Look, if you’ve spent more than five minutes in the Friday Night Funkin’ (FNF) rabbit hole, you know the deal. You can’t escape it. One second you’re looking for a tutorial on how to hit the double notes in "M.I.L.F.," and the next, your feed is plastered with fan art of a blue-haired kid and a ginger mercenary with an Uzi. It’s the ship that launched a thousand mods. BF x Pico. Or "Picofridge." Or "Boyfrico." Whatever the kids are calling it these days.
But honestly? If you take a step back and actually look at the "lore" (if we can even call it that), the whole thing feels... well, kinda dumb.
I know, I know. Calm down. Before you come for my head with a microphone, let's talk about why people actually think bf x pico is dumb and why, despite the logic gaps, the developers leaned into it anyway. It’s a weird saga of Newgrounds nostalgia, developer trolling, and a fandom that took a joke and ran across a marathon finish line with it.
The "Exes" Logic: Wait, When Did They Even Date?
The core of the BF x Pico ship—and the reason people find it so baffling—is the "Ex-Boyfriend" reveal.
Back in the early days of FNF, specifically around Week 3, the community started headcanoning that Pico and Boyfriend had a history. Why? Mostly because Pico was hired by Daddy Dearest to kill Boyfriend but decided to... rap instead. People figured, "Hey, maybe they have history?"
Then, the lead dev, ninjamuffin99, dropped the bomb on Twitter. He confirmed they were exes.
But here’s the thing: ninjamuffin99 is the king of "Yes-And" trolling. For months, it was unclear if this was a legitimate piece of world-building or just a developer having a laugh at his fans' expense. Eventually, it was cemented as canon. Pico and Boyfriend are canonically former lovers.
Is it actually dumb? Sorta.
👉 See also: What Can You Get From Fishing Minecraft: Why It Is More Than Just Cod
Think about the timeline. Pico is a character from 1999. He’s a survivor of a school shooting (the original Pico’s School is... dark, to say the least). Boyfriend is a modern-day rhythm game protagonist who communicates in "beep boops." Putting them together feels like a crossover fanfiction from 2005 that someone accidentally turned into a real game. It’s tonally jarring. One guy is a traumatized mercenary; the other is a guy who would probably try to rap battle a natural disaster rather than run away.
Why the BF x Pico Relationship Dynamic Breaks the Game
If you look at the actual gameplay of Friday Night Funkin', the entire premise is built on Boyfriend’s unwavering, borderline obsessive devotion to Girlfriend.
The game literally doesn't happen without their relationship. He’s fighting her dad, her mom, a lemon-headed monster, and a literal spirit in a video game just to hold her hand. Then suddenly, enter Pico.
When people say bf x pico is dumb, they’re usually pointing at the narrative whiplash. If Boyfriend is so head-over-heels for GF that he’s willing to face death every Friday night, how does a random ex-boyfriend fit into that?
The Jealousy Factor (Or Lack Thereof)
In Week 7, Pico literally shows up to save the day. He drops in, guns blazing, to protect Boyfriend and Girlfriend from Tankman’s army.
If they’re exes, where is the drama? Where is the tension?
- Pico is protecting his ex’s new girl.
- Girlfriend doesn't seem to care that her man’s former flame is her bodyguard.
- Boyfriend is just vibing.
Honestly, it makes everyone in the game look like they have the emotional complexity of a goldfish. But maybe that’s the point. FNF isn't exactly The Last of Us. It’s a game about clicking arrows. Maybe expecting a deep, nuanced exploration of a past queer relationship in a game where you fight a floating head in a mall is the "dumb" part.
✨ Don't miss: Free games free online: Why we're still obsessed with browser gaming in 2026
The "Pico's School" Connection
We have to talk about Tom Fulp. He’s the creator of Pico and the founder of Newgrounds. When the BF x Pico ship started gaining steam, even Tom Fulp got in on the action. He released an "update" to the original Pico’s School for April Fools’ Day (Pico’s School: Love Conquers All) where the whole massacre is avoided because Pico and Boyfriend are dating.
It was a joke. A literal April Fools' prank.
But the fandom? They didn't see a prank. They saw validation.
This is where the "dumb" argument really gains legs. Much of the "canon" evidence for this relationship comes from jokes, memes, and "what if" scenarios. When you build a ship on a foundation of irony, it’s going to feel a bit hollow to the people who actually care about cohesive storytelling.
Pico's character has always been about edgy, 90s-era grit. Seeing him reduced to "the tsundere ex-boyfriend" in thousands of TikTok edits is a massive departure from his roots. For old-school Newgrounds fans, it feels like watching a gritty reboot of a classic character turn into a soft-boy caricature.
Why It Works (Despite Being Ridiculous)
Alright, I've spent a lot of time calling it dumb. But I have to admit: there’s a reason it stuck.
The "rivals to lovers" (or in this case, "exes to allies") trope is like catnip for the internet. It adds a layer of history to a world that is otherwise very thin on plot. It gives Pico a reason to be there other than "I was hired to kill you but I'm too cool for that."
🔗 Read more: Catching the Blue Marlin in Animal Crossing: Why This Giant Fish Is So Hard to Find
Plus, it makes the world feel smaller and more connected. In the Newgrounds universe, everyone knows everyone. Having Pico and Boyfriend be exes bridges the gap between the "old" Newgrounds (1999) and the "new" era of FNF (2020s).
Real Talk: Is It Just Shipping Fatigue?
A lot of the "bf x pico is dumb" sentiment actually comes from people who are just tired of the fandom. FNF has a notoriously loud, young, and sometimes aggressive community. When a specific ship dominates the conversation to the point where you can’t discuss the game’s music or mechanics without seeing "Boyfrico" art, people get annoyed.
It’s not necessarily that the pairing is bad—it’s that it’s everywhere.
The Actionable Truth for FNF Fans
So, where do we actually stand? If you're a fan of the game or just a casual observer, here is how you should actually view the BF x Pico situation:
- Accept the Canon, Ignore the Noise: The devs have said they are exes. It’s officially part of the lore. You don’t have to like it, but it’s there. You can enjoy the game without needing to engage with the shipping side of things.
- Separate Fanon from Fact: Most of what you see on social media—Pico being "protective" or Boyfriend being "sad" about the breakup—is fan-made. In the actual game, they barely interact beyond the music. Keep that perspective so you don't get frustrated by the "dumb" fan interpretations.
- Appreciate the Trolling: Remember that FNF was built on the spirit of Newgrounds. That means it's supposed to be a bit chaotic, a bit irreverent, and very "meta." The devs making this canon was a way to interact with the fans in the most Newgrounds way possible: by making a meme real.
- Focus on the Music: At the end of the day, Week 3 and Week 7 have some of the best tracks in the game. "Pico," "Philly Nice," and "Blammed" are bangers regardless of who Pico used to date.
The whole "BF x Pico" thing is a perfect example of how modern indie games evolve. They aren't just products; they're conversations between creators and fans. Sometimes that conversation results in something brilliant. Sometimes it results in something that feels a little dumb.
But hey, that’s just how the rhythm goes. Whether you ship them or think it's the worst thing to happen to the game, you can't deny that it made Friday Night Funkin' way more interesting than a simple story about a guy and his girlfriend ever would have been.
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the actual game mechanics rather than the romance, your best bet is to spend some time in the "Erect Mode" remixes. They actually challenge your fingers rather than your patience for fandom drama. Stick to the arrows, and the lore becomes much easier to digest.