Board games usually start with high hopes and a shared goal. Everyone's a team. You're exploring this creepy, modular mansion, flipping tiles, and hoping you don't find a basement full of spiders. But then, it happens. The Haunt begins. One of your friends—maybe the one who brought the snacks—suddenly becomes the traitor. This is Betrayal at House on the Hill, a game that is as much about managing your crumbling friendships as it is about rolling dice.
It's chaotic. It's often unbalanced. Honestly, it's one of the most frustrating and brilliant tabletop experiences ever made.
Why Betrayal at House on the Hill is Basically a B-Movie Simulator
The game doesn't care about fair play in the traditional sense. It cares about atmosphere. You spend the first half of the game, the "Exploration Phase," just wandering around. You might find a Bloodstone or a Spear. You might fall through a Collapsed Ceiling and end up in the basement.
Everything changes when the Omens pile up.
Once the Haunt rolls succeed (or fail, depending on how you look at it), the game splits. One person leaves the room to read the Traitor's Tome. The rest of the group huddles over the Secrets of Survival. This specific moment is where the tension peaks. You're left wondering if your friend is currently reading a script that allows them to summon a 50-foot tall blob or if they're just becoming a vampire.
The Mechanics of the Turn
There are 50 different scenarios in the base game. That's a lot of potential outcomes. Because the house is built differently every single time, you might find yourself in a situation where the traitor is trapped in the attic while the survivors are all by the front door. Or, worse, you're all trapped in the same room when the betrayal happens.
The Haunt: Where Things Get Weird
Most people get the rules wrong the first time they play. It's almost a rite of passage. Maybe you forgot that the traitor gets to ignore certain movement penalties, or you didn't realize that a specific item was required to kill the monster.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Every Bubbul Gem: Why the Map of Caves TOTK Actually Matters
Take the "voodoo doll" scenario. If you're the traitor, you're trying to poke holes in the survivors' stats from afar. If you're a survivor, you're frantically searching the house for the doll to stop the madness.
The complexity isn't in the math. It's in the narrative.
Designers Bruce Glassco, Rob Daviau, and the rest of the Avalon Hill team didn't set out to make a tight, competitive strategy game like Chess. They made a story engine. Sometimes the story is a tragedy where the survivors die in two turns. Sometimes it's an epic struggle that lasts two hours.
Stats Matter (Until They Don't)
You have four traits: Might, Speed, Knowledge, and Sanity.
- Might and Speed are your physical traits. You need these for combat.
- Knowledge and Sanity are mental. These are usually for resisting the house's influence.
If any of your stats drop to the skull icon before the Haunt starts, you don't die. You just stay at the lowest possible value. But once that betrayal hits? One bad roll and you're out. Well, unless the Haunt turns you into a ghost.
Common Mistakes That Ruin the Experience
Don't overthink the balance. If you go into Betrayal at House on the Hill expecting a perfectly tuned competitive experience, you're going to have a bad time. The game is swingy. Sometimes the traitor is so overpowered it feels like a joke.
🔗 Read more: Playing A Link to the Past Switch: Why It Still Hits Different Today
The biggest mistake? Not reading the Haunt rules carefully.
Since the two sides read different books, no one person knows all the rules. This leads to "accidental cheating." The traitor might think they can move through walls when they actually can't. The survivors might think they need to find a specific room that isn't even on the board yet.
Pro tip: If a rule seems completely broken, double-check the "Setup" section of your specific Haunt manual. Often, there’s a small detail about placing tokens or moving tiles that changes everything.
Which Edition Should You Actually Play?
The 2nd Edition is the one most people know. It's got those iconic (and slightly annoying) plastic clips for the character cards. Then there's the 3rd Edition, which smoothed out a lot of the clunky mechanics and updated the art style.
If you want the "classic" feel with all the weird quirks, 2nd Edition is the way to go. If you want a more streamlined game that actually fits together properly, get the 3rd Edition. There’s also Betrayal Legacy, which is widely considered one of the best legacy games ever made. It tells a story across generations of families trapped by the house. It's heavy, it's emotional, and the betrayals feel way more personal when it's your great-grandfather doing the stabbing.
The Scooby-Doo Factor
There's even a Betrayal at Mystery Mansion version. It’s shorter, easier, and themed after Scooby-Doo. It’s actually a great way to teach kids the mechanics of betrayal without the "bleeding walls" and "cannibalism" themes of the original.
💡 You might also like: Plants vs Zombies Xbox One: Why Garden Warfare Still Slaps Years Later
Surviving the House: A Tactical Mindset
You can't really "plan" for the Haunt because you don't know what it is. But you can prepare.
- Keep the group somewhat close. If the Haunt starts and you're on the third floor while everyone else is in the basement, you're an easy target.
- Hoard the items. Even if you don't think you need the Madman or the Girl, take them. They provide stat boosts that could save your life later.
- Explore the upper floor. The Attic and the Gallery can be dead ends, but they also hold some of the best items in the game.
- Don't ignore Sanity. A lot of Haunts require Sanity rolls to resist being controlled or damaged. If your Sanity is low, you’re basically a walking liability.
The Social Dynamic of the Traitor
Being the traitor is lonely. You’re sitting there in the other room, frantically reading your win conditions, while you hear your friends laughing and strategizing in the kitchen.
When you walk back in, the vibe has shifted. You aren't "Dave" anymore. You're the "Ancient One's Prophet."
Embrace it. Roleplay a little. The game is much better when the traitor leans into the villainy. If you're just silently moving pieces, it feels like a chore. If you're narrating your descent into madness, it's a memory.
What to Do When the Game Breaks
Sometimes, the game just breaks. You'll get a Haunt that is literally impossible for one side to win because of how the house was built.
In these cases, just house-rule it. If the survivors need to get to the Underground Lake but it's buried under five other tiles with no way to get there, just move the tile. Or declare a "narrative victory." The goal is to have fun, not to litigate the rulebook of a game that thrives on randomness.
Betrayal at House on the Hill is a flawed masterpiece. It's a game of "what ifs." What if the professor hadn't found the Revolver? What if the little girl hadn't turned into a werewolf in the larder? It’s these stories that keep people coming back to the house, even after they’ve been stabbed in the back by their best friend for the tenth time.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Next Game Night
- Assign a "Rules Lawyer": Have one person (who isn't the traitor) be the designated person to look up general rule clarifications so the traitor doesn't have to reveal their secrets.
- Use an App for Stats: The plastic clips on the character cards are notorious for sliding off or scratching the cardboard. Download a companion app or use paper and pencil to track your Might, Speed, Knowledge, and Sanity.
- Set the Mood: This game lives and breathes on its theme. Dim the lights, put on a "spooky ambient" playlist on Spotify, and actually read the flavor text on the cards. It makes the eventual betrayal feel much more impactful.
- Check the Errata: If you're playing the 2nd Edition, there are several Haunts with known typos that make them unplayable. Keep a printout of the official errata from Avalon Hill in the box to avoid a mid-game meltdown.