Ice cream is basically a science experiment that tastes good. Most people think of Ben & Jerry’s as just another colorful tub in the freezer aisle, but the reality is much weirder. It’s a story about a guy who couldn't smell, a $5 correspondence course, and a massive corporate tug-of-war that still makes headlines today. Honestly, if Jerry Greenfield and Ben Cohen hadn't failed at their initial dreams, we'd probably be eating bagels right now instead of Phish Food.
Ben Cohen had a literal physical condition that changed the way you eat dessert. He has anosmia. That means he has almost no sense of smell, which, as any chef will tell you, nukes your sense of taste. To enjoy food, Ben needed texture. He needed big chunks. He needed things that snapped, crunched, and felt substantial under his teeth. That’s why your pint of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough has massive boulders of dough instead of tiny flecks. It wasn't a marketing gimmick; it was the only way one of the founders could actually enjoy his own product.
How Jerry and Ice Cream Changed the Texture Game
Most ice cream companies try to keep their "overrun" high. Overrun is just a fancy industry word for air. If you buy a cheap gallon of store-brand vanilla, you’re basically paying for 50% frozen air. Jerry Greenfield and Ben Cohen went the opposite direction. They made "super-premium" ice cream with incredibly low air content. It’s dense. It’s heavy. If you’ve ever noticed that a pint of Ben & Jerry's feels like a brick compared to other brands, that’s why.
They started in 1978 in a renovated gas station in Burlington, Vermont. It was cold. Like, dangerously cold. They originally wanted to do bagels, but the equipment was too expensive, so they pivoted to ice cream after taking a $5 course from Penn State. That’s the kind of low-stakes beginning that usually ends in a bankruptcy filing within six months. Instead, they became a global phenomenon because they understood something about "mouthfeel" that the big guys were ignoring.
Jerry was the "ice cream man" in the literal sense—he was the technician, the guy who made the operations run. Ben was the visionary with the broken nose. Together, they realized that if they packed the ice cream with massive inclusions (the chunks), people would develop a sort of cult-like devotion to the brand. And they were right.
The David vs. Goliath Battle with Häagen-Dazs
In the 1980s, the "ice cream wars" were actually a real thing. Pillsbury, which owned Häagen-Dazs at the time, tried to block Ben & Jerry’s from being distributed in certain markets. They didn't like the competition. Most startups would have folded or sued quietly.
Not these guys.
They started a campaign called "What’s the Doughboy Afraid Of?" It was genius. They put the slogan on their tubs. They took out ads. They turned a legal distribution dispute into a cultural moment. It established them as the "little guy" fighting the corporate machine, a reputation they’ve tried to maintain even after being bought by Unilever for $326 million in 2000.
The Weird Logic of "Flavor Graveyards"
Ever wonder why your favorite flavor just... vanishes? It’s not a mistake. The company maintains a literal "Flavor Graveyard" at their factory in Waterbury, Vermont. It has headstones. It has poems for the "deceased" flavors like Bovinity Divinity and Urban Bourbon.
The turnover is part of the strategy. They keep the lineup fresh by constantly rotating "Limited Batches." This creates a "buy it now or lose it forever" mentality in the consumer. But it’s also a necessity of the supply chain. When you’re dealing with Fair Trade cocoa, non-GMO ingredients, and specific chunks like "fudge-covered waffle cone pieces," the logistics are a nightmare. If a flavor isn't a top-ten seller, it gets the axe to make room for the next experiment.
- Cherry Garcia remains one of the longest-running successes, named after the Grateful Dead guitarist.
- Many flavors fail because the "mix-ins" get soggy over time—maintaining the crunch is the hardest part of the R&D process.
- The company uses "Chunkanators" (not a joke, that’s the actual internal term for the machinery) to pump those massive pieces into the base.
The Social Mission Tension
You can't talk about Ben & Jerry's without talking about politics. It’s baked into the cream. Whether it's marriage equality, climate change, or the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, they jump in where most brands run away. This isn't always easy for Unilever, the parent company.
👉 See also: How to Put a Belt on So Your Pants Actually Stay Up
There is a permanent tension between the independent Board of Directors in Vermont and the corporate headquarters in London. In 2021, this boiled over when the brand decided to stop selling ice cream in "Occupied Palestinian Territory." It led to lawsuits, stock fluctuations, and a very public spat between the founders and the parent company.
It’s a case study in Brand Purpose. A lot of companies "greenwash" or pretend to care about social issues for a PR boost. Ben & Jerry’s has it written into their legal merger agreement. They have the right to be "activists," even if it hurts the bottom line. It’s a messy, complicated way to run a business, but it’s the reason they have a level of brand loyalty that most consumer packaged goods (CPG) companies would kill for.
Why the "Super Premium" Category Is Shrinking
We are currently seeing a weird shift in the frozen dessert aisle. People are moving toward high-protein, low-calorie options like Halo Top, or dairy-free alternatives. Ben & Jerry’s was actually pretty late to the non-dairy game, but they’ve since caught up by using almond milk and sunflower butter bases.
The problem with super-premium ice cream is that it’s an indulgence in an era where people are increasingly health-conscious—or at least pretend to be. A single pint can pack 1,200 calories. That’s a lot. But the brand leans into it. They aren't trying to be "healthy." They are trying to be an experience.
The Science of the "Chunk"
How do they keep a brownie from becoming a rock when it's frozen? Or a pretzel from getting mushy? It’s all about moisture migration. If you put a regular pretzel in ice cream, it sucks up the water from the cream and turns into a soggy mess within days.
To prevent this, the "chunks" are often coated in a fat-based barrier—usually a thin layer of chocolate or oil. This keeps the moisture out and the crunch in. It’s why the "Core" line was such a technical breakthrough. Keeping a pillar of jam or fudge soft enough to spoon through, while the ice cream around it stays frozen solid, requires precise sugar-to-fat ratios. If the sugar content in the core is too low, it freezes into an icicle. If it’s too high, it never sets.
Actionable Insights for the Savvy Ice Cream Eater
If you want to actually enjoy your ice cream like a pro, stop eating it straight out of the freezer. Most home freezers are set to $0^\circ\text{F}$ ($-18^\circ\text{C}$). That is way too cold for high-fat ice cream. It numbs your taste buds.
- The 10-Minute Rule: Let the pint sit on the counter for about 10 minutes before diving in. This allows the fats to soften slightly, which releases the flavor molecules.
- The Upside Down Trick: Store your pint upside down in the freezer. This prevents "freezer burn" (the crunchy ice crystals) from forming on the top surface by moving the air pocket to the bottom.
- Check the "Best By" Date: Because Ben & Jerry’s has so many chunks and complex ingredients, it’s more prone to "texture degradation" than plain vanilla. Fresher is always better.
- The Knife Cut: Instead of struggling with a spoon, use a serrated knife to cut the entire pint container in half (or thirds) horizontally. You get a perfect "disk" of ice cream with an even distribution of chunks.
The story of Jerry and ice cream isn't just about sugar and cream. It’s about how a physical limitation—a lack of smell—created a global standard for what "good" ice cream feels like. Next time you hit a massive chunk of fudge, remember that it’s only there because Ben Cohen couldn't taste his lunch.