You probably remember the memes. The chin. The screaming matches with Tom Brady on the sidelines. But mostly, you remember that trade. You know the one—where DeAndre Hopkins, arguably the best receiver in football, was shipped off to Arizona for a running back who was clearly past his prime and a handful of picks that felt like pocket change.
That single move became the defining image of the Bill O’Brien Texans era. It was the moment the city of Houston collectively threw its hands up. But if you think the story is just about one bad trade or a guy who couldn't handle the "GM" title, you're missing the weird, complicated reality of what actually happened at NRG Stadium between 2014 and 2020.
Honestly, it wasn't all a disaster. That’s the part people forget.
The Winning That Nobody Talks About
Before the wheels came off in spectacular fashion, Bill O’Brien was actually winning games. A lot of them.
He took over a 2-14 dumpster fire from Gary Kubiak and immediately went 9-7. He did that with Ryan Fitzpatrick, Case Keenum, and Ryan Mallett. Think about that for a second. Most coaches would have been picking in the top five again with that QB room, but O’Brien squeezed out a winning record.
He ended up winning the AFC South four times in five years. People like to joke that the AFC South was the "trash division" back then, and yeah, it wasn't exactly the gauntlet of the AFC North today. But you still have to win the games.
📖 Related: MLB Home Run Leaders: Why Giancarlo Stanton and Aaron Judge Still Matter
- 2015: 9-7 (1st in AFC South)
- 2016: 9-7 (1st in AFC South)
- 2018: 11-5 (1st in AFC South)
- 2019: 10-6 (1st in AFC South)
He was a "quarterback whisperer" who actually struggled to find a quarterback until Deshaun Watson fell into his lap in 2017. Before Watson, it was a revolving door of mediocrity: Brian Hoyer, Brock Osweiler, Tom Savage. It's almost impressive he made the playoffs with Osweiler, considering that $72 million contract was basically an anchor around the franchise's neck from day one.
The Power Struggle and the "Chin"
The real downfall of the Bill O’Brien Texans wasn't just X's and O's. It was the "Game of Thrones" stuff happening behind the scenes.
O’Brien had a reputation for being... let's say, combustible. He was a Bill Belichick disciple, but he lacked the rings to make the "my way or the highway" attitude work long-term with star players. He eventually won a massive power struggle that saw longtime GM Rick Smith leave and later, Brian Gaine get fired after just one season.
By 2020, O’Brien was everything. He was the Head Coach. He was the General Manager. He was the de facto king of the building.
That’s when things got truly bizarre.
Most people point to the Hopkins trade as the beginning of the end, but it started with the Jadeveon Clowney situation. O’Brien didn't value Clowney the way the rest of the league did. He traded a former #1 overall pick to Seattle for a third-rounder and some rotational linebackers. It was a pennies-on-the-dollar move that signaled O’Brien cared more about "culture" and "fit" than raw, game-breaking talent.
The Laremy Tunsil "Blank Check"
Then came the Laremy Tunsil trade. Desperate to protect Watson, O'Brien sent two first-round picks and a second-rounder to Miami.
The problem? He didn't have a contract extension worked out before the trade.
Tunsil, knowing the Texans had just given up their entire future for him, basically had the team over a barrel. He became his own agent and negotiated a record-breaking deal because O'Brien had zero leverage. It was a classic example of a coach thinking like a coach (I need a tackle now) while failing as a GM (I just destroyed our cap and draft capital).
Why It Finally Collapsed
The end didn't come because of one loss. It came because of a 24-0 lead.
In the 2019 playoffs against the Kansas City Chiefs, the Texans were up three touchdowns in the first quarter. They were embarrassing Patrick Mahomes. And then, O’Brien started coaching "scared." A fake punt on his own side of the field failed. A field goal on 4th-and-short when he could have buried the Chiefs.
They didn't just lose that game; they gave up 51 points.
The locker room never really recovered. When you trade away a locker room leader like Hopkins because of a personality clash and then start the next season 0-4, you’re done. J.J. Watt—the face of the franchise—basically admitted as much after a Week 4 loss to the Vikings in 2020.
🔗 Read more: Murray State Women's Basketball Schedule: Why This Season Feels Different
Cal McNair finally pulled the plug on October 5, 2020.
The Nuance of the Legacy
Is Bill O'Brien a "bad" coach?
Probably not. He’s back in the college ranks now at Boston College, and he had successful stints at Penn State and as Alabama's OC. The guy knows football. But the Bill O’Brien Texans story is a cautionary tale about ego and organizational structure.
You can't be the guy who negotiates a player's salary on Monday and then expects that same player to run through a wall for you on Sunday. Those two roles—the "bad cop" GM and the "leader of men" coach—are almost impossible for one person to balance.
Lessons From the O'Brien Era
If you're a fan of a team looking to give their coach "total control," look at Houston first.
- Talent vs. Culture: You need "culture guys," but you can't win in the NFL without superstars. Trading away Hall of Fame talent (Hopkins) for "system fits" is a recipe for a 4-12 season.
- Leverage is Everything: Whether it's the Tunsil trade or the Clowney exit, O'Brien consistently negotiated from a position of weakness. A good GM knows when to walk away.
- The Belichick Trap: Just because you worked for Bill Belichick doesn't mean you are him. The "Patriot Way" only works when you have the greatest quarterback of all time and a decade of winning to back up the discipline.
The Texans are finally in a new era with DeMeco Ryans and C.J. Stroud, and honestly, the vibes are the best they've been in a decade. But the scars of the O'Brien years—the missing draft picks, the fractured relationships—took years to heal.
✨ Don't miss: Iowa Football Game Tonight: What Most People Get Wrong
To really understand where the Texans are now, you have to look back at that 0-4 start in 2020. It wasn't just a bad month. It was the collapse of a kingdom built on a single man's belief that he could do everything himself.
Actionable Insight: When evaluating your own team's front office, look for the "silo" effect. If the head coach has no one to tell him "no" on personnel moves, the franchise is one bad trade away from a five-year rebuild. Check if your team has a clear separation between the person coaching the players and the person writing the checks.