If you’ve spent any time on the "healing" side of the internet lately, you’ve seen it. That white and orange cover. The title that sounds less like a medical text and more like a warning: The Body Keeps the Score.
It’s been over a decade since Dr. Bessel van der Kolk released this book, and honestly, it’s kind of a phenomenon. Most science books have the shelf life of an open avocado. But this one? It’s basically the "trauma bible" for millions of people. It’s spent nearly seven years on the New York Times bestseller list. As of early 2026, it’s still sitting there, which is wild for a dense, 400-page book about neurobiology and suffering.
But why? Why does a book by a Dutch psychiatrist about the "viscera" and "amygdala hijacking" keep showing up in people's beach bags and bedside tables?
The Core Idea: It’s Not All in Your Head
The big takeaway—the thing that makes people feel seen for the first time—is that trauma isn't just a bad memory.
Van der Kolk’s whole thesis is that trauma is a physical change. It’s a rewiring. When something terrible happens, your brain’s alarm system (the amygdala) gets stuck in the "on" position. Your prefrontal cortex—the part that does the logic and the "hey, we're safe now" thinking—basically goes offline.
Basically, the body stays in a state of high alert, secreting stress hormones like cortisol and adrenaline long after the danger is gone. You aren't just "remembering" the past; your body is literally re-experiencing it. That's where the title comes from. Your mind might try to forget, but your heart rate, your digestion, and your tensed-up shoulders remember everything.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Science
Look, as much as people love this book, it’s got some critics. Hardcore scientists and researchers have been pushing back on some of the claims recently.
👉 See also: Pros and cons to fast food: What the health headlines usually get wrong
For instance, the idea that trauma is "stored" in the muscles or organs isn't exactly a proven medical fact in the way most people think. It’s more of a powerful metaphor for how the nervous system stays dysregulated.
Some researchers, like Elizabeth Loftus, have also pointed out that the book’s take on "repressed memories" is a bit controversial. There’s a fear that if you go looking for "buried" trauma that isn't there, you might accidentally create false memories.
Also, the "polyvagal theory" mentioned in the book? Mainstream neuroscience is still pretty split on that. Some experts call it a bit pseudoscientific, or at least an oversimplification of how the vagus nerve actually works.
Why the "Talk Therapy" Critique Hits Hard
Van der Kolk is pretty famously skeptical of just sitting in a chair and talking. He’s noted that during a flashback, the Broca’s area of the brain—the part responsible for speech—actually shuts down.
Think about that. You literally cannot put the feeling into words because the "speech center" has left the building.
This is why he argues that traditional Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) often fails for deep-seated trauma. You can't talk your way out of a physiological reflex. It's like trying to talk your way out of a sneeze.
The Weird and Effective Paths to Healing
If talking doesn't work, what does? This is where the book gets into what some call the "flaky" stuff, though van der Kolk backs it up with his own studies.
- EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing): This involves following a light or a finger with your eyes while thinking about the trauma. It sounds like hypnotism, but the goal is to "reprocess" the memory so it moves from the emotional brain to the logical brain.
- Yoga: Not just for the "namaste" vibes. It’s about learning to inhabit your body again without feeling like it’s a crime scene.
- Neurofeedback: Training your brainwaves to be less "spiky" using real-time computer displays.
- Theater and Drama: This is one of the coolest chapters. He found that putting traumatized kids in plays helped them "rehearse" different emotions and social roles in a safe way.
Real Talk: The Man vs. The Work
We have to talk about the elephant in the room. Bessel van der Kolk was actually fired from his own Trauma Center in Brookline back in 2018.
The allegations weren't about his science, but about his behavior—reports of a "toxic" work environment and how he treated staff. It’s a classic "separate the art from the artist" situation. Does his personal reputation ruin the book’s message? For some, yeah. For others, the relief they got from understanding their own brains outweighs the man’s personal failings.
Actionable Steps: What Do You Actually Do?
If you feel like your body is keeping some "score" you’d rather not have, where do you start? You don't just read the book and get cured.
- Check your HRV: Heart Rate Variability is a big metric in the book. Many wearable trackers (like Oura or Whoop) measure this now. Low HRV often correlates with a nervous system that’s stuck in "fight or flight."
- Experiment with "Bottom-Up" techniques: Instead of just talking, try things that involve the body. Breathwork, rhythmic drumming, or even just long walks where you focus on the sensation of your feet hitting the ground.
- Find a Trauma-Informed Therapist: Not all therapists are created equal. Look for someone who mentions "somatic" work or is trained in EMDR if you feel stuck in your current talk therapy.
- Build a "Safety" Map: Identify what physically makes you feel safe. Is it a certain heavy blanket? A specific smell? The goal is to give your amygdala "safety signals" to counteract the "danger signals."
Trauma is a beast, but the biggest gift van der Kolk gave us was the realization that we aren't "broken." We’re just adapted. Our bodies did exactly what they were supposed to do to survive a threat. The work now is just convincing the body that the war is over.
Next Step: Research a local "Trauma-Sensitive Yoga" class or look for a therapist specifically trained in Somatic Experiencing to see if a body-first approach changes your progress.