He’s the guy in the slicker. The one with the heavy breathing and the rusted meat hook. If you grew up in the late nineties, Ben Willis wasn't just a movie character; he was the reason you looked twice at every person wearing a yellow raincoat during a storm. Honestly, it’s kinda wild how a guy who barely speaks managed to become such a massive staple of the slasher genre.
Most people remember the basics. Four teenagers—Julie, Helen, Ray, and Barry—hit a guy with their car on the Fourth of July. They panic. They dump him in the water. They think he’s dead.
But he wasn't.
The Man Behind the Hook
Ben Willis is the quintessential "grudge" killer. Unlike Michael Myers, who is basically evil in a jumpsuit, or Freddy Krueger, who enjoys the theatricality of the dream world, Ben is motivated by something very human and very ugly: pure, unadulterated revenge.
Before he was "The Fisherman," Ben was just a guy living in Southport, North Carolina. Life wasn't exactly kind to him. He was a widower raising two kids, Susie and Will. The tragedy that kickstarts the whole franchise actually happened before the famous car accident. Ben’s daughter, Susie, died in a horrific car crash on the winding roads near the cliffs. David Egan was the driver who survived that night, and Ben couldn't handle that. He blamed David entirely.
On the night of July 4, 1996, Ben finally took his revenge. He lured David to the cliffs and murdered him. He was literally walking away from a fresh crime scene when the four teens struck him with their car.
Talk about bad timing.
💡 You might also like: Cliff Richard and The Young Ones: The Weirdest Bromance in TV History Explained
Why Ben Willis Isn't Just Your Average Slasher
What makes Ben Willis so effective in I Know What You Did Last Summer is the psychological warfare. He doesn't just jump out of a closet (well, sometimes he does, like with poor Helen Shivers). He sends notes. He leaves a trunk full of crabs in Julie’s car. He shears Helen’s hair while she sleeps.
He wants them to feel the guilt.
Most slashers are about the "how" of the kill. Ben is about the "why." He’s a mirror. He represents the consequence of that one terrible decision made in a moment of panic. You’ve probably thought about it yourself—what would you do if you hit someone on a dark road? The movie works because it preys on that specific fear of being "caught" for your worst mistake.
Muse Watson, the actor who played Ben in the first two films, brought a terrifying physicality to the role. He wasn't a giant monster. He was a lean, weathered man who looked like he’d spent thirty years hauling nets out of the Atlantic. That groundedness is why the character still works.
The Sequel Shift and the "Zombie" Problem
If you’ve seen the sequels, things get a bit weirder. In I Still Know What You Did Last Summer, Ben follows Julie to the Bahamas. We find out he has a son, Will Benson (get it? Ben-son?), who helped lure the group to the island. It's a bit of a stretch, but it keeps the revenge theme alive.
Then we get to the third movie, I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer.
📖 Related: Christopher McDonald in Lemonade Mouth: Why This Villain Still Works
This is where things go off the rails for a lot of fans. In the third installment, Ben Willis returns as a literal undead zombie. He’s no longer just a man with a grudge; he’s an urban legend come to life. He teleports. He has superhuman strength. He basically becomes a supernatural entity that hunts anyone who tries to cover up a death.
A lot of purists hate this. Honestly, I get it. The scares in the original were rooted in the idea that a person was coming for you. Once he becomes a ghost-zombie, the stakes feel different. It's less about the guilt of the characters and more about a monster-of-the-week vibe.
The Real Legacy of the Fisherman
Despite the direct-to-video sequels, the image of the Fisherman remains iconic. Here is why he actually matters in the history of horror:
- The Urban Legend Connection: The film leans hard into the "Hookman" legend, making Ben feel like he stepped right out of a campfire story.
- The Slasher Revival: Along with Scream, this movie saved the slasher genre in the 90s.
- A Unique Weapon: Most killers use knives or machetes. The meat hook is visceral, industrial, and just plain nasty.
The franchise is currently seeing a massive resurgence. With rumors of a 2025 legacy sequel featuring the return of Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr., Ben Willis is once again at the center of the conversation. If the new film follows the "legacy sequel" trend (think Halloween 2018 or Scream 2022), they might just ignore the zombie stuff and bring him back as a very old, very angry man.
What We Can Learn From Southport
So, what’s the takeaway here? Beyond "don't dump bodies in the ocean," there’s a real lesson in how Ben Willis functions as a character. He is the physical manifestation of unresolved trauma.
The characters in I Know What You Did Last Summer weren't just running from a guy with a hook. They were running from the version of themselves that decided Barry’s scholarship or Helen’s pageant crown was worth more than a man’s life.
👉 See also: Christian Bale as Bruce Wayne: Why His Performance Still Holds Up in 2026
Ben Willis is just the guy who makes sure they don't forget it.
If you're looking to dive back into the series, I'd suggest sticking to the 1997 original for the atmosphere and the 1998 sequel for the sheer 90s-ness of it all. Skip the third one unless you're a completionist who really wants to see a fisherman teleport.
To really understand the character, pay attention to the silence. Ben doesn't quip like Chucky. He doesn't laugh like Freddy. He just stares. And sometimes, that's way more effective than any jump scare.
Next time you're near the coast and the fog starts rolling in, maybe leave the yellow slicker at home. You never know who might be watching.
Practical Steps for Slasher Fans
- Watch the 1997 Original: Focus on the cinematography by Denis Crossan; the way he uses the North Carolina coastline creates a sense of isolation that most modern slashers lack.
- Analyze the Motivation: Notice how Ben's murders aren't random. He targets the people who directly impacted his life or the lives of his children first.
- Explore the Source Material: Read the 1973 novel by Lois Duncan. Interestingly, in the book, there is no "Fisherman" costume and no hook. The movie took a grounded suspense novel and turned it into the slasher we know today.
Stick to the lore, respect the hook, and for heaven's sake, if you hit something on the road, just call the police.