It’s sitting in millions of medicine cabinets right now. A tiny plastic dial. Most people don't think twice about it, but the birth control pill history is actually one of the weirdest, most legally precarious, and ethically gray sagas in modern medicine. It wasn't some clean breakthrough in a sleek lab. It was a heist. It was a rogue mission funded by a millionaire widow and led by a biologist who had already been kicked out of academia.
Honestly, it’s a miracle it exists at all.
Back in the early 1900s, talking about contraception wasn't just "taboo." It was literally a crime. Under the Comstock Laws, mailing information about birth control was considered "obscene," on par with hard-core pornography. Margaret Sanger, who eventually founded what we now know as Planned Parenthood, had to flee to England to avoid prison just for writing about it. She wasn't some quiet advocate; she was a firebrand who believed women couldn't be free until they owned their own bodies. But she needed a scientist. She needed a way to make pregnancy a choice, not a "fate."
The rogue scientist and the $40,000 gamble
Enter Gregory Pincus. By 1951, Pincus was basically a scientific outcast. He’d been denied tenure at Harvard because his work on in vitro fertilization in rabbits—essentially "test-tube bunnies"—had freaked out the public. People thought he was playing God. He was working out of a small, underfunded lab in Massachusetts when Sanger introduced him to Katharine McCormick.
💡 You might also like: Anorexia and hair loss: Why it happens and how to actually get your thickness back
McCormick is the unsung hero here. She was one of the first women to graduate from MIT and had married into the massive International Harvester fortune. She was also a hardcore suffragist. When she asked Pincus if a "magic pill" was possible, he told her it might be, but he had no money. McCormick didn't blink. She wrote him a check for $40,000—a massive sum in 1951—and eventually poured over $2 million of her own wealth into the project.
They started with progesterone. Scientists already knew that progesterone naturally stops ovulation during pregnancy. If you could give a woman a dose of it, you could theoretically "trick" the body into thinking it was already pregnant. The problem? Natural progesterone was insanely expensive to produce and had to be injected. You couldn't just swallow it.
That’s where Frank Colton and Carl Djerassi come in. Working for pharmaceutical companies Searle and Syntex, they independently synthesized "progestin," a version that was shelf-stable and could be taken orally.
The Puerto Rico trials: A dark chapter
We have to talk about the ethics. It’s unavoidable. Because birth control was illegal in many U.S. states (especially in Massachusetts where Pincus worked), they couldn't run a large-scale clinical trial easily. They went to Puerto Rico.
In 1955, they began testing the pill on women in low-income housing projects in Rio Piedras. Many of these women weren't fully told what they were taking or that it was experimental. They just knew it prevented pregnancy. The doses were massive—way higher than what we use today.
The side effects were brutal. We’re talking nausea, dizziness, and blood clots. Three women died during the trials, but no autopsies were performed. When Dr. Edris Rice-Wray, who was overseeing the trials, told Pincus that the pill had too many side effects to be used, he basically ignored her. He was convinced that the side effects were "psychosomatic."
He was wrong. But he was also desperate to get it to market.
The "Moonflower" loophole
By 1957, the FDA approved Enovid—the first pill—but only for severe menstrual disorders. It wasn't legally a contraceptive. Suddenly, half a million American women magically developed "severe menstrual disorders." Everyone knew what was happening. It was the worst-kept secret in America.
Finally, in 1960, the FDA caved and approved it for contraceptive use. It was a cultural explosion. By 1965, 6.5 million women were on it. It changed everything: divorce rates, college graduation rates, and the workforce. But the safety issues didn't just vanish because the FDA signed a paper.
The Nelson Pill Hearings of 1970
Imagine being a woman in 1970. You're taking this pill every morning, and suddenly you see a headline about young women dropping dead from strokes or pulmonary embolisms.
Senator Gaylord Nelson convened hearings to investigate the safety of the pill. The weirdest part? Not a single woman was invited to testify. Members of a group called the D.C. Women’s Liberation began interrupting the hearings, shouting, "Why are you using us as guinea pigs?"
These protests actually led to the first-ever "patient package insert." You know that tiny, folded-up piece of paper with microscopic text that comes with your prescription? That exists because of the birth control pill history and the activists who demanded to know the risks.
Doctors were eventually forced to lower the hormone doses. The original Enovid pill had 10,000 micrograms of progestin; modern pills often have less than 150. We realized that more isn't better.
💡 You might also like: Why the Reproductive Health Experiences and Access Survey Matters More Than You Think
Why the "Placebo Week" even exists
This is a detail that trips people up. Why do most pill packs have a week of sugar pills that make you bleed? It’s not medically necessary. You don’t actually need a "period" when you’re on the pill because you aren't ovulating.
The reason is purely PR.
John Rock, the Catholic doctor who helped Pincus develop the pill, wanted the Catholic Church to accept it. He argued that the pill wasn't "unnatural" because it just mimicked a woman's natural cycle. He added the placebo week to ensure women still had a monthly bleed, making it feel "normal" and distinct from "abortion." He spent years trying to convince the Pope to approve it.
He failed. In 1968, Pope Paul VI issued Humanae Vitae, which officially banned all artificial birth control. Rock was devastated and eventually stopped attending Mass, but the 28-day cycle stuck. We still use it today mostly because of a failed attempt to appease the Vatican in the 1960s.
The legacy of Enovid
The pill didn't just change biology; it changed the law. In 1965, the Supreme Court case Griswold v. Connecticut struck down the ban on birth control for married couples, establishing a "right to privacy." It took until 1972 (Eisenstadt v. Baird) for that right to be extended to unmarried people.
It’s easy to look back and see a straight line of progress. But it was jagged. It was built on the backs of women in Puerto Rico who didn't give informed consent. It was funded by a wealthy woman who was tired of waiting for men to care about women's health.
What most people get wrong
A common myth is that the pill "broke" the traditional family. In reality, the pill arrived at a time when families were already changing. It gave women the ability to time their pregnancies so they could finish law school or medical school. It turned out that when women can control their reproduction, the entire economy shifts.
Another misconception? That the pill is the "best" or "only" way. Today, we have IUDs, implants, and patches that are often more effective because they remove human error. But the pill remains the icon. It was the first time a "medicine" was taken by healthy people to prevent a condition (pregnancy) rather than treat a disease.
Actionable insights: Navigating your options today
If you're looking at birth control pill history because you're trying to decide on a method for yourself, the landscape is vastly different than it was in 1960. You have choices Pincus never imagined.
- Audit your dose: If you’re experiencing mood swings or low libido, talk to your doctor about the androgenic index of your pill. Not all progestins are the same. Some are derived from testosterone and can cause more acne or irritability than others.
- Check for contraindications: If you have migraines with aura or a history of high blood pressure, combined pills (estrogen + progestin) might be dangerous for you. The "Mini-Pill" (progestin-only) is often the safer historical successor.
- Don't fear the "Skip": If you hate your period, talk to your provider about continuous use. You can skip the placebo pills and skip the bleed entirely. It’s perfectly safe; the "monthly bleed" was a marketing tactic from the '60s.
- Look at the LARC options: Long-Acting Reversible Contraception (like the Nexplanon implant or Mirena IUD) has a much lower failure rate (under 1%) compared to the pill (about 7-9% with typical use).
The history of the pill is a reminder that medical progress is usually driven by the people who need it most, often working outside the system. It’s a tool of autonomy, but like any tool, it’s only as good as the information you have about it. Use the patient insert. Ask the hard questions. That’s what the activists in 1970 fought for.