Collecting is a weird, emotional business. If you’d told a Cleveland fan in 2020 that they’d eventually be hunting for a Baker Mayfield autographed jersey in a different shade of red, they might have thrown their remote at you. But here we are. It’s early 2026, and the market for Baker memorabilia is doing something most experts didn't see coming: it's actually stabilizing.
He isn't just a "bridge" quarterback anymore. He's found a home in Tampa, and that shift has completely changed how collectors value his signature. When he was bouncing from the Panthers to the Rams, you could snag a signed piece for peanuts. Now? Not so much. People are actually paying a premium for that #6 Buccaneers jersey, especially the Creamsicle throwbacks.
The Massive Price Gap: Browns vs. Buccaneers Gear
Values are all over the place right now. You’ll find old Cleveland Browns jerseys—the ones with the "18 #1 Pick" inscriptions—floating around for roughly $175 to $250. They're historical markers, sure. But the demand just isn't there compared to the Tampa stuff.
Honestly, it’s a supply and demand thing. There are thousands of Browns jerseys out there from his early-career hype. His Tampa Bay gear is newer, and because he’s actually winning games there, it’s what everyone wants. A standard signed Bucs home red jersey usually sits between $210 and $300. If you’re looking at a Nike Vapor Limited or a framed "Fire the Cannons" inscribed piece, you're easily clearing $500.
Then you have the Sooners gear. Oklahoma fans are a different breed of loyal. A Baker Mayfield autographed jersey in that classic crimson remains the gold standard for Heisman collectors. Don't be shocked to see authentic Oklahoma jerseys—especially those with "HT 17" (Heisman Trophy 2017) inscriptions—listed for $400 or more.
📖 Related: The 2024 Dodgers World Series Run: What Actually Happened and Why the Yankees Melted Down
Don't Get Burned by Fakes: The Authenticity Checklist
The worst feeling in this hobby is opening a box and realizing the "Sharpie" looks a little too shaky. Counterfeits are everywhere. You’ve got to be smart.
- The Big Three Rule: If it doesn't have a COA (Certificate of Authenticity) from Beckett (BAS), JSA (James Spence), or PSA/DNA, basically keep your wallet closed. These companies use forensic experts to verify the ink.
- Fanatics Authentic: Baker has had exclusive deals with Fanatics in the past. If you see a Fanatics hologram on a jersey, it’s like a digital fingerprint. You can type that number into their database, and it’ll tell you exactly when and where Baker sat down to sign it.
- The "Too Good to be True" Test: If someone on a random social media marketplace is selling a "hand-signed" jersey for $60, it’s a fake. Or it’s a "custom" jersey, which is code for a cheap knock-off fabric that isn't licensed by the NFL.
Custom jerseys are a point of contention. You’ll see them a lot on eBay—they have the name and numbers, but no team logos. They’re way cheaper, often around $120. They’re fine for a man cave if you just want the signature, but they don't hold value like an official Nike jersey does.
Why 2026 is the "Sweet Spot" for Buyers
Timing is everything in the memorabilia world. Right now, Baker is a proven veteran. He's past the "bust" allegations but hasn't yet reached the "legend" retirement status where prices skyrocket due to scarcity.
He’s also still active with fans. In July 2025, he was out at training camp signing for the "Krewe," and there have been various private signings throughout early 2026. This keeps the supply healthy. When a player stops signing regularly, the prices for a Baker Mayfield autographed jersey will likely creep up another 20%.
✨ Don't miss: Who Won the Dodger Game? A Breakdown of Last Night’s Result and Why It Happened
Framing and Preservation
If you’re dropping $400 on a jersey, don't just pin it to the wall. Sweat and UV light are the enemies of ink.
Go for a shadow box with UV-protected glass. It’s worth the extra $100 to $150. Many professional framers will also include a "floating" mount so the jersey looks 3D. If you buy a pre-framed piece from a site like SportsMemorabilia.com, you’re looking at a total cost of around $750 to $1,000, but it’s ready to hang and protected forever.
How to Source Your Jersey Today
If you want the real deal right now, your best bets are the big-box authenticators.
- Fanatics / NFL Shop: These are the most expensive but the most "bulletproof" in terms of authenticity.
- Beckett Marketplace: Great for finding unique inscriptions or older Cleveland/Oklahoma gear.
- Pristine Auction: If you’re feeling lucky, you can sometimes win a jersey for under market value here, but keep an eye on those "buyer's premiums" (extra fees) that can tack on an extra 17-20% at the end.
Check the hologram before you bid. Search the serial number on the authenticator's website. If the database entry matches the item in the photo, you're good to go.
Actionable Next Steps
- Verify the serial: Take any jersey you're looking at and run the COA number through the PSA, JSA, or Beckett database immediately.
- Compare "Custom" vs "Authentic": Decide if you want a $120 "no-logo" jersey for display or a $500 Nike jersey as an investment.
- Check the inscription: Look for "Heisman 17" or "1st Pick" for long-term value, as these are harder to find than a standard signature.