You know that feeling when you catch a whiff of something so cozy it basically feels like a cashmere blanket? That's the Eilish No. 1 effect. When Billie dropped her first fragrance in that iconic gold bust bottle, the internet collectively lost its mind. It’s a thick, syrupy, "I want to eat my own arm" kind of gourmand. But honestly, $60 to $75 for a bottle isn't always in the budget, especially if you're spraying it like it's oxygen.
People are constantly hunting for Billie Eilish perfume dupes because, let’s be real, we want the vibe without the price tag. But here’s the thing: most "dupe" lists are just guessing. They see "vanilla" on a label and assume it’s a match. It’s not. Finding a true alternative to Billie's scents—whether it’s the original cocoa-vanilla, the woody No. 2, or the limited No. 3—requires a bit more nuance.
I’ve smelled my way through a dozen "inspired" bottles to see which ones actually hold up in 2026. Some are 1:1 clones, while others are just... weirdly minty?
The Best Alternatives for Eilish No. 1 (The Gold Bottle)
The original Eilish is all about sugared petals, cocoa, and creamy vanilla. It has this "skin-like" musk at the base that makes it smell expensive rather than just like a cupcake.
📖 Related: Not to Scale Meaning: Why Those Tiny Drawing Labels Actually Save Lives
1. Lattafa Nebras (The "Gold Standard" Clone)
If you want the closest possible match, stop looking. Nebras by Lattafa is it. I'm not even exaggerating.
It’s an Arabian perfume that often retails for around $30-$40, and the performance is actually better than the original.
Nebras adds a slight red berry note at the top that makes it feel a bit juicier, but the dry down is almost indistinguishable from Eilish. It’s got that heavy, lactonic (milky) chocolate-vanilla heart.
Pro tip: Let this bottle sit in a dark drawer for a week or two after you first spray it. Arabian perfumes often need to "macerate" to reach their full potential.
2. Fine’ry Sweet on the Outside
You can find this at Target for about $15.
Is it a 100% match? No. It’s a bit lighter and more "smoky" than Billie’s version.
However, for the price of a Chipotle bowl, it’s the best budget option for everyday wear. It captures the tonka bean and cacao vibe perfectly without the heavy price tag.
3. Bath & Body Works Viva Vanilla
This one came out as part of their "Everyday Luxuries" line. It’s a body mist, so don't expect it to last eight hours, but the scent profile is a dead ringer for the woody-vanilla sweetness of Eilish.
Cracking the Code on Eilish No. 2 Dupes
No. 2 is the "dark" sibling. It’s moody. It’s rainy. It’s got palo santo, ebony wood, and black pepper. It’s much harder to dupe because those woody notes can easily smell like pencil shavings if done cheaply.
- Dua Brand "Bill-Ish 2": This is a niche clone house that specifically replicates high-end scents. Their version of No. 2 is an extrait de parfum, meaning it’s super concentrated.
- The "Vibe" Alternatives: If you can’t find a direct clone, 7 Virtues Santal Vanille hits a very similar note. It’s not a dupe, but it lives in the same house. It’s woody, spicy, and just a little bit sweet.
- Snif Sweet Ash: This is a cult favorite. It has that same low-key, unisex, "cool person" energy that No. 2 carries.
What About Eilish No. 3?
No. 3 was the limited edition red bottle. It’s a lot more "red" and "spicy" with a heavy dose of saffron.
Honestly? It’s hard to find a cheap dupe for this one because saffron is an expensive ingredient.
However, a lot of people in the fragrance community point toward Snif Sweet Ash or even layering a basic vanilla with a saffron-heavy scent like Lattafa Pride Vintage Radio to get that same medicinal-but-sweet kick.
Why Some Dupes Fail (And How to Fix It)
Ever buy a dupe and think, "This smells like chemicals"?
It happens.
The main issue with cheap Billie Eilish perfume dupes is the "opening." The first five minutes of a cheap perfume are usually just alcohol and synthetic citrus.
The Fix: Spray your clothes, not just your skin.
Synthetic notes often react weirdly with skin chemistry. Fabric holds onto the "heart" and "base" notes longer, which is where the Billie-inspired magic actually lives.
Also, look for Tonka Bean and Cacao in the notes list.
Many "vanilla" perfumes are too floral. Billie's scents are gourmand-heavy, meaning they need to smell edible. If you see jasmine or lily as a main note, it’s probably not the dupe you’re looking for.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Fragrance Hunt
If you're ready to save some cash but still want to smell like a warm vanilla dream, here is exactly what you should do:
- Check Amazon or Jomashop for Lattafa Nebras. It is the most consistent and highest-quality clone of the original gold bottle. Usually, it's under $35.
- Head to Target and test Fine’ry Sweet on the Outside. Spray it on your wrist, walk around the store for 20 minutes, and see how it smells once the alcohol evaporates.
- Layer your scents. If you have a cheap vanilla body mist, layer it over a woody lotion (like EOS Vanilla Cashmere). This mimics the "complex" depth of Billie's perfumes for a fraction of the cost.
- Buy a travel size first. If you’re eyeing a clone house like Dua or Miim.Miic, don't buy the full bottle immediately. Get the 10ml to see if it actually works with your skin.
Remember, fragrance is subjective. What smells like Eilish to me might smell like a candle to you. But if you start with Nebras or the Fine'ry mist, you're already 90% of the way to that signature Billie scent profile.