It was a Monday. October 19, 1987. Traders in New York didn't just lose money; they lost their minds. By the time the closing bell rang, the Dow Jones Industrial Average had plummeted 508 points. That was a 22.6% drop in a single day. Think about that for a second. If that happened today, we’d be looking at a several-thousand-point crater in a matter of hours. People called it Black Monday, and honestly, the name stuck because it felt like the end of the world for the financial sector.
The stock market crash of 1987 remains a bit of a ghost in the machine. It’s the event that haunts modern algorithmic trading. Unlike the Great Depression of 1929, which dragged on and on like a bad cold, 1987 was a flash flood. It was violent. It was sudden. It was also deeply confusing because there wasn't one single "smoking gun" like a war or a bank failure. It was a perfect storm of math, panic, and new-age technology that didn't know how to talk to itself.
If you weren't there, you probably think it was just a bunch of guys in yellow jackets screaming on a floor. It was way more than that. It was the moment the "machines" took over, and they weren't ready for the responsibility.
Why the Stock Market Crash of 1987 Still Terrifies Wall Street
Markets were actually doing great before the wheels fell off. From 1982 until the peak in August 1987, the Dow had more than tripled. People were making money hand over fist. But then, things got weird. Interest rates were creeping up. The U.S. dollar was wobbly. There were tensions in the Persian Gulf. Basically, the vibes were shifting.
Then came the "portfolio insurance." This is the part that gets people's heads spinning. It was a strategy used by big institutional investors—pension funds, insurance companies—to protect themselves if prices fell. They used computer programs to automatically sell stock index futures when the market dropped. The logic was simple: sell a little now to avoid losing a lot later.
The problem? Everyone had the same idea at the same time.
🔗 Read more: Jamie Dimon Explained: Why the King of Wall Street Still Matters in 2026
When the market dipped on that Monday morning, the computers started selling. Those sales drove the price lower. Because the price was lower, the computers sold more. It was a feedback loop from hell. It wasn't human panic—at least not at first. It was code. The stock market crash of 1987 proved that when everyone uses the same "safety" program, there’s no such thing as safety. There were no "circuit breakers" back then. No one could just pull the plug and say, "Hey, let's take a five-minute breather." The tape was running so far behind that traders didn't even know the real prices. They were flying blind into a hurricane.
The Role of Arbitrage and the "Decoupling"
While the big guys were using portfolio insurance, arbitrageurs were trying to profit from the gap between the price of stocks in New York and the price of futures in Chicago. Usually, these two markets move together. On Black Monday, they snapped apart. The "spread" became a canyon.
The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) was overwhelmed. Some stocks didn't even open for trading because there were so many sell orders and zero buyers. If you can’t find a buyer, you can’t have a price. If you don't have a price, the computers freak out even more. It was a total breakdown of the plumbing.
Shaking Off the Myths
A lot of people think the stock market crash of 1987 caused a recession. Weirdly, it didn't. Most people outside of the financial districts went to work on Tuesday, grabbed their coffee, and kept living their lives. The economy actually stayed pretty resilient. This wasn't 1929. The Fed, led by a brand-new Alan Greenspan, stepped in immediately. They flooded the system with liquidity. They basically told the banks, "Don't stop lending. We've got your back." It worked.
Another myth is that it was all because of a trade deficit report. Sure, there was a disappointing trade deficit number released a few days prior, but that was just the match. The "portfolio insurance" was the gasoline-soaked rags in the basement.
💡 You might also like: Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion Book and Why It Still Actually Works
- Fact: The decline was global. This wasn't just a "Wall Street" problem. Hong Kong, London, and Australia got absolutely hammered too.
- Fact: Many big-name stocks like IBM and Procter & Gamble saw their prices evaporate because the specialists on the floor simply couldn't handle the volume.
- Fact: The recovery was faster than anyone expected. Within two years, the Dow had climbed back to its pre-crash highs.
What the Experts Say
Luminaries like Robert Shiller, the Nobel-winning economist, actually surveyed traders right after the crash. He wanted to know why they sold. His findings were fascinating. It wasn't because of news about interest rates or the Persian Gulf. It was because they saw everyone else selling. It was a psychological contagion. The machines started it, but the humans finished it because they were terrified of being the last ones holding the bag.
Lessons That Keep Traders Awake at Night
If you're looking at your 401(k) today, you need to understand that 1987 changed everything about how the market operates. It gave us circuit breakers. Now, if the S&P 500 drops 7%, the whole thing shuts down for 15 minutes. It’s a "forced nap" for the market. We have 1987 to thank for that.
But here’s the kicker: we now have High-Frequency Trading (HFT). We have algorithms that are infinitely faster and more complex than the crude "portfolio insurance" of the 80s. The stock market crash of 1987 was a warning shot. It showed that the system is only as stable as its weakest link. In '87, that link was the physical capacity of the exchange to process orders. Today, the link might be the complexity of the algorithms themselves.
How to Protect Yourself from a "Flash" Scenario
You can't predict a crash. Anyone who tells you they can is selling something. But you can prepare for the volatility that 1987 taught us is always possible.
- Stop-Loss Orders Aren't Magic. On Black Monday, stop-loss orders were often skipped over. If a stock closes at $50 and opens at $30, your "stop" at $45 doesn't matter. You're selling at $30.
- Liquidity is King. In a crash, everyone wants out, but no one wants in. If you're in "thin" investments (small-cap stocks, certain crypto assets, etc.), you might find yourself trapped.
- The "Greenspan Put" Mentality. Ever since '87, investors have expected the Federal Reserve to save the day whenever the market dips. This has created a bit of a "moral hazard" where people take more risks because they think the Fed won't let the market fail. Don't rely on that.
The stock market crash of 1987 wasn't a failure of the American economy. It was a failure of the American market's infrastructure. It was a technical glitch that cost trillions. It reminds us that the market is a machine, and sometimes, machines break.
📖 Related: How to make a living selling on eBay: What actually works in 2026
Actionable Steps for Today's Investors
Stop checking your portfolio every ten minutes during high volatility. It’s the easiest way to make a panic-based mistake. Instead, look at your "Asset Allocation." If a 22% drop in one day would literally ruin your life, you're too heavily invested in equities. Period.
Review your "automatic" triggers. If you have automated trading rules set up, make sure they aren't designed to sell into a vacuum.
Diversification didn't save people in '87 because everything went down at once. However, having cash on the sidelines did allow the smartest investors to buy the dip of a lifetime. The ones who kept their cool on Tuesday morning ended up being the ones who retired wealthy.
Keep a written "Investment Policy Statement." When the screen turns red and the news anchors start shouting, read your own rules. It sounds simple. It’s actually the hardest thing in the world to do when everyone else is running for the exits.
The ghosts of 1987 are still there. They’re in the code of every trading bot and the back of every veteran trader's mind. History doesn't always repeat, but it definitely rhymes, and the rhyme of Black Monday is a loud, chaotic warning about the dangers of over-reliance on "fail-safe" systems.
Keep your eyes open. Don't trust the machines blindly. And always, always remember that the market can go down much faster than it ever goes up.
Next Steps for Your Portfolio:
- Audit your risk exposure: Calculate your total loss if the S&P 500 dropped 20% tomorrow. If that number makes you sick, rebalance into bonds or cash.
- Study the "Flash Crash" of 2010: Compare the 1987 events with modern high-frequency crashes to see how the "machine" has evolved.
- Verify your brokerage's "Emergency" protocols: Know how to execute a trade if their web interface goes down during a high-volume event.