Everyone knows the line. You’ve probably belted it out at a wedding or a dive bar at 2 a.m. while swaying rhythmically with a lukewarm beer in your hand. "A bottle of red, a bottle of white / It all depends upon your appetite." It’s the opening salvo of "Scenes from an Italian Restaurant," arguably the most ambitious piece of music Billy Joel ever recorded.
But here’s the thing about the billy joel bottle of red bottle of white lyric: it isn't just a catchy rhyme about wine preferences. It’s the gateway into a seven-and-a-half-minute rock opera that almost didn't happen. Most people think "Piano Man" is his masterpiece. They’re wrong. Ask any die-hard Joel fan, or even Billy himself, and they’ll point to the multi-part epic on the The Stranger album as the peak of his storytelling.
It feels lived-in. Why? Because it was.
The Real Restaurant Behind the Song
For years, fans played a guessing game. Was it in Little Italy? Somewhere in the Bronx?
Billy eventually cleared the air. The "Italian Restaurant" was a spot called Fontana di Trevi, located right across from Carnegie Hall on 57th Street in Manhattan. It wasn’t some romanticized, hidden gem in a cobblestone alley. It was a place where a working musician could sit down, grab a drink, and watch the world go by. Sadly, the restaurant is gone now, replaced by the relentless march of New York City real estate, but the DNA of that room lives on in the recording.
The "bottle of red, bottle of white" line was actually inspired by a waiter. Billy was sitting there, looking at the menu, and the server literally asked him if he wanted a bottle of red or a bottle of white. It was mundane. It was everyday life.
Joel realized that the simplest interactions often mask the deepest nostalgia.
The song isn't actually about the wine. It’s about Brenda and Eddie, the "popular" couple who peaked in high school and fell apart under the weight of real life. The wine is just the lubricant for the conversation between two old friends—the narrator and a character named Binnie—who are catching up after years of silence.
Structure and the "B-Side" Influence
If you listen closely to the transition from the slow, melodic intro into the frantic, jazzy middle section, you might notice it feels like a medley.
👉 See also: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
That wasn’t an accident.
Billy Joel was obsessed with Side Two of The Beatles’ Abbey Road. He wanted to create his own version of that continuous flow where different song fragments stitch together to tell a larger story. He had three different song ideas that weren't quite working on their own. One was a slow ballad, one was an upbeat Dixieland jazz piece, and one was a driving rock-and-roll story about a failed marriage.
Producer Phil Ramone was the genius who helped him realize they were all the same song.
Ramone’s production on The Stranger is legendary for a reason. He captured the atmosphere. When you hear that saxophone solo—played by the incomparable Richie Cannata—it doesn't just sound like a studio recording. It sounds like a smoky room in 1977. It sounds like regret and Chianti.
Why Brenda and Eddie Still Hurt
We all know a Brenda and Eddie.
They were the king and queen of the prom. They had the "it" factor. In the song, they get married too young, buy a waterbed, and then realize that "money was tight" and "the luck that they had was beginning to fade."
It’s a brutal look at the American Dream crashing into the 1970s recession.
- They got a painting from Sears.
- They fought over the bills.
- They "parted ways" by the end of the summer.
The "bottle of red, bottle of white" serves as the bookends. We start with the excitement of a reunion and end with the bittersweet realization that you can't go back. The tempo slows down, the piano returns to that familiar, strolling rhythm, and we’re left with the bill.
✨ Don't miss: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
Technical Mastery in the Studio
Recording this wasn't easy.
Keep in mind, this was before digital editing. You couldn't just "snap to grid" or fix the timing with a mouse click. The band had to play through those tempo shifts live. When the song kicks into the upbeat "things are okay with me these days" section, the energy shift is palpable because it was a physical performance.
Richie Cannata’s sax solo wasn't meticulously planned out for weeks. It was about feel. He brought that New York street energy that Billy craved.
The lyrics are dense, too. Joel is a master of internal rhyme. "A box of Ritz and a bottle of wine / A little bit of more than I can buy." It rolls off the tongue. It’s conversational. It feels like something a guy at the end of the bar would actually say to you.
The Misconceptions About the Wine
There is a funny bit of trivia often discussed in wine circles regarding this lyric.
In the 70s, "Italian Restaurant" wine in New York usually meant one thing: Bolla. Or maybe a straw-covered bottle of Chianti. It wasn't the era of high-end sommelier culture in the neighborhood spots. When Billy sings about "a bottle of rose instead," he's signaling a specific type of casual, easy-drinking culture.
It’s a "working man’s" wine selection.
Some people have tried to over-analyze the "rose" line as a metaphor for a "rosy" outlook on the past. Honestly? It's probably just because "instead" rhymes with "red." Billy has always been a craftsman first. He picks the word that fits the rhythm and the rhyme before he worries about deep philosophical symbolism.
🔗 Read more: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
Cultural Legacy of the Lyric
The "bottle of red, bottle of white" line has become shorthand for a specific kind of nostalgia. It’s been referenced in sitcoms, covered by Broadway stars, and remains a staple of Billy’s live shows.
Interestingly, Billy Joel didn't think it would be a hit.
At over seven minutes, it was way too long for Top 40 radio in 1977. Most stations wanted three-minute pop songs. But the fans didn't care. They requested it so much that it became a permanent fixture of FM rock radio. It proved that audiences had an appetite for complex storytelling, as long as the hook was strong enough.
And that hook is ironclad.
How to Listen Like a Pro
If you want to truly appreciate the billy joel bottle of red bottle of white experience, you have to listen to the vinyl version or a high-fidelity lossless stream.
The way the drums (played by Liberty DeVitto) kick in during the transition is a masterclass in dynamic range. You can hear the room. You can hear the "scenes."
- The Intro: Pay attention to the piano. It’s light, almost hesitant, like someone walking into a restaurant and looking for a familiar face.
- The Transition: Listen for the "drip" of the piano notes right before the tempo explodes.
- The Middle: This is where the storytelling peaks. Notice how the music gets more frantic as Brenda and Eddie’s marriage falls apart.
- The Outro: The return of the sax. It’s mournful this time. It’s the sound of the lights being turned off.
Actionable Insights for the Billy Joel Fan
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the world of The Stranger and the stories behind these lyrics, here is how you can actually engage with the history:
- Visit the Site: While Fontana di Trevi is gone, you can still visit 151 West 57th Street. Stand across from Carnegie Hall and imagine the New York of 1977. It helps the song's geography click into place.
- Listen to the "Live at Carnegie Hall 1977" Recording: There is a raw energy in the live versions from that era that exceeds the studio track. You can hear Billy explaining the "scenes" to the audience in real-time.
- Pair the Music: Do what the song says. Buy a bottle of Italian red (a Chianti Classico is the move here) and listen to the full album from start to finish. Don't skip tracks. The Stranger is designed to be a cohesive experience.
- Study the Lyrics: Look at the way Joel uses "Binnie." It’s a real name, but it’s also a placeholder for the listener. We are Binnie. We are the ones sitting across from him, drinking the wine, and listening to the stories of people we used to know.
The song works because it’s honest. It doesn't pretend that Brenda and Eddie lived happily ever after. It acknowledges that sometimes, the "king and the queen" end up just being two people who couldn't make it work.
But as long as there's a bottle of red and a bottle of white, we can at least talk about it.