Red Hood for this. You don't. She's her own separate beast.

🔗 Read more: Why Black Ops 3 Zombies is still the only game you need to play in 2026

Another thing: the SEN (Sanity) system. While SEN is vital for Ending E (where you need 0 SEN to fight Alice's nightmare form), for the standard Ending A, you just need to keep your head on straight and keep that Sin count at zero. If you find yourself unable to progress past the "Where is Alice?" screen, it’s not because the game is broken. It’s because the story has concluded for this chapter. You've officially finished the first game's primary narrative arc.

How to Fix Your Save if You're Locked Out

If you’re sitting there with 5 Sin and no way to get Ending A, you have a few options, though none of them are particularly "easy."

• The Absolution Route: There are ways to lower Sin, but they are limited. In many cases, if you've gone on a murder spree, you're better off starting a New Game Plus or a fresh file.
• The Cheat Engine "Fix": Look, I’m not saying you should, but many players in the community use tools to reset their Sin variable if they just want to see the ending without replaying 15 hours.
• The "Secret" Items: Make sure you didn't miss the Leaf's Ring if you're trying to pivot into the companion-specific versions of the ending.

Honestly, the "stuck" feeling usually comes from the game’s lack of a quest log. You're expected to remember who you talked to and what you did. If you missed a single dialogue trigger with Elma in the library or didn't finish Victoria's questline, the "Alice" ending simply won't trigger. It’s binary. Either you did everything, or you get the "Where is Alice?" placeholder.

💡 You might also like: Free Fill In Puzzles: Why These Word Games Are Actually Better Than Crosswords

Actionable Steps to Guarantee Ending A

To stop being stuck and actually see the credits roll on the Alice path, follow this checklist exactly. No shortcuts.

1. Check your Sin immediately. If it's not 0, stop. You need to find a way to lower it or restart.
2. Verify your Heroine count. You need: Leaf, Hansel & Gretel, Dorothy, Princess Frog, Elisabeth, Goose, Bremen, Elma, Victoria, and Jeanne.
3. Kill Cinderella. This is the point of no return.
4. Dismiss your active companion before interacting with the final fog/object.
5. Embrace Alice. When the "Where is Alice?" text appears, take a screenshot. You’ve done it.

The real "ending" to this series isn't even in the first game. It's a long, dark road through the sequels. If you've reached this point, you've seen the best and worst of what Grimm (the developer) has to offer. Now, the only thing left to do is move on to the second game and realize that everything you just did was only the beginning of a much larger, much more depressing cosmic horror story.