Honestly, walking into a performance of the Bach St Matthew Passion (or Matthäus-Passion, if you want to be fancy) is a bit like committing to a Marvel movie marathon, but with way more crying and much better woodwinds. It’s long. It’s heavy. And it’s arguably the most ambitious thing anyone ever did with a quill pen and some ink.
For three hours, you’re basically trapped in a room with Johann Sebastian Bach’s brain, and he’s not letting you leave until you’ve felt every ounce of betrayal, guilt, and grief possible.
The "Great Passion" vs. Everything Else
Most people know Bach for those catchy cello suites or the stuff they play at weddings, but the Bach St Matthew Passion is a different beast entirely. Bach’s own family used to call it "the great Passion" simply because of its sheer scale. While his St. John Passion is like a fast-paced, jagged thriller, St. Matthew is a sprawling, cinematic epic.
Think about the logistical nightmare Bach created for the 1727 premiere at the Thomaskirche in Leipzig. He didn't just want a choir. He wanted two. Plus two separate orchestras. And then, just for kicks, a third "ripieno" choir of kids to sing over the top of the opening movement.
It was basically the 18th-century version of surround sound.
He even wrote the score in different colored inks. Red ink for the Bible verses. Black for everything else. He knew this was his masterpiece. He treated the physical manuscript like a holy relic, carefully sewing up the pages himself when they started to fray.
What Most People Get Wrong About the "Halo"
If you’ve ever listened to the Bach St Matthew Passion, you might have noticed something weird about the voice of Jesus. Whenever he speaks, he’s surrounded by this warm, glowing shimmer of strings. Most music geeks call this the "halo." It's beautiful. It's divine.
But here’s the kicker: at the very end, when Jesus is on the cross and cries out, "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?", the halo vanishes.
Bach pulls the strings away.
Suddenly, the voice is supported by nothing but a cold, lonely organ. It’s a brutal musical trick. He’s showing you—not telling you—that the "divine" protection is gone and only the human man is left. It’s a gut punch that still works 300 years later.
A Quick Breakdown of the Players
- The Evangelist: A high tenor who acts as your narrator. He’s the one moving the plot along at breakneck speed.
- Jesus: A bass-baritone who gets the "string halo" (until he doesn't).
- The Turba Choruses: These are the "crowd" scenes. When the choir starts screaming "Crucify him!" it’s meant to be terrifying and chaotic.
- The Chorales: These are the simple, hymn-like moments where everyone (historically the congregation) takes a breath and reflects.
The 100-Year Ghost Story
Believe it or not, the Bach St Matthew Passion almost disappeared. After Bach died in 1750, people kinda... forgot about it. They thought Bach was a "musical mathematician"—someone who wrote dry, complicated exercises rather than emotional music.
It sat in a library for decades.
Then comes Felix Mendelssohn. In 1829, at just 20 years old, he decided to bring it back. He had to cut a bunch of it (people didn't have the attention span for three hours even back then) and swapped out some of the weird old instruments like the oboe da caccia for clarinets.
That single performance in Berlin didn't just save the Passion; it basically started the "Bach Revival." We literally wouldn't be talking about Bach today if Mendelssohn hadn't been an obsessive fanboy.
Why It’s Actually Semi-Scandalous
When it was first performed, some people in Leipzig were actually offended. One elderly lady reportedly screamed, "God help us, 'tis surely an opera-comedy!"
In the 1720s, church music was supposed to be humble and restrained. Bach brought in double orchestras and dramatic, theatrical arias. He was pushing the boundaries of what was "allowed" in a house of worship. He was using every trick in the book—word-painting, dissonance, complex counterpoint—to make the listener feel the physical pain of the story.
How to Actually Listen to It (Without Getting Bored)
You don't need to be a musicologist or a religious scholar to get this piece. Honestly, just look for the "Erbarme dich" aria. It’s for an alto voice and a solo violin. It’s about Peter’s regret after he realizes he betrayed his best friend.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Willie Nelson A Song for You Cover Still Hits So Hard
The violin literally sounds like it’s sobbing.
If that doesn't move you, check your pulse.
Practical Tips for Your First Listen
- Don't do it all at once. It’s okay to listen to Part I (the first hour and change), go get a coffee, and come back for Part II.
- Follow the libretto. Even if you don't speak German, knowing when the "crowd" is yelling versus when a solo voice is "thinking out loud" helps you navigate the structure.
- Watch a "ritualized" version. Some modern conductors, like Sir Simon Rattle, have staged the Passion where the singers move around like actors. It makes the "double choir" dialogue way easier to follow.
- Look for the "O Sacred Head Now Wounded" tune. This melody shows up five different times throughout the work, but each time it’s harmonized differently to match the mood of the story. It’s like a recurring theme in a movie score.
The Bach St Matthew Passion isn't just a piece of "old music." It’s a massive, messy, beautiful exploration of what it means to be human—to fail, to mourn, and to hope. Whether you see it in a cathedral or listen to it on your AirPods while commuting, it demands your full attention.
And it usually earns it.
🔗 Read more: Why Tom of Finland’s Kake and the Highway Patrol Series Still Define Queer Art
If you're ready to dive in, start by finding the 1958 Karl Richter recording for a "classic" feel, or the Philippe Herreweghe recordings if you want something that sounds a bit more lean and transparent. Just make sure you have some tissues nearby for the final chorus, "Wir setzen uns mit Tränen nieder." It’s a doozy.
Next Steps for You
- Listen to "Erbarme dich": Find a version on YouTube (search for Julia Hamari or Lorraine Hunt Lieberson) to hear the most famous aria.
- Compare the Passions: Spend 15 minutes listening to the opening of the St. John Passion versus the St. Matthew to hear the difference between "anxiety" and "solemnity."
- Check Local Schedules: Many cities perform this work during the Lenten season or around Easter; seeing it live is a completely different sensory experience than a recording.