You’re sitting there, hands gripping a lukewarm soda, watching your best friend place a plastic tile that just ruined your entire night. We’ve all been there. One minute you’re exploring a creepy attic with a priest and a fortune teller, and the next, the "Haunt" begins, and suddenly your buddy is a werewolf trying to rip your throat out. That’s the core magic of Betrayal at House on the Hill. It is chaotic. It is often wildly unbalanced. And honestly, it is one of the most polarizing board games ever designed by Avalon Hill.
The game doesn't care about your feelings. It doesn't care if you spent the last forty minutes gathering items only to lose them all because the dice rolls went sideways. It’s a narrative engine masquerading as a strategy game. If you go into it expecting a perfectly tuned competitive experience like Chess or even Settlers of Catan, you’re going to have a bad time. You have to embrace the mess.
Why the Haunt is the Best (and Worst) Part of the Game
Everything changes when the haunt starts. Up until that point, you’re just wandering around, discovering rooms like the Coal Chute or the Gardens. But once that omen roll fails—boom. The game splits. One person becomes the Traitor. Everyone else becomes the Heroes.
The complexity spike here is legendary. The Traitor has to leave the room, read a secret booklet called the Traitor's Tome, and figure out how their new powers work. Meanwhile, the survivors huddle together over the Secrets of Survival book, whispering about how to kill whatever monster just appeared. It's a frantic, stressful transition. Often, the rules are slightly ambiguous, leading to mid-game arguments that can last longer than the actual combat.
Rob Daviau and the design team at Avalon Hill (and later Wizards of the Coast for the 3rd Edition) built this game to feel like a B-movie horror flick. In those movies, the rules of reality often break. The game reflects that. Sometimes the Traitor is so overpowered it feels like a foregone conclusion. Other times, the Heroes are so geared up with the Spear and the Medkit that the Traitor gets stomped in two turns. It’s swingy.
The Strategy Nobody Tells You About
Most people think Betrayal at House on the Hill is just luck. It's not. Well, it is mostly luck, but you can tilt the odds.
✨ Don't miss: Mass Effect Andromeda Gameplay: Why It’s Actually the Best Combat in the Series
First, stop exploring new rooms once you have a decent hand of items if the haunt roll is getting risky. Every time you draw a card, you're potentially triggering the end of the "peaceful" phase. If you aren't ready, don't open that door. Also, pay attention to your stats. If you're playing as Ox Bellows, you need to be in the gym or the weight room. If you’re Professor Longfellow, stay in the library. Boosting your "Knowledge" or "Might" before the traitor is revealed is the only way to ensure you aren't immediate fodder.
Rooms matter more than you think.
- The Basement: A death trap if you don't have a way out (like the stairs or the elevator).
- The Upper Landing: Great for jumping down to the ground floor in an emergency.
- The Attic: Often holds the best items but leaves you cornered.
When the betrayal happens, the map is your biggest enemy or your best friend. I've seen games won simply because the Traitor was stuck in the basement while the Heroes finished a ritual on the roof. Movement is the most underrated stat in the game. Speed allows you to kite monsters and reach objective rooms before the Traitor can setup their defense.
3rd Edition vs. 2nd Edition: What Changed?
If you’re still playing the 2nd Edition (the one with the green box), you’re dealing with some notorious bugs. Some haunts in that version were literally broken—as in, the win conditions for both sides were mathematically impossible to achieve at the same time.
The 3rd Edition, released a few years back, fixed a lot of this. They introduced "Scenarios." Instead of the haunt being purely random based on which omen you found in which room, you now pick a theme at the start. It gives the narrative more cohesion. They also updated the character miniatures, which—let's be real—were pretty hideous in the older versions. The 3rd Edition also clarified the "Line of Sight" rules, which used to be the primary cause of tabletop divorces.
🔗 Read more: Marvel Rivals Emma Frost X Revolution Skin: What Most People Get Wrong
However, some purists miss the absolute randomness of the older sets. There was something special about finding a "Girl" in the "Larder" and having that turn into a ghost story that made zero sense but was hilarious anyway.
Surmounting the "Rulebook" Hurdle
Let's talk about the elephant in the room: the rulebooks are a lot. You have the base rules, then two separate hidden booklets. If the person who becomes the Traitor is the person who least understands the game, you're in for a long night.
A pro tip for groups? If a brand-new player triggers the haunt and becomes the Traitor, let an experienced player "consult" with them. Yes, it spoils the surprise slightly, but it prevents the game from grinding to a halt because someone didn't understand how their "Wall Walk" ability worked. The goal is fun, not legalistic adherence to the "no talking" rule.
Common Misconceptions About Betrayal
A huge myth is that the Traitor is always the "villain." In a purely mechanical sense, yes. But narratively? Sometimes they are possessed. Sometimes they are just a victim of the house. This matters because some haunts allow the Traitor to be "cured." Don't always assume the only way to win is by killing your friend. Read the victory conditions carefully. I've seen Heroes lose because they focused on combat when they should have been focused on destroying a specific item or room.
Another thing? The "Haunt Roll" isn't a fixed number anymore. In the newer editions, you roll a number of dice equal to the number of omens in play. You only trigger the haunt if you roll a 5 or higher. This means the haunt is almost impossible to trigger in the first few turns, giving everyone time to actually play the game before the betrayal hits.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Right Words That Start With Oc 5 Letters for Your Next Wordle Win
How to Make Your Next Game Session Better
If you want to actually enjoy Betrayal at House on the Hill, you need to set the atmosphere. This isn't a game for a bright, sterile kitchen table with the news playing in the background. Turn the lights down. Put on a "Creepy Horror Ambience" playlist on Spotify. Read the flavor text on the cards out loud with a dramatic voice.
The game is a generator for stories. You won't remember who won the "The Stars Are Right" haunt three years from now, but you will remember the time the little boy character threw a dynamite stick into the basement and accidentally blew up the entire party.
Actionable Steps for Players:
- Audit your character choice: Don't just pick the one that looks cool. Check their starting stats. If your group lacks a "Knowledge" heavy character, someone should fill that gap, or you'll fail every research-based haunt.
- Master the "Item Drop": Remember you can drop items for other players. If the Traitor is coming for the person holding the Holy Symbol, drop it and let the faster player pick it up and run.
- Track the Omens: Keep a mental tally of how many omens are out. Once there are 4 or 5, start positioning yourself near the center of the house so you aren't isolated when the betrayal occurs.
- Use the 3rd Edition if possible: If you're buying the game today, don't hunt for a used 2nd Edition unless you're a collector. The 3rd Edition’s streamlined "Reluctance" mechanics and better-organized booklets make for a much smoother evening.
- House Rule the ambiguities: If a rule doesn't make sense, don't spend 20 minutes on BoardGameGeek. Make a group vote, decide what's "scarier" or "fairer," and keep moving. The momentum of the story is more important than the literal interpretation of a poorly translated 2004 rulebook.
The house is waiting. Just try not to be the one holding the sacrificial dagger when the lights go out.