Digging a hole in the dirt sounds easy. You grab a shovel, find a spot behind the garage, and start throwing earth until you’ve got a crater deep enough to hide a spare tire. But honestly, if you think a below ground fire pit is just a DIY hole in the backyard, you’re probably going to end up with a soggy, smoky mess that won't stay lit for more than twenty minutes. There is a specific science to why these things work—and why they fail.
Most people see those sleek, Pinterest-ready stone circles tucked into the lawn and think about the aesthetics. They want that campfire vibe without the bulky metal ring sitting on top of their grass. It looks cleaner. It feels more primitive, like something you'd find at an ancient campsite. Yet, the physics of airflow changes the second you drop your fuel source below the grade of the surrounding terrain. Oxygen is the lifeblood of fire. When you go underground, you’re basically trying to light a match in a box with the lid halfway closed.
The Hidden Physics of the Below Ground Fire Pit
Air is heavy. Cold air sinks, and hot air rises. In a standard above-ground setup, the breeze hits the logs from the side, feeding the flames constantly. With a below ground fire pit, you have to find a way to "trick" the air into circulating. If you don't, you get what's known as "choking." The fire consumes the oxygen in the pit, creates a vacuum, and then just... dies. Or worse, it produces so much thick, acrid smoke that you can't even sit near it.
You've probably heard of the Dakota Fire Hole. It’s the gold standard for survivalists and people who actually know what they’re doing with earth-based fires. It’s not just one hole. It’s two. You dig the main pit for the wood, then you dig a secondary "chimney" or air shaft at an angle that connects to the bottom of the main hole. This creates a natural draft. The heat from the fire pulls air through the secondary tunnel, creating a forge-like intensity that burns incredibly hot and almost entirely without smoke.
It’s efficient.
But most homeowners aren't looking to build a tactical survival trench. They want a permanent feature. For a permanent below ground fire pit, you’re looking at drainage issues that would make a basement contractor sweat. If your soil is heavy clay, your fire pit is actually a pond. You’ll go out to light a fire on a Friday night only to find three inches of stagnant rainwater staring back at you.
Drainage is the Part Everyone Skips
You need a sump. Or at least a deep base of structural gravel. When I say deep, I’m talking 12 to 18 inches of ¾-inch crushed stone beneath your actual fire floor. This gives the water somewhere to go while the fire is doing its thing. If you’re really fancy, you run a PVC drain pipe from the bottom of the pit out to a lower point in your yard, though that’s honestly overkill for most residential setups unless you live in the Pacific Northwest.
Materials That Won't Explode
Here is something scary: rocks can explode. It’s not a myth. If you grab river stones from a nearby creek and line your below ground fire pit with them, you’re basically planting tiny claymore mines. River rocks are porous and often filled with moisture. When that water turns to steam inside the rock, it has nowhere to go. Pop. You’ve got shards of hot stone flying toward your face.
Stick to fire-rated bricks (kiln-fired) or specific landscape blocks designed for high heat. Lava rock is another solid choice for the floor because it’s incredibly porous and handles thermal expansion like a pro.
- Fire Bricks: These are dense and usually yellowish. They reflect heat back into the center of the pit rather than absorbing it.
- Steel Liners: A lot of people use a heavy-duty steel ring to line the top 12 inches. It prevents the soil at the lip of the pit from drying out and collapsing into your embers.
- Paver Sand: Use this to level your base. It’s cheap and stays put.
Honestly, the "look" of the pit is secondary to the safety of the walls. Soil is heavy. Over time, the weight of the earth around the hole will want to push inward, especially after a heavy rain. If you don't have a structural wall—either stone, brick, or a metal ring—your pit will eventually just become a shallow depression in the mud.
The Smoke Factor
We need to talk about the "cone of silence" but for smoke. In a sunken pit, the smoke tends to linger at waist height because it gets trapped by the surrounding "walls" of the earth. This is the biggest complaint people have. To fix it, you need to build your fire using the "top-down" method.
