You know the faces. They’re on the pints of Cherry Garcia and Chunky Monkey. Two guys, looking kinda like your favorite laid-back uncles, who turned a $5 correspondence course into a multi-billion dollar empire. But if you think the Ben and Jerry founder story is just a sweet tale of peace, love, and waffle cones, you’ve got it wrong.
Honestly, the real story is a lot messier. It’s a 40-year saga of corporate wars, radical politics, and a recent, heart-wrenching split that has basically changed the company forever.
Two "Fat Kids" from Long Island
Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield weren’t exactly the guys you’d pick to run a global conglomerate. In their own words, they were the "slowest, fattest kids in gym class." They met in 1963 at Merrick Avenue Junior High. Ben was the one yelling back at the coach; Jerry was the one finding it hilarious.
They were failures first. Jerry couldn't get into medical school. Ben was a college dropout who drove a taxi. By the time they hit their late 20s, they were bored and hungry. They decided to start a food business.
It was almost bagels.
Really.
But bagel equipment was too expensive ($40,000 back then was a fortune), so they pivoted to ice cream. They split a $5 correspondence course from Penn State on how to make the stuff. In 1978, with $12,000 in their pockets—five grand of which was borrowed—they opened their first shop in a renovated gas station in Burlington, Vermont.
💡 You might also like: Class A Berkshire Hathaway Stock Price: Why $740,000 Is Only Half the Story
The secret to their success wasn't some complex algorithm. It was Ben’s nose. He has anosmia, which means he can't smell much and can barely taste. To compensate, he insisted on "mouthfeel." He wanted huge chunks of cookies and candy so he could feel what he was eating. That’s why your pint of Half Baked is basically a minefield of dough.
Why the Ben and Jerry Founder Spirit Clashed with Corporate Giants
The company grew fast. Too fast for two guys who wanted to run it like a commune. By the 80s, they were fighting Häagen-Dazs in a "David and Goliath" battle because the bigger brand tried to block them from distributors. Ben’s response? He started a campaign called "What's the Häagen-Dazs hiding?" and personally handed out leaflets.
It worked. People loved the underdog.
But the real drama started in 2000. That’s when Unilever, the British-Dutch giant that owns everything from Dove soap to Hellmann’s mayo, bought Ben & Jerry’s for $326 million.
The founders didn’t want to sell. They actually tried to find local investors to keep it private, but as a public company, their board was legally required to take the highest bid. It was a "sell-out" that felt like a funeral.
📖 Related: Getting a music business degree online: What most people get wrong about the industry
For twenty years, they had a "unique" arrangement. Ben & Jerry’s kept an independent board of directors to protect its social mission. They could still talk about climate change, racial justice, and marriage equality. For a long time, it was a weird, functional marriage between a hippie and a suit.
The 2025 Breakup: Why Jerry Finally Quit
Things turned ugly recently.
If you’ve been following the news in 2025 and early 2026, you know the relationship has completely imploded. In September 2025, Jerry Greenfield officially resigned as a brand ambassador. After 47 years.
"My heart is broken," Jerry basically told the press.
The issue? Gaza. The independent board wanted to call for a permanent ceasefire and launch a "Palestine solidarity" flavor. Unilever stepped in and blocked it. They also allegedly removed the CEO, David Stever, without the board's permission.
👉 See also: We Are Legal Revolution: Why the Status Quo is Finally Breaking
Ben Cohen stayed on but he’s been protesting outside Unilever’s offices in London. He’s calling for the brand to be "freed."
Unilever is currently spinning off its entire ice cream division into a new company called Magnum. The founders are desperate to keep Ben & Jerry’s out of it. They want the brand to go back to its roots—independent and outspoken. But as of January 2026, Unilever is holding firm. They say the brand is "not for sale."
What Most People Get Wrong About the Brand
Most people think Ben and Jerry are still the bosses. They aren't. They haven't had "operational control" since the Clinton administration. They were basically highly-paid mascots—until Jerry walked away.
Another misconception? That the activism is just marketing.
Whether you agree with their politics or not, these guys were serious. They pioneered "linked prosperity," the idea that if the company makes money, the farmers and the employees should too. They used Greyston Bakery (which hires people with criminal records) for their brownies long before "social enterprise" was a buzzword.
Real Lessons from the Ben & Jerry’s Legacy
If you’re looking to build a brand like the Ben and Jerry founder duo, there are some hard truths to digest:
- Authenticity is a double-edged sword. The very thing that made them famous (being outspoken) is now the thing causing their corporate divorce.
- The "Mouthfeel" Rule. If your product doesn't have a "hook" (like those giant chunks), no amount of social justice will save it.
- Contracts Matter. The only reason the brand survived this long with its soul intact was that specific 2000 merger agreement. Without that independent board, they would have been just another vanilla brand years ago.
Next Steps for the Savvy Consumer:
If you want to support the founders' original vision, look into the "Free Ben & Jerry’s" movement or check out the B-Corp status of other brands. You can also follow Ben Cohen’s independent projects, like "Ben’s Best," where he’s still trying to use business as a tool for radical change without a corporate parent breathing down his neck.
The era of Ben and Jerry being "just ice cream guys" is over. They’ve become the ultimate case study in what happens when a counter-culture dream hits the ceiling of global capitalism. It’s messy, it’s cold, and it’s definitely not over yet.