You probably think you know your birthstone. Most people do. You’ve seen the cheap spinning racks at the mall or the personalized jewelry ads on Instagram, and you’ve accepted that if you’re born in July, you’re "a ruby." But honestly? The history of birthstone colors and months is a messy, beautiful, and occasionally corporate-driven tangle that goes back way further than a 1912 marketing meeting.
It’s weirdly personal. People wear these stones like tiny badges of identity. But the "official" list you see everywhere isn't the only list. It’s just the one that won the PR war.
The Weird Origin Story of Birthstone Colors and Months
Before we get into the specifics of which rock belongs to which month, we have to talk about why this even exists. It wasn’t just a jeweler trying to sell rings in the early 20th century, though they definitely helped.
The tradition actually tracks back to the Breastplate of Aaron, described in the Book of Exodus. It had twelve stones. Later, in the 1st and 5th centuries, scholars like Josephus and St. Jerome started making the connection between those twelve stones and the twelve signs of the zodiac.
Back then, you didn't just wear your own stone. That’s a modern twist. People used to own all twelve and rotate them throughout the year. It was like a spiritual prescription. You’d wear the emerald in May to soak up that specific energy, then swap it out. The idea of a "birth" stone—one gem for life—only really gained traction in 18th-century Poland.
January: The Garnet’s Secret Range
Most people see January and think "dark red." Like a scab or a cheap Cabernet. But the garnet is actually a massive family of minerals.
If you’re a January baby, you aren't stuck with that brownish-red stuff. You’ve got the Tsavorite garnet, which is a screaming, electric green that rivals high-end emeralds. Then there’s the Spessartite, which looks like a crushed orange Fanta. The "standard" red is usually Pyrope or Almandine. Garnets are incredibly tough—7 to 7.5 on the Mohs scale—which makes them great for everyday wear. They don’t have a cleavage plane, meaning they don't chip as easily as diamonds when you accidentally whack your hand against a granite countertop.
Why February and March Are So Polar Opposite
Amethyst is the February staple. It’s quartz. Cheap, plentiful, and purple. Historically, though, it was as expensive as a diamond until huge deposits were found in Brazil. It was the "sober" stone. The Greeks literally named it amethystos, meaning "not drunken." They thought if you drank from a cup made of amethyst, you wouldn't get a hangover. Spoilers: It doesn’t work.
Then you hit March. Aquamarine.
The name says it all—water of the sea. It’s a beryl, the same family as emerald, but it grows in much cleaner crystals. While emeralds are usually full of "gardens" (fractures and inclusions), aquamarine is often eye-clean. Legend says sailors kept them under their pillows to prevent drowning. It’s a calming stone. It’s the visual equivalent of a Xanax.
The Diamond Monopoly of April
April is the diamond. Boring? Maybe. Expensive? Definitely.
👉 See also: AR 15 NYS Compliant: How to Actually Stay Legal in New York
But here’s the thing: Diamonds weren't even the "king of gems" for most of human history. Rubies were. The obsession with April diamonds is a relatively recent phenomenon fueled by massive marketing campaigns. If a diamond feels too "bridal" for a birthstone gift, look into "salt and pepper" diamonds. They have wild carbon inclusions that look like galaxies. They’re much cooler, honestly, and they still fit the April criteria.
May and June: The High-Maintenance Months
May belongs to the Emerald. It’s a stunning green, but emeralds are the divas of the gemstone world. They are "brittle." If you drop an emerald on a tile floor, there is a very real chance it will shatter into green sand.
Most emeralds are treated with cedar oil to fill the tiny cracks that reach the surface. If you put your May birthstone jewelry in an ultrasonic cleaner at a jewelry store, you might actually strip that oil out and make the stone look dull and cracked. Don't do that.
June is even weirder because it has three "official" stones: Pearl, Alexandrite, and Moonstone.
- Pearls are organic. They come from oysters.
- Alexandrite is a freak of nature. It’s "emerald by day, ruby by night." It literally changes color from green to purplish-red depending on the light source.
- Moonstone has adularescence, that ghostly blue sheen that looks like it’s trapped under the surface.
The Mid-Year Heat: July and August
July is Ruby. The "King of Precious Stones." A ruby is just a red sapphire. Chemically, they are both Corundum. If it’s any other color, it’s a sapphire. If it’s red, it’s a ruby. But "red" is a spectrum. The most prized is "pigeon’s blood"—a deep red with a hint of blue.
August used to be just Peridot. Peridot is one of the few gemstones that only comes in one color: lime green. It’s formed deep in the Earth’s mantle and brought up by volcanoes. Some have even been found in meteorites.
