Batman died in 1988. Well, Jason Todd did. Fans actually called a 1-900 number to vote for his execution, and by a slim margin of 72 votes, DC Comics let the Joker beat a teenager to death with a crowbar. For decades, that was the status quo. Then came 2010.
When Batman: Under the Red Hood hit shelves as a direct-to-video animated feature, nobody really expected it to become the gold standard for DC storytelling. It did. Honestly, it’s better than most of what we’ve seen in theaters over the last decade. It’s gritty. It’s lean. It doesn't waste your time with origin stories we've seen a thousand times.
The film adapts the sprawling comic arc by Judd Winick, who also wrote the screenplay. That’s probably why it feels so cohesive. It’s a tragedy disguised as a high-octane crime thriller.
The Red Hood film is basically a lesson in how to handle a legacy
Most superhero movies struggle with stakes. If a character dies, they’re back in two years with a shiny new suit. But in the world of Batman: Under the Red Hood, the resurrection of Jason Todd isn't a cheap gimmick; it’s Bruce Wayne’s greatest failure coming back to haunt him in a leather jacket.
Jensen Ackles voiced Jason. Most people know him from Supernatural, but his performance here is visceral. You can hear the throat-tearing rage when he confronts Batman about why the Joker is still breathing. It's not just "villain" dialogue. It's the sound of a betrayed son.
Bruce Greenwood plays Batman, and he brings a weary, parental weight to the role that even Kevin Conroy—the GOAT—sometimes traded for pure authority. This film understands that the conflict isn't about who can punch harder. It’s a philosophical debate held over gunpoint and batarangs.
Why does it work so well?
🔗 Read more: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
Focus.
The movie clocks in at under 80 minutes. In that time, it establishes Black Mask as a legitimate (and hilarious) threat, introduces the mysterious Red Hood, executes a perfect Ra's al Ghul cameo, and delivers a finale that still makes people get misty-eyed on Twitter.
What most people get wrong about Jason Todd’s return
There’s this misconception that Jason Todd came back as a "villain." He didn't. He came back as a pragmatist.
In the Red Hood film, Jason’s logic is terrifyingly sound. He doesn't want to end crime; he wants to control it. He tells the Gotham mob bosses that he’ll take 40% of their earnings in exchange for protection from both Batman and the police. His only rule? No selling to kids.
It’s a middle ground that Batman’s morality can’t touch.
Brandon Vietti, the director, used a very specific visual style here. Gotham feels damp and claustrophobic. The action sequences are fluid but heavy. When a punch lands, the sound design makes sure you feel the bone-crunching impact. This isn't the sanitized action of the Justice League cartoons. It’s messy.
💡 You might also like: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
The Joker Factor
John DiMaggio took a massive risk with his Joker portrayal. Everyone compares every Joker to Mark Hamill or Heath Ledger. DiMaggio didn't try to mimic them. His Joker is a brick wall of a human being—slower, deeper-voiced, and utterly sadistic in a way that feels more like a mob enforcer than a clown.
When he’s being beaten by Red Hood in that final act, he’s laughing. Not because it’s funny, but because he knows he’s already won. He broke the Bat's family. That’s the psychological depth that live-action films often trade for "damaged" tattoos or fancy cinematography.
Why the animation holds up in 2026
Even sixteen years later, the animation by Warner Bros. Animation holds a certain grit that modern CG-heavy projects lack. There's a scene where Nightwing (voiced by Neil Patrick Harris, surprisingly) and Batman chase Red Hood across the rooftops. The sense of momentum is incredible. It’s one of the few times you actually see how fast these characters have to be to survive.
- The choreography is grounded in actual martial arts.
- The color palette shifts from the neon-blue of Nightwing to the harsh, blood-red of the climax.
- The "Lazarus Pit" sequence is handled with a psychedelic horror vibe that actually explains Jason’s instability without a ten-minute monologue.
Honestly, if you look at the 2020 interactive "sequel" Batman: Death in the Family, it almost feels unnecessary. The original 2010 film said everything that needed to be said. It explored the trauma of the "Boy Wonder" mantle and the impossible burden of being Batman’s partner.
The climax that redefined Batman’s "One Rule"
We have to talk about the bathroom scene. Not a sentence I usually write, but the final confrontation in a dilapidated apartment building is the heart of the story.
Jason gives Batman an ultimatum. He holds a gun to the Joker’s head and hands Batman a gun. "Him or me," he says. It’s the ultimate trolley problem.
📖 Related: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
This isn't just about the Red Hood film being "cool." It’s about the fact that Batman’s refusal to kill the Joker isn't just a moral code—to Jason, it's a personal insult. It means the "code" is more important than the life Jason lost.
The nuanced writing here is what separates this from a generic "superhero vs. anti-hero" story. You actually sympathize with Jason. You see the tragedy of a man who was raised to be a hero but was broken by the very world he was supposed to save.
Where to go from here
If you’ve watched the movie and want more, don’t just jump into the Titans live-action show. It tries to adapt this story and, frankly, misses the mark by making Jason too whiny.
Instead, look for the Under the Hood trade paperback by Judd Winick. It gives you the internal monologue that the movie had to skip. You’ll see the detective work Bruce did to figure out Jason was alive, which involves some wild stuff with Hush and Clayface that the movie wisely trimmed for time.
Also, check out the Red Hood and the Outlaws (Rebirth) run by Scott Lobdell. It’s a different vibe—more of a "dark Trinity" with Bizarro and Artemis—but it shows Jason's evolution from a vengeful ghost to a leader.
The Red Hood film remains a masterclass because it didn't try to build a cinematic universe. It just tried to tell a story about a father and his lost son. In an era of three-hour epics and "multiverse" fatigue, there is something incredibly refreshing about a 75-minute movie that hits you like a freight train and leaves you thinking about it for days.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Watch the "Death in the Family" Interactive Short: If you have the Blu-ray, play through the "branching" paths to see what would happen if Jason survived the warehouse explosion. It’s a fascinating "What If?" scenario.
- Track down the 2010 Special Features: There is a great documentary on the disc called Robin's Reckoning that explores the history of the sidekick in DC Comics.
- Compare the Score: Listen to Christopher Drake’s soundtrack on Spotify. It uses heavy electronic beats mixed with orchestral dread, which set the tone for the Arkham games later on.