If you tuned into HBO or Max expecting a typical, glossy rock-star victory lap, you probably felt a bit of a gut punch during the credits. Billy Joel And So It Goes Part 2 isn't exactly the "Piano Man" singalong fans were promised. It’s heavy. It’s raw. Honestly, it’s kinda heartbreaking in a way that most music documentaries are too scared to be.
While Part 1 focused on the meteoric rise—the leather jackets, the Christie Brinkley era, and the hits that defined the '70s—the second installment takes a sharp turn into the shadows. We’re talking about the grit of the Nylon Curtain years, the crushing weight of lawsuits, and the health scares that have dominated the headlines recently. If you’re looking for a simple "where are they now," this isn't it. This is a deep look at why a man who has everything still feels like life is a fight.
The Trauma Nobody Expected in Billy Joel And So It Goes Part 2
Most fans know about the motorcycle accident or the high-profile divorces. But the documentary really digs into the psychological toll of his later career. There’s a specific sequence where Joel talks about his father, Howard Joel. Seeing Billy recount their "complicated" reunion is tough. It’s not just a footnote; it’s a central theme. The film suggests that much of Billy’s drive—and his eventual burnout—stemmed from trying to reconcile with a ghost.
👉 See also: Why Movies With Natalie Portman Still Matter in 2026
Critics and fans on Reddit have been divided. Some felt it was "too much" trauma and not enough music. But that’s the point, isn't it? You can’t have The Stranger without the guy who feels like a stranger in his own life. The director, Susan Lacy, clearly wasn't interested in making a PR piece. She treats Joel like an unreliable narrator at times, which is a bold move for a sanctioned biography.
- The Father Dynamic: The secret Jewish history of his family and how they escaped Nazi Germany is explored with more depth here than in any previous interview.
- The "Bad Blood" with Elton: We finally get the real story behind Elton John’s "tough love" rehab comments. Joel admits it was rock bottom, but there’s still a bit of a defensive edge when he talks about it.
- The Missing Hits: Some fans were annoyed that "Turn the Lights Back On"—his big 2024 comeback—was barely mentioned. It felt like the filmmakers wanted to stick to the "end of the residency" narrative rather than the new beginning.
Why the Ending Left Everyone Confused
The conclusion of Billy Joel And So It Goes Part 2 is a bit of a head-scratcher. It ends with the 100th Madison Square Garden residency show and a performance of "Piano Man." Roll credits.
Wait, what about the brain disorder?
In real life, 2025 was a brutal year for Billy. He was diagnosed with Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus (NPH), a condition that affects balance and cognitive function. It’s the reason he cancelled his tour and why he was notably absent from the Tribeca premiere of the film. The documentary touches on his health, but it doesn't give you that definitive "he's okay" moment.
💡 You might also like: Craig Anton Movies and TV Shows: Why the Phil of the Future Dad is Everywhere
His booking agent, Dennis Arfa, recently told HITS Magazine that Billy is doing his physical therapy and "hopefully" will return to the stage in 2026. But the film leaves things much more ambiguous. It’s bittersweet. It’s like the song the movie is named after—nothing is permanent, and everything is sort of fading away.
The 155-Track Rabbit Hole
If you finished the doc and felt like you missed the music, Sony dropped a massive digital companion. It’s 155 songs long. Yeah, you read that right. It includes archival stuff that actually explains the "Part 2" era better than the talking heads do.
- "December Theme": An unreleased gem from the Cold Spring Harbor sessions.
- "Tomorrow Is Today (2025 Mix)": A fresh take on one of his darkest songs, which feels eerie given his recent health battles.
- "Scenes From An Italian Restaurant (Live at CW Post)": The first-ever recorded performance of the classic. It's raw and imperfect, just like the man himself.
What Really Happened with the Lawsuits?
One thing the film doesn't shy away from—though Billy gets pretty defensive—is the financial betrayal. Most people forget that Billy Joel was essentially broke at the height of his fame because of his former manager (and ex-brother-in-law) Frank Weber.
Part 2 details the "litigation years." It’s not sexy. It’s lawyers and ledgers. But seeing Billy talk about how he had to tour just to stay afloat changes how you hear those 80s hits. He wasn't just playing for the fans; he was playing for his life. Honestly, it makes the "angry young man" persona feel a lot more justified.
🔗 Read more: Sean Milliken from My 600 lb Life: What Really Happened to One of the Show’s Most Tragic Figures
The Takeaway for Fans
If you haven't seen it yet, prepare for a version of Billy Joel that isn't the wisecracking Long Island guy. He’s older, he’s tired, and he’s remarkably honest about his mistakes.
Next Steps for the Ultimate Experience:
- Watch the Documentary on Max: Specifically, pay attention to the transition between the An Innocent Man era and The Nylon Curtain. It’s where the mask starts to slip.
- Listen to the Digital Companion: Skip the hits you know. Find the "Shelter Island Sessions" tracks. They show the creative process in a way the film only hints at.
- Check the 2026 Tour Schedule: If you’re in Toronto or Pittsburgh, those rescheduled dates are finally coming up. Just keep an eye on official updates, as his recovery from NPH is still the main priority.
The film proves that even if the "lights go out" on his touring career, the music has a life of its own. It’s a messy, complicated legacy, but it’s real. And in a world of fake AI-generated pop stars, that's basically all we can ask for.