You’ve seen the posters. The tall, gaunt figure of Count Dracula looming over a terrified victim, followed shortly by the flat-headed, heavy-browed Monster stumbling through the graveyard. For nearly a century, Bela Lugosi and Boris Karloff have been the twin pillars of horror. Most people think they were bitter rivals who spent their lives trying to out-spook and out-earn each other. Pop culture, especially films like Tim Burton’s Ed Wood, has spent decades feeding us this image of a grumpy, foul-mouthed Lugosi cursing Karloff’s name between takes of B-movie disasters.
Honestly? Most of that is just Hollywood lore.
The real story isn't about two enemies. It's about two middle-aged immigrants who hit it big way later than everyone else and then had to navigate a studio system that basically treated them like disposable props. They weren't best friends who went out for drinks every Friday, but the idea that they hated each other’s guts is mostly a myth cooked up by studio publicists to sell tickets.
The 1934 Turning Point and the "Black Cat" Rivalry
In 1934, Universal Pictures decided to put their two biggest stars together for the first time. The movie was The Black Cat. It had almost nothing to do with the Edgar Allan Poe story, but it had everything to do with chemistry.
Karloff played Hjalmar Poelzig, a Satan-worshipping architect who lives in a house built over a mass grave. Lugosi was Dr. Vitus Werdegast, a man seeking revenge for his lost family. If you watch the film today, you can see the friction, but it’s professional friction. They were testing each other. Lugosi was the classically trained Hungarian who lived and breathed the theater. Karloff was the soft-spoken Englishman, William Henry Pratt, who had spent years digging ditches and driving trucks before Frankenstein made him a household name at age 43.
Universal loved the "versus" angle. They marketed it like a heavyweight boxing match.
👉 See also: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
The studio executives were smart—and kinda cruel. They knew Lugosi was desperate for money. Because of his thick accent and his habit of taking any role offered to him, the studio could lowball him. While Karloff was often getting top billing and a solid paycheck, Lugosi was frequently signed for a fraction of the cost. In The Raven (1935), Lugosi is arguably the star. He plays the obsessed Dr. Vollin and has way more screen time than Karloff. Yet, Karloff got the top name on the poster.
That hurt. It wasn’t Karloff’s fault, but you can imagine how Lugosi felt seeing his "rival" get the glory for work he was arguably carrying.
Why the "Hatred" Myth Stuck
If you want to know why everyone thinks they were enemies, look at the 1994 movie Ed Wood. Martin Landau won an Oscar for playing Bela Lugosi, and he did it brilliantly, but he portrayed Lugosi as a man obsessed with Karloff’s success. He screams about "Boris Karloff’s limey blood" and curses him out in almost every scene.
In reality? Lugosi’s son and Karloff’s daughter have both said this was nonsense.
They were professionals. When they worked together on films like Son of Frankenstein or The Body Snatcher, they were reportedly cordial and respectful. Lugosi even visited Karloff in the hospital at one point. They weren't "besties" like Peter Cushing and Christopher Lee—who would later become the faces of Hammer Horror—but they weren't enemies.
✨ Don't miss: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
They were just two guys in their 50s and 60s trying to keep their careers alive in a genre that Hollywood viewed as a fad.
The Career Divergence
So, why did Karloff end up "winning" the fame game? Basically, it came down to versatility and business sense.
- Boris Karloff was a chameleon. He could play the monster, sure, but he could also play a gentle old man, a Chinese detective, or a sophisticated villain. He did a lot of radio work and even voiced the Grinch in the classic Christmas special. He understood the industry.
- Bela Lugosi was always Lugosi. He was intense. He was hypnotic. But he was also trapped by his own image. He struggled with the English language early on, which led to a perception that he couldn't play anything other than a "foreign" menace.
By the late 1940s, Karloff was still a major name. Lugosi was working for "Poverty Row" studios, making movies for peanuts. This disparity fueled the rumors. People assumed that if one was doing well and the other wasn't, there must be a feud.
The Eight Films They Made Together
You’ve got to see these if you want to understand the dynamic. They shared the screen eight times, and each one tells you something different about their relationship.
- The Black Cat (1934): The best one. Pure atmosphere and a weird, erotic undertone that was way ahead of its time.
- Gift of Gab (1934): Just a cameo for both, but it showed Universal was already trying to milk the pairing.
- The Raven (1935): Lugosi goes full ham as a Poe-obsessed surgeon. It’s glorious.
- The Invisible Ray (1936): Sci-fi horror where Karloff glows in the dark and Lugosi plays the "sane" scientist for once.
- Son of Frankenstein (1939): Lugosi steals the movie as Ygor. If you think he couldn't act, watch this. It’s his best performance.
- Black Friday (1940): A weird brain-transplant movie where they barely even share a scene together.
- You'll Find Out (1940): A musical comedy. Yeah, you read that right.
- The Body Snatcher (1945): Their final pairing. Produced by Val Lewton. It’s a quiet, literary horror film where Karloff gives a career-best performance, and Lugosi has a small, tragic role.
What You Should Take Away From This
Looking back at Bela Lugosi and Boris Karloff, it's easy to see them as caricatures. We see the Halloween costumes and the parodies. But if you actually sit down and watch the movies, you see two actors who respected the craft.
🔗 Read more: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
Lugosi wasn't just a "vampire." He was a man who fought in the trenches of WWI, was wounded three times, and later struggled with a morphine addiction that he eventually conquered. Karloff wasn't just a "monster." He was a founding member of the Screen Actors Guild who fought for the rights of bit players and extras.
They were pioneers. They created the blueprint for every horror icon that followed, from Freddy Krueger to Pennywise.
The "rivalry" was a marketing gimmick that got out of hand. In reality, they were two immigrants who found a home in the shadows of Hollywood and stayed there because they were better at being scary than anyone else.
Next Steps for Horror Fans
If you're looking to dive deeper into this history, stop watching the parodies and go to the source.
- Watch Son of Frankenstein: Pay attention to Lugosi’s performance as Ygor. It’s a masterclass in physical acting and vocal characterization.
- Read Bela Lugosi and Boris Karloff by Gregory William Mank: This is the definitive book on their collaboration. It clears up the myths with real production notes and interviews.
- Check out The Body Snatcher: It’s on most streaming services. It shows both men at the end of their Universal/RKO run, playing characters with real depth and sadness.
Don't buy into the "hatred" narrative. It’s a lot more interesting to think of them as two titans who knew that, without each other, the Golden Age of Horror wouldn't have been nearly as dark—or as fun.