Football in January is usually cold. But the 2024 AFC Wild Card matchup between the Buffalo Bills and the Pittsburgh Steelers was something else entirely. It wasn't just a game; it was a logistics nightmare turned into a highlight reel. Honestly, if you weren't following the weather reports that week, you missed half the drama before the first whistle even blew.
Snow. Feet of it.
The game was originally supposed to happen on a Sunday, but Mother Nature had other plans. New York Governor Kathy Hochul basically looked at the lake-effect blizzard heading toward Orchard Park and said, "Nope." She instituted a travel ban. The NFL had to push the kickoff back by 27.5 hours. It was the kind of storm where the Bills actually had to put out a public call for fans to come help shovel snow for $20 an hour. You’ve probably seen the videos—thousands of people in parkas, tossing white powder over their shoulders just so the bleachers would be visible.
The Josh Allen Show (and That Unreal Run)
When they finally took the field on Monday, January 15, the Bills vs steelers playoffs narrative shifted from the weather to the sheer talent of Josh Allen. He didn't just play; he dominated. Buffalo started hot, and they stayed hot, even while the air was freezing.
Allen finished 21-of-30 for 203 yards and three touchdowns through the air. But stats don't tell the story of the 52-yard run. It was a third-and-8 situation in the second quarter. Allen dropped back, saw a lane, and just... went. People were screaming for him to slide. He didn't. He shook off a tackle from Damontae Kazee and outran the rest of the Pittsburgh secondary to put Buffalo up 21-0.
"It’s almost normal now. Him making a crazy play like that almost every single game." — Bills TE Dawson Knox
🔗 Read more: Cowboys Score: Why Dallas Just Can't Finish the Job When it Matters
That run was the second-longest rushing touchdown by a quarterback in NFL playoff history. Only Colin Kaepernick has a longer one. It also set a new record for the longest postseason rush in Bills history. It’s the kind of play that reminds you why some guys are paid $250 million.
Why the Steelers Couldn't Keep Up
Mason Rudolph was under center for the Steelers, making his first-ever playoff start. Honestly, he wasn't terrible. He threw for 229 yards and two scores. But you can't turn the ball over twice in the first half against a team like Buffalo.
The Steelers’ defense was missing T.J. Watt. That’s a massive hole. Without the NFL’s sack leader, the pass rush just didn't have that "it" factor to keep Allen contained. Pittsburgh fought back, though. They cut the lead to 24-17 in the fourth quarter after a Calvin Austin touchdown. For a second there, Highmark Stadium got real quiet.
A History of One-Sided Streaks
If you look at the all-time history of the Bills vs steelers playoffs, it’s a weirdly streaky rivalry. Pittsburgh still leads the overall series 20-14, but Buffalo has been the bully lately. They’ve won four of the last five meetings.
Before this 2024 clash, the two teams hadn't met in the postseason since the 1995-96 season. Back then, it was Bill Cowher’s Steelers beating Jim Kelly’s Bills 40-21. It’s funny how the roles have flipped. Back in the 90s, Pittsburgh had the "Steel Curtain" and Buffalo had the "K-Gun" offense. Now, Buffalo is the one with the high-octane superstar QB, and Pittsburgh is the one trying to find their identity after the Big Ben era.
💡 You might also like: Jake Paul Mike Tyson Tattoo: What Most People Get Wrong
The Khalil Shakir "Magic" Play
We have to talk about Khalil Shakir.
Late in the fourth quarter, the game was still technically in reach for Pittsburgh. Allen threw a quick slant to Shakir. Minkah Fitzpatrick—one of the best safeties in the league—met him right at the catch point. Most receivers go down there.
Shakir didn't.
He absorbed the hit, spun like a top, and somehow stayed on his feet to sprint into the end zone for a 17-yard score. It was the dagger. It was also a perfect example of why the Bills' offense is so hard to stop when their secondary options are making plays like that.
Key Stats from the 31-17 Victory
- Total Yards: Bills 368, Steelers 324.
- Rushing Yards: Buffalo put up 179 on the ground, nearly doubling Pittsburgh’s 106.
- Third Down Efficiency: The Bills were 7-of-13; the Steelers were 8-of-15.
- Turnovers: 2-0 in favor of Buffalo.
The turnover margin was basically the game. Taron Johnson forced a George Pickens fumble early on, and Kaiir Elam snagged an interception in the end zone that killed a promising Steelers drive. When you give Josh Allen extra possessions, you’re basically asking for a loss.
📖 Related: What Place Is The Phillies In: The Real Story Behind the NL East Standings
What Most Fans Get Wrong About This Matchup
There’s a common misconception that the weather "helped" the Bills. People think because they live in Buffalo, they love playing in 15-degree weather with 30 mph winds.
Actually, the Bills’ offense is built on speed and deep passing. High winds are usually an equalizer that helps the team with the better run game—which is often the Steelers. In fact, if the game had been played on Sunday during the whiteout, Pittsburgh might have had a better chance to turn it into a muddy, low-scoring brawl. By Monday, the skies had cleared. The "blue sky" cold favored Allen’s arm.
Actionable Insights for the Next Matchup
If you're betting on or analyzing a future Bills vs Steelers game, keep these things in mind:
- Monitor the Turnover Margin: In their last several meetings, the winner has almost always won the turnover battle. The Bills' defense is coached to be aggressive, which works against younger or less experienced QBs.
- The "Watt" Factor: Pittsburgh is a different team without T.J. Watt. If he’s sidelined, their ability to disguise coverages drops significantly because they can't rely on a 4-man rush.
- Home Field Advantage is Real: Highmark Stadium is one of the most difficult places to play in January. It's not just the temperature; it's the swirling winds off Lake Erie that can make a 40-yard field goal feel like a 60-yarder.
The 2024 playoff game proved that while the Steelers are resilient under Mike Tomlin, they are still a few pieces away from competing with the elite quarterbacks of the AFC. Buffalo, meanwhile, continues to be a juggernaut that just can't seem to get past the "Chiefs" hurdle, which is exactly where they headed after this win.
To prepare for future matchups, fans should watch how the Steelers address their quarterback room and whether the Bills can find a consistent secondary run threat to take the pressure off Allen. Keeping an eye on the injury report—specifically in the linebacker corps—is usually the best indicator of how these physical games will go.