Finding a Beanie Baby with your exact birthday used to be the ultimate flex in the 90s. If you were born on April 11, you actually have a surprisingly cool roster of "birthday twins" in the Ty world. We're not just talking about one random bear. There’s a whole squad of retired plushies that claim this spring date.
Honestly, the obsession with the beanie baby april 11 date usually starts with a search for a gift or a nostalgia trip, but it quickly turns into a deep dive into tag generations and "tush tag" errors. It’s funny how a little heart-shaped piece of cardboard can change the value of a toy from $5 to $500.
The April 11 Birthday Squad: Who are They?
Most people think there’s only one "April" bear, but Ty Warner was never that simple. If you check the official archives, several iconic characters share this birthdate.
Eggbeart the Bear is probably the most famous one. Released in 2004, this bright yellow bear is basically the embodiment of Easter. He’s got that classic 9-inch build and was produced in China during the later years of the original Beanie craze. People love him because he’s unapologetically yellow.
Then you have Peekaboo the Turtle. This little guy is a fan favorite because of his shell—it’s usually a mix of orange and green tie-dye. Peekaboo was "born" on April 11, 2000. Because he’s tie-dyed, no two Peekaboos look exactly the same. That’s a big deal for collectors who want a "unique" version of a mass-produced toy.
🔗 Read more: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
There are a few others too:
- Lilac the Rabbit: A pastel bunny that fits the spring theme perfectly.
- Sheepishly the Sheep: One of the more underrated farm animals in the collection.
Why the Beanie Baby April 11 Date Matters for Value
Value is a tricky thing with Beanie Babies. You’ve probably seen those insane eBay listings for $10,000 and wondered if people actually pay that.
Spoiler: mostly no.
But for an april 11 beanie baby like Peekaboo or Eggbeart, the price is dictated by the "Gen" (Generation) of the tag. If you find a Peekaboo with a 6th Generation heart tag and a 9th Generation tush tag, it’s a common find, maybe worth $10 to $15.
💡 You might also like: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
However, errors are the "holy grail." If the tag says "April 11" but the tush tag has a different year, or if there's a typo in the poem, the price jumps. For example, some collectors hunt for the "Gasport" error (where Gosport, UK is misspelled) or extra spaces in the poems.
The McDonald’s Connection
Interestingly, April 11 has another weird spot in Ty history. Back in 2009, the McDonald’s Teenie Beanie Baby 2.0 promotion actually kicked off on April 11.
This was the 30th anniversary of the Happy Meal. They released 30 different Teenie Beanies, including characters like Aussie the Koala and Boomer the Dog. While these little guys don’t usually have the April 11 birthday (Aussie’s is July 10, for instance), the date is etched into the brains of collectors who stood in line for nuggets just to get a plastic-wrapped crab or bear.
How to Spot a "Fake" or Overpriced Listing
If you’re looking to buy a beanie baby april 11 twin for yourself or a friend, don't get scammed.
📖 Related: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
First off, "Rare" is the most overused word on the internet. Just because a seller says Eggbeart is rare doesn't mean he is. Thousands were made. A real collector looks at the tush tag. Does it have a red star? Is it "handmade in China" or Indonesia?
Indonesia-made Beanies are often considered slightly more valuable by hardcore enthusiasts because the stuffing (PVC pellets vs. PE pellets) feels different and the production runs were sometimes smaller.
Taking Care of Your April 11 Finds
Let’s say you found your birthday twin. You want to keep it mint.
- Tag Protectors are Non-Negotiable: That "swing tag" is 80% of the value. A crease in the heart is like a dent in a Ferrari.
- Avoid Sunlight: The yellow on Eggbeart or the purple on Lilac will fade into a sad, dusty grey if left on a sunny shelf.
- The "Smell" Test: Old Beanies can pick up attic smells. Don't wash them in a machine! Use a damp cloth and maybe a gentle fabric freshener, but keep the tags dry.
Whether you're hunting for Peekaboo's funky shell or Eggbeart's sunny face, the beanie baby april 11 search is a fun rabbit hole. It reminds us of a time when the world was obsessed with "collecting them all," and honestly, there's something kinda nice about having a little plush friend that shares your special day.
Check your old bins. You might just have a yellow bear or a tie-dyed turtle waiting to be rediscovered.
Next Steps for Collectors:
- Verify your tag generation by comparing the font and star placement with a trusted database like TyCollector.
- Inspect the tush tag for the "PE" or "PVC" marking to determine the era of production.
- Invest in acrylic display cases if you find a version with a verified tag error, as these are the only ones that truly appreciate in value.