Ten months. That is how long the earth screamed in northeastern France. If you’re looking for a quick name to attach to the question of the battle of verdun who won, the technical answer is France. But "winning" feels like a weird word to use for a graveyard that stretches across miles of rolling hills.
From February to December 1916, the German and French armies threw everything they had at each other in a space smaller than Manhattan. It wasn't just a battle; it was a meat grinder. The Germans, led by Chief of Staff Erich von Falkenhayn, didn't actually set out to capture the city for strategic glory. They wanted to "bleed France white." They chose Verdun because they knew the French couldn't afford to lose it for sentimental and historical reasons. It was a trap.
Why the question of who won the Battle of Verdun is complicated
Ask a historian and they’ll tell you the French won because they held the ground. By the end of December, the front lines were basically back where they started. The German offensive failed. They didn't break the French spirit, and they didn't knock France out of the war. In that sense, it’s a clear French victory.
But look at the cost.
The French suffered around 377,000 casualties. The Germans took about 337,000. We are talking about 700,000 men killed, wounded, or missing in a single struggle. It’s hard to celebrate a win when your entire generation is buried in the mud. The landscape today still looks like the surface of the moon because of the millions of shells fired. Literally millions. Some estimates say 60 million shells were lobbed back and forth. You can still see the craters today if you visit. It's haunting.
👉 See also: Who's the Next Pope: Why Most Predictions Are Basically Guesswork
The strategy of attrition
Falkenhayn’s plan was cold. He believed that if he attacked a point the French were forced to defend, he could destroy their entire army through superior artillery. He didn't need to move the map; he just needed to kill.
General Philippe Pétain, who took over the French defense, became a national hero for his "They shall not pass" (Ils ne passeront pas) attitude. He organized the "Voie Sacrée" (Sacred Way), a single road that kept the French army alive by bringing in supplies and fresh troops every few seconds. Literally, a vehicle passed every 14 seconds to keep the meat grinder fed.
- The Germans attacked first on February 21, after a nine-hour bombardment.
- Fort Douaumont, the strongest point in the French line, fell without much of a fight because the French had ironically stripped its guns earlier in the war.
- The battle turned into a series of small, brutal fights for tiny patches of woods and shattered villages.
- By June, the Germans were close to breaking through, but the start of the Battle of the Somme forced them to pull troops away.
The moment the tide turned for France
By the autumn of 1916, the German momentum had died. They were exhausted. The French, under the more aggressive leadership of Robert Nivelle and Charles Mangin, started taking back the forts they had lost.
Fort Douaumont was recaptured in October. Fort Vaux followed in November. By the time the snow started falling in December, the Germans realized the gamble had failed. They hadn't bled France dry; they had bled themselves just as badly. Paul von Hindenburg and Erich Ludendorff, who had taken over the German high command, finally called it quits.
✨ Don't miss: Recent Obituaries in Charlottesville VA: What Most People Get Wrong
Honestly, the German army was never quite the same after Verdun. It was a psychological blow as much as a physical one. They realized that even their best artillery and most calculated plans couldn't break the French infantry's will. But for the French, the "victory" led to a massive mutiny in 1917. The soldiers were done being slaughtered for inches of dirt.
What most people get wrong about the outcome
People often think "winning" means gaining territory. At Verdun, the French won by staying put. They regained their lost forts, sure, but the victory was purely defensive.
Another misconception? That it was a purely French vs. German affair. While those were the primary combatants, the British offensive at the Somme was what actually saved the French at Verdun. If the British hadn't started their own massive attack in July 1916, the Germans might have had enough reserves to finish the job at Verdun. It was a team effort, even if the French bore the brunt of the horror.
The legacy of the "Bone-Mill"
Verdun changed how we think about war. It wasn't about maneuver or brilliant cavalry charges. It was industrial slaughter. It was the first time "logistics" became more important than "bravery." If the trucks on the Sacred Way had stopped, the battle would have ended in a week.
🔗 Read more: Trump New Gun Laws: What Most People Get Wrong
Today, the Douaumont Ossuary holds the remains of 130,000 unidentified soldiers—both French and German—mixed together. It’s a powerful symbol. It tells you that in the end, the earth didn't care who won.
If you're looking for the definitive answer to battle of verdun who won, remember these points:
- Strategically: France won because they maintained their lines and the German objective (attrition) failed.
- Tactically: It was a draw for most of the year, ending in a French recovery of lost ground.
- Humanly: Everyone lost. The sheer scale of trauma defined the French psyche for decades, contributing to their collapse in 1940.
To really understand the impact, you have to look at the "Zone Rouge." There are still areas around Verdun where the soil is so poisoned with lead, arsenic, and unexploded shells that nothing can be built there. Over a century later, the battle isn't really over. It's just sleeping.
What you should do next to learn more
If you're a history buff or just curious, don't just read a textbook. Check out the World War I series by Peter Hart for a deep look at the soldier's perspective. Or, if you're ever in France, skip the Eiffel Tower for a day and take the train to Verdun. Seeing the "forest" that is actually a series of shell craters covered in trees changes your perspective on what "winning" a war actually means. You can also look into the memoirs of soldiers who survived, like those collected in The Price of Glory by Alistair Horne, which remains the gold standard for English-language books on this specific battle. Dive into the logistics of the Voie Sacrée to see how a single road changed world history.