When people talk about Bay FC vs Orlando Pride, the conversation usually starts and ends with the standings. You’ve got Orlando, the 2024 NWSL Champions, a powerhouse that seems to find ways to win even when they aren't playing their best. Then you have Bay FC, the expansion side trying to find its feet in a league that doesn't give anyone a free pass.
But if you actually watch the games? It's a different story.
Honestly, the scoreboards are lying to you. On paper, Orlando has dominated the series since Bay FC entered the league. But every single meeting between these two has been a cage match. We are talking about games decided by a single deflection, a controversial VAR call, or a moment of individual brilliance from a world-class striker. If you’re looking for a blowout, this isn't the fixture for it. These two teams basically drag each other into deep water every time they step on the pitch.
The Zambian Connection: Kundananji vs Banda
You cannot talk about Bay FC vs Orlando Pride without mentioning the two most expensive players in the league. Racheal Kundananji and Barbra Banda. They aren't just teammates on the Zambian national team; they are the gravitational centers of their respective clubs.
When they face off, it’s personal. Sorta.
In their June 2025 meeting at PayPal Park, Banda was the difference-maker. She scored the only goal of the match in the 58th minute, a scrappy effort from the six-yard box that took a deflection and broke Bay FC hearts. But look at the stats: Bay FC actually outshot Orlando 20 to 10. They hit the crossbar. They forced saves. They did everything but put the ball in the net.
✨ Don't miss: Seattle Seahawks Offense Rank: Why the Top-Three Scoring Unit Still Changed Everything
Kundananji, meanwhile, has become Bay FC’s all-time leading scorer. In their most recent clash in September 2025, she finally got her lick back. She headed home a goal in first-half stoppage time to give Bay FC a 1-0 lead. It was a massive moment for the expansion side, proving they could actually lead against the best team in the country.
Why the 1-1 Draw in September Mattered
That 1-1 draw on September 13, 2025, was probably the most chaotic game of the year. It had everything that makes NWSL soccer both incredible and frustrating to watch.
- Disallowed Goals: Both teams had goals wiped off the board by VAR.
- Goalkeeping Heroics: Jordan Silkowitz tied her career high with seven saves, including a diving stop on a point-blank shot from Angelina.
- The Equalizer: Ally Watt finally broke through for Orlando in the 70th minute, thanks to a beautiful curling cross from newcomer Jacqueline Ovalle.
For Bay FC, that point wasn't just a point. It snapped a four-match losing streak. It showed that they could go into Inter&Co Stadium—a place where teams usually go to die—and leave with their heads held high.
Coaching Chess: Seb Hines vs Albertin Montoya
Seb Hines has turned Orlando into a defensive fortress. They don't just win; they grind you down. In 2024, they set a club record with six straight wins, and a big part of that was their ability to keep clean sheets. When they played Bay FC in May 2024, they won 1-0 on a penalty from Adriana. It was clinical. It was boring. It was exactly what Hines wanted.
On the flip side, Albertin Montoya wants Bay FC to be expansive. He wants them to use the width of the pitch. That’s why you see players like Caprice Dydasco and Alyssa Malonson pushing so high up the flanks.
🔗 Read more: Seahawks Standing in the NFL: Why Seattle is Stuck in the Playoff Purgatory Middle
The problem? That aggressive style often leaves them vulnerable to the counter-attack, which is exactly where Barbra Banda thrives. It is a classic tactical clash. One team wants to control the chaos, and the other team is the chaos.
Breaking Down the Matchup History
If you're a betting person, you've probably noticed a trend in the Bay FC vs Orlando Pride history.
- May 11, 2024: Orlando wins 1-0 (Adriana penalty).
- September 20, 2024: Orlando wins 1-0 (Banda goal).
- June 13, 2025: Orlando wins 1-0 (Banda goal).
- September 13, 2025: 1-1 Draw (Kundananji and Watt goals).
Notice something? Three out of the four games ended 1-0. The total goal aggregate is 4-2 in favor of Orlando over four matches. That is incredibly tight for two teams on opposite ends of the historical spectrum. It suggests that Bay FC’s backline—led by veterans like Abby Dahlkemper—actually matches up quite well against Orlando’s high-octane offense.
The atmosphere at these games is also starting to rival some of the older NWSL rivalries. In San Jose, the June 2025 match drew over 12,000 fans. In Orlando, the "Teddy Bear Toss" and "Kids Night Out" promotions have turned these matches into massive community events.
What to Expect in the 2026 Season
As we look toward the next slate of games, the dynamic is shifting. Bay FC isn't the "new kid" anymore. They have a year and a half of chemistry under their belts. They’ve reinforced their midfield with players like Dorian Bailey and Tess Boade, who provide the grit needed to stop Orlando’s transition play.
💡 You might also like: Sammy Sosa Before and After Steroids: What Really Happened
Orlando is also evolving. They aren't just the "Banda and Marta show" anymore. The emergence of Jacqueline Ovalle has given them a new dimension on the wing. She’s creative, she’s fast, and she’s already proving to be a nightmare for fullbacks who overcommit.
Key things to watch for in the next Bay FC vs Orlando Pride meeting:
- The First 15 Minutes: Bay FC tends to dominate possession early. If they don't score during that window, Orlando usually settles in and takes over.
- The Subs: Seb Hines isn't afraid to make five changes at once. In the last draw, his second-half subs changed the momentum entirely.
- VAR Interventions: Given the history of these two, expect at least one goal to be scrutinized by the cameras. It’s basically a tradition at this point.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you are following this matchup, stop looking at the win-loss column and start looking at the "Expected Goals" (xG) and defensive recoveries. Bay FC often wins the statistical battle but loses the game because they lack that final "killer instinct" in the box.
For Orlando, the key is maintaining focus. They’ve had several games where they let Bay FC hang around way too long, nearly resulting in dropped points. If they want to remain the queens of the NWSL, they have to put the expansion side away earlier.
Watch the movement of the outside backs. When Dydasco (Bay) and Abello (Orlando) are both flying forward, the middle of the pitch opens up for a track meet. That is when this game is at its absolute best.
The next time Bay FC vs Orlando Pride shows up on the schedule, don't assume it's an easy three points for the champions. It’s going to be a scrap. It’s going to be loud. And more than likely, it’s going to be decided by a single goal in the 80th minute.