Bigger Blacker Box Secret Cards: What Most People Get Wrong

You’ve probably got that massive, matte-black slab of cardboard sitting on your shelf right now. It’s heavy. It’s imposing. It smells faintly of satire and poor life choices. But if you’re like most people, you bought the Bigger Blacker Box secret cards just to have a place to dump your 1,500 expansion cards and never thought about it again.

That's a mistake. A massive, $15 mistake.

Honestly, the Cards Against Humanity team has a long history of hiding things in plain sight. They sold actual bull excrement for Black Friday. They dug a "Holiday Hole" for no reason. So, why would you think their storage solution was just... a box? It’s not. There are literally cards built into the physical structure of the thing, and if you haven't taken a box cutter to your expensive storage case yet, you're missing out on the rarest cards in your collection.

Finding the Bigger Blacker Box secret cards without ruining everything

Most people think there’s just one card. They’re wrong. Depending on which version of the box you own—the original long, thin one or the newer, rectangular "Boks" style—you might be sitting on a goldmine of offensive humor.

The Lid Card (Version 1 and 2)

This is the "classic" secret. If you run your hand along the inside of the top lid, right in the center, you'll feel a slight rectangular bump. That isn’t a manufacturing defect. It’s a card.

To get it out, you have to be brave. You basically need to take an X-Acto knife or a sharp kitchen blade and carefully slice through the thin black paper lining. Don't go too deep; you don't want to scar the card itself. Inside, you’ll find a shiny, silver-foiled white card that reads: "The Biggest, Blackest Dick." It’s a legendary pull. It’s arguably the most powerful card in the game because, well, it’s a silver-foiled card about a giant appendage.

The Bottom Card (The Second Edition Surprise)

If you have the newer version of the box (the one with multiple rows, released around 2015-2016), there is a second hidden card. This one is way harder to find because it’s tucked under the paper lining in the bottom of the box, specifically in the middle row.

Most people miss this one. They think the lid card was the only one and stop there. But if you feel the floor of that middle compartment, there’s another bump. Slice it open, and you’ll find a second silver-foil card: "A dick so big and so black that it is a problematic stereotype." It's a mouthful. It's awkward. It’s peak CAH.

The "Unique" Card: The one you probably threw away

Wait, there's more. Beyond the hidden Bigger Blacker Box secret cards buried in the cardboard, the newer boxes came with a yellowish envelope. Inside that envelope was a "procedurally-generated" card.

This means your card is literally the only one in existence. The CAH team used an algorithm to mash together words and phrases to create 1-of-1 cards for every single box sold. Some are hilarious. Some make absolutely no sense. I've seen cards about "A huge dragon with history's greatest clitoris" and "A regular priest with an inspiring scrotum."

If you lost that envelope during a move, you’ve lost a piece of gaming history that can never be replaced. No two are the same.

Why people are still tearing their boxes apart in 2026

You’d think after a decade, everyone would know this. But every week on Reddit or Discord, someone "discovers" a bump in their box and freaks out. The 2026 market for "pristine" Bigger Blacker Boxes is actually kinda weird—collectors want the box, but they also want the cards.

Here is the thing: a box with the cards still "inside" the lining is technically worth more to a certain type of nerd, but you can't play with them if they're stuck in the lid. Most players choose violence. They cut the box.

📖 Related: Gerudo Town: Why It Is Still the Most Interesting Spot in Breath of the Wild

Tips for a "Clean" Extraction

• Use a flashlight: Shine it at an angle across the paper. The shadow will show you exactly where the card edges are.
• Don't rip: Use a blade. If you rip the paper, it looks like a raccoon attacked your game.
• Tape it back: Some people use black electrical tape to cover the "surgical site" afterward. It blends in surprisingly well.

Is it actually worth the effort?

Look, if you're a casual player who only brings the game out when you're three drinks deep on New Year's Eve, maybe you don't care. But for the completionists, these cards are the "holy grail." They aren't included in the 100th Anniversary Edition or the newer "Boks" (which has its own, different secrets).

The Bigger Blacker Box secret cards are a relic of an era when CAH was at its most chaotic. They wanted you to destroy the thing you just bought. They wanted to see if you were paying attention.

If you haven't checked your box yet, go do it. Right now. Seriously. Run your thumb across the inside of that lid. If you feel that 2.5-by-3.5-inch bump, you’ve got work to do. Just be careful with the knife. No one wants "A trip to the ER for a thumb reattachment" to be the next card you play.

Actionable Steps for Box Owners

1. Identify your version: If it's a single long row, you have one hidden card (Lid). If it's a wide box with multiple rows, you likely have two (Lid and Bottom Floor).
2. The Touch Test: Firmly press the center of the inner lid. If it's perfectly flat, you might have a rare "dud" or a counterfeit, but 99% of genuine BBBs have the card.
3. Perform Surgery: Use a precision craft knife to make a 1-inch slit. Slide the card out. Do not try to peel the whole paper layer off, as it's glued heavily at the edges and will ruin the structural integrity of the box.
4. Check the envelope: If you still have the original packaging, find the small yellow envelope. That unique card is your "social security number" in the CAH world. Protect it.