📖 Related: What Does Pilled Mean? The Internet’s Most Complicated Slang Explained
Recently, the American Gem Trade Association added Spinel as an August alternative. Spinel is the great imposter. For centuries, famous "rubies" in crown jewels (like the Black Prince's Ruby in the British Imperial State Crown) turned out to be red spinels.
September to December: The Blue Shift
September is Sapphire. Everyone thinks blue, but sapphires come in every color of the rainbow except red (because then it's a ruby). You can get peach sapphires, yellow sapphires, and even "Parti" sapphires that show two colors at once.
October gives you Opal or Tourmaline.
Opals are like 10% water. They can literally dehydrate and crack if you live in a desert and don't wear them. They are the most individualistic stones; no two look alike. Tourmaline is also a "gemstone rainbow." Some crystals are green on the outside and pink on the inside—those are called Watermelon Tourmalines.
November is Topaz or Citrine.
Most "Blue Topaz" you see today starts as colorless or brownish stones that are blasted with radiation and then heated. It’s safe, but it’s definitely "man-assisted" beauty. Imperial Topaz, which is a natural peachy-orange, is the real prize here.
December has the most identity crisis.
Is it Turquoise? Zircon? Tanzanite?
- Turquoise is the ancient choice, used by the Egyptians and Native Americans.
- Zircon is the oldest mineral on Earth. Not to be confused with cubic zirconia (the fake stuff). Zircon is a natural, heavy, brilliant stone.
- Tanzanite was added in 2002. It’s only found in one place on Earth: a small strip of land in Tanzania near Mount Kilimanjaro. It’s a deep, velvety violet-blue.
The 1912 Shift: Why the List Changed
In 1912, the National Association of Jewelers (now Jewelers of America) met in Kansas City to standardize the list. Before this, it was a free-for-all. Every culture had different stones. The jewelers wanted to make sure they could actually stock what people were asking for.
They chose stones that were commercially available. That’s why some "traditional" stones like Chrysolite or Bloodstone were pushed to the sidelines. They weren't as "pretty" or easy to sell to a mass market.
In 1952, 2002, and 2016, the list was tweaked again. They added things like Alexandrite, Tanzanite, and Spinel. Why? Because people like choices, and jewelers like having more things to sell you. It’s a mix of ancient mysticism and modern retail strategy.
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception about birthstone colors and months is that the color is the only thing that matters. People buy "birthstone jewelry" that is just colored glass or cubic zirconia. If you’re buying for the meaning, the mineral matters.
A "ruby-colored" glass stone isn't a ruby. It doesn't have the 9-hardness of corundum. It doesn't have the history.
Another error is the "durability" trap. People buy Opals for their kids or for engagement rings without realizing that Opals are about as soft as glass. They will scratch. They will break. If you’re an October baby and you’re active, you should probably go with Tourmaline instead.
Specifics for the Skeptical Buyer
If you are looking for a birthstone, check the "Origin" and "Treatment" reports.
- Heat Treatment: Almost all Sapphires and Rubies are heated. It’s standard. It’s fine. It just makes the color pop.
- Fracture Filling: Common in Emeralds. Be careful.
- Synthetic vs. Natural: A lab-grown ruby is chemically a ruby. It’s just grown in a machine. A "simulated" ruby is just plastic or glass. Know the difference before you swipe your card.
Making Birthstones Work for You
Forget the "rules" for a second. If you hate the color of your month's stone, look at the alternatives. December has four. June has three. Even if your month only has one "official" stone, look at the varieties.
💡 You might also like: Jersey City: What Nobody Tells You About the Weather Before Moving Here
If you're a January baby who hates red, get a mint-green Tsavorite. If you're a November baby who hates orange, get a London Blue Topaz.
The real power of these stones isn't in some magical alignment of the planets. It’s in the story. It’s a way to mark your place in time with something that took millions of years to grow.
Next Steps for the Savvy Collector:
- Check the Mohs Scale: Before buying a daily-wear ring, ensure the stone is at least a 7. Anything lower (like Opal or Pearl) is better suited for earrings or necklaces where they won't hit hard surfaces.
- Ask for Certification: For expensive stones like Emeralds, Rubies, or Tanzanite, always ask for a GIA or AGL report to verify the stone's origin and any treatments it has undergone.
- Explore "Secondary" Stones: Many months have "ancient" or "zodiac" alternatives that aren't on the modern list. If the 1912 list doesn't resonate, look into the Tibetan or Ayurvedic birthstone charts for a more unique connection.