Put your big logs on the bottom. Stack smaller sticks on top. Put your kindling at the very peak. By lighting it from the top, the fire consumes the smoke-producing gases as they rise from the wood below. It’s a cleaner burn. It keeps your guests from smelling like a hickory smoked ham for the next three days.
Legalities and "The Boring Stuff"
Before you put a shovel to the dirt, you have to check your local ordinances. I know, it’s annoying. But many urban and suburban areas have strict rules about "open burning." Some cities classify a below ground fire pit differently than a portable metal one from a big-box store.
One big thing: the 10-foot rule. Almost every fire marshal in the country will tell you that a fire needs to be at least 10 to 15 feet away from any structure, overhanging trees, or wooden fences. Underground fires are sneakier. Roots can catch fire. It’s called a "ground fire," and it’s a nightmare. If you dig a pit near an old oak tree, the heat can actually ignite the peat and root system underground. The fire can travel through the roots and pop up five feet away.
Call 811. Just do it. You don't want to be the person who slices through a fiber-optic cable or a gas line while trying to build a place to roast marshmallows. It’s free, and they’ll mark your lines. No excuses.
Real World Maintenance
An in-ground pit is a magnet for debris. Leaves, twigs, and your neighbor's wandering cat will all find their way into that hole. You’re going to need a lid. Not just a mesh screen, but a solid, weatherproof cover.
A heavy steel plate or a custom-fitted wooden lid (only used when the pit is stone-cold, obviously) is essential. Without it, you’ll be spending twenty minutes cleaning out wet muck every time you want to have a beer by the fire.
Ash Management
Cleaning out an in-ground pit is a chore. You can't just tip it over like a Kettle Joe. You’re down there with a small shovel and a bucket.
🔗 Read more: The Queen Bed Frame with Bookcase: Why Your Nightstand is Probably Failing You
- Wait 48 hours. Ash stays hot way longer than you think.
- Use a metal bucket. Never plastic.
- Don't dump the ash in your compost if you burned treated wood or trash (which you shouldn't do anyway).
- Leave a thin layer (one inch) of ash at the bottom to protect your drainage gravel from direct heat.
Why Bother?
With all these warnings, you might wonder why anyone would choose this over a $50 portable pit.
The answer is the heat.
An in-ground pit radiates heat differently. Because the fire is shielded from the wind, the coal bed stays hotter for longer. You get this deep, consistent glow that warms your feet in a way an above-ground pit never could. It’s also safer in windy conditions. Sparks are less likely to catch a gust and fly onto your roof if they have to climb out of a 16-inch deep hole first.
It’s also about the "camp" feel. There is something deeply psychological about sitting around a fire that is level with the ground. It feels more permanent. It feels like home.
Cost Breakdown (The Real Numbers)
If you do it yourself, a solid below ground fire pit will cost you about $150 to $300. That’s for the gravel, the fire bricks, and a decent steel liner.
If you hire a "pro" landscape crew? You're looking at $1,500 to $4,000. They’ll do the masonry, the gas lines (if you go that route), and the drainage. Is it worth it? Maybe, if you want it to look like a resort. But for most of us, a Saturday afternoon and a few blisters are the better way to go.
Actionable Next Steps
If you’re ready to start digging, don’t just wing it.
💡 You might also like: Isidor and Ida Straus: What Most People Get Wrong About the Titanic’s Most Famous Couple
Start by marking a circle with a radius 6 inches wider than your intended pit. This gives you room for the wall materials. Dig down 24 inches. Fill the first 10 inches with that crushed stone I mentioned.
Then, when you’re building the walls, leave small gaps in the first layer of bricks. These are your "weep holes." They let air in and let water out. It’s the single most important detail that separates a professional pit from a muddy hole.
Once the walls are up, backfill the outside with more gravel—not soil. Soil expands when it freezes; gravel doesn't. This keeps your pit from cracking when the winter hits.
Finally, buy a long-handled ash shovel. Your back will thank me later. You've got this. Just watch out for the roots and keep the water out. A well-built pit will last twenty years; a poorly built one will last until the first big rainstorm. Get to digging.