The red and white neon sign used to be a beacon on 32nd Ave W. For decades, if you lived in Magnolia, Bartell Drugs wasn’t just a store—it was the place you went for a last-minute birthday card, a scoop of Cascade Pride ice cream, or a prescription refill from a pharmacist who actually knew your name. It felt permanent. But as of late 2025, that era has officially ended.
Honestly, walking past the empty storefront at 2222 32nd Ave W feels weird. It’s quiet. The "Former Bartell Drugs" leasing signs are up, and the neighborhood is still figuring out how to fill the void. This wasn’t just a retail closure; it was the death of a 135-year-old Seattle legacy that got swallowed up by corporate bankruptcy and shifting market forces.
What Happened to Bartell Drugs Magnolia Seattle?
The downfall didn't happen overnight, but when it hit, it hit fast. Most people remember the 2020 announcement: Rite Aid bought Bartell Drugs for $95 million. At the time, they promised to keep the Bartell name and the local feel. It sounded okay on paper, but the reality was a slow-motion car crash.
Rite Aid filed for its first bankruptcy in 2023. By 2025, a second bankruptcy filing effectively ended the company's run. The Magnolia location, which anchored the Magnolia Village Center, was caught in the middle of a massive liquidation. On September 27, 2025, the last three Bartell stores in the region turned off their lights for good. Magnolia's store was one of the victims.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today
You might be wondering why CVS didn't just take it over. While CVS did snap up a lot of Bartell’s assets and prescription files (over 600 locations nationwide), they didn't keep every physical storefront open. In Magnolia, the prescription records were transitioned to other nearby pharmacies, leaving the 18,369-square-foot building sitting empty.
The Real Impact on the Village
Magnolia is a bit of an island. If you live there, you know that leaving "the hill" can be a chore, especially with the bridge traffic. Having a full-service pharmacy and grocery hybrid right in the Village was a lifeline for the older residents and young families alike.
Now? The retail landscape in the Village is shifting. The property at 2230 32nd Ave W recently traded hands for about $8 million. The new owners are looking at a space that is massive by neighborhood standards. It’s "excellent box retail," as the brokers say, but for locals, it’s just a big hole where the heart of the shopping district used to be.
🔗 Read more: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
Where to Get Your Medics Now
With Bartell Drugs Magnolia Seattle gone, you’ve basically got a few options left, and none of them are quite as convenient as the old walk-to-the-Village routine.
- Safeway Pharmacy: Located at 2550 32nd Ave W, this is now the primary "on the hill" option. It’s reliable, but the lines have definitely gotten longer since the Bartell closure.
- CVS Pharmacy: While they bought the Bartell files, the physical locations are mostly outside Magnolia. You’re looking at a drive to Queen Anne or Ballard.
- Independent Options: Some locals have started looking at smaller, independent pharmacies or delivery services like Scripps, which has been picking up former Bartell customers who are tired of the big-chain chaos.
It’s Kinda About More Than Just Pills
The thing about Bartells was the "Seattle-ness" of it. They carried local brands like Oberto jerky and Theo Chocolate long before it was trendy. They had a toy aisle that could save any parent heading to a 5-year-old’s birthday party.
When George H. Bartell Sr. started this whole thing in 1890, he lived in the back of his first store. That grit and local focus stayed with the brand for over a century. Seeing it vanish because of a corporate bankruptcy based in Pennsylvania (Rite Aid's headquarters) feels like a betrayal of that history.
💡 You might also like: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
Actionable Steps for Magnolia Residents
If you’re still mourning the loss of your local pharmacy or trying to navigate the "new normal" in the Village, here’s what you should actually do:
1. Confirm Your Prescription Transfer
If you haven't filled a script since the late 2025 closures, don't just show up at Safeway. Call your doctor and verify where your "active" files are. Many were moved to CVS locations by default, but you can have them sent anywhere you want.
2. Support the Remaining Village Businesses
The loss of an "anchor tenant" like Bartells is a nightmare for small neighboring shops. Foot traffic in the Village depends on people having a reason to be there. Make a conscious effort to hit the local coffee shops and boutiques so the Village doesn't lose more than just its drugstore.
3. Explore Delivery for Specialty Meds
If you have mobility issues and the Safeway line is too much, look into mail-order options through your insurance. It’s not the same as chatting with the pharmacist you’ve known for ten years, but it beats the parking headache in the Safeway lot.
The space at 2222 32nd Ave W will eventually find a new tenant. Whether it's a specialty grocer, a fitness center, or another retail chain, the "Bartell Drugs Magnolia Seattle" era is officially in the history books. It’s a reminder that even the most "permanent" neighborhood staples are vulnerable to the whims of the national retail market.