You’re staring at a tiny piece of blue-and-white mesh encased in a thick slab of plastic. It’s a "relic," a "swatch," a "memorabilia card." To the uninitiated, it’s a scrap of fabric. To a hockey collector, that Auston Matthews jersey card is a tangible piece of the "Papi" legacy. But here is the thing: not all jersey cards are created equal. In fact, if you’re buying strictly for investment, most of them are kinda... well, disappointing.
Most people think "game-used" is a universal term. It isn't. If you’ve been scouring eBay or your local card show, you've probably seen cards ranging from $15 to $5,000. Why the massive gap? It’s because the industry has a hierarchy that isn't always obvious to the casual fan.
The "Game-Used" vs. "Player-Worn" Trap
Here is the dirty little secret of the modern hobby. Some cards say "Game-Used Memorabilia." Others say "Player-Worn." There is a massive difference.
Basically, "Game-Used" means Matthews actually wore that jersey during an NHL game—dodging hits, scoring goals, and sweating in it. "Player-Worn" often means he threw the jersey on for thirty seconds at a photoshoot, took it off, and signed some papers. For a superstar like Matthews, collectors want the grit of an actual game. If you’re looking at an Auston Matthews jersey card from a lower-end set like Upper Deck Series 1, check the back. If it doesn't explicitly say "Game-Used," the value won't ever hit the stratosphere.
🔗 Read more: Scottie Barnes Last 10 Games: Why the Raptors Star is Finally Redefining His Ceiling
Honestly, the "event-worn" stuff is fine for a personal collection, but it won't pay for your retirement. You’ve got to look for the "Game-Used" stamp if you want the real deal.
Which Sets Actually Matter?
If you're hunting for a jersey card that holds value, you need to know where to look. Not every box of cards is going to have a winner.
- The Cup: This is the "Holy Grail." An Auston Matthews jersey card from The Cup (especially the Rookie Patch Auto or RPA) can sell for the price of a mid-sized sedan. We’re talking five figures for a PSA 10 or BGS 9.5.
- SP Game Used: This set is literally built around jersey swatches. You can find "Draft Day" jerseys, "Net Cord" relics, and even pieces of the glass.
- Upper Deck Artifacts: This is usually the first place you'll find a Matthews jersey card each season. They’re beautiful, often featuring "dual" or "triple" relics where you get a piece of Matthews' jersey alongside teammates like Mitch Marner or William Nylander.
- Premier: These cards are thick. I mean really thick. They usually feature "Jumbo" patches, which are way cooler than the tiny little square swatches.
Why the "Patch" is King
You’ll hear people use "Jersey" and "Patch" interchangeably. Don’t do that.
A "Jersey" card is usually just a plain white or blue piece of the jersey's torso. It’s flat. It’s one color. A "Patch" card comes from the logo, the numbers, or the shoulder patches. These have multiple colors, stitching, and texture.
If you find an Auston Matthews jersey card that features a piece of the Maple Leafs' "Leaf" logo—maybe a bit of the white vein in the blue leaf—you’ve hit the jackpot. Collectors call these "multi-color patches," and they are significantly more rare than plain swatches. In 2026, a 2-color patch from a 2016-17 rookie year set is basically a blue-chip stock.
Understanding the Market Value in 2026
Prices for Matthews are weirdly volatile. When he hits a scoring slump, the "weak hands" sell off. When he’s chasing 70 goals, the prices go parabolic.
Currently, a base Auston Matthews jersey card from a recent year (like 2023-24 or 2024-25) might only set you back $20 to $40. That's affordable! But if you go back to his 2016-17 rookie season, even a plain jersey relic can fetch $200+.
The "National Selections" jersey cards from the Tim Hortons sets are also surprisingly popular. They’re "retail" cards, meaning you get them at a coffee shop, but because so many people collect the set, the demand stays high.
Spotting a Fake (Yes, They Exist)
It’s sad, but "patch swapping" is a real thing. Scammers take a cheap Auston Matthews jersey card with a plain white swatch, pry the card open, and replace it with a colorful patch they cut out of a knock-off jersey.
How do you tell? Look at the edges of the window where the fabric is. If there are glue stains or if the cardboard looks fuzzy or tampered with, run away. Authentic Upper Deck cards have very clean, die-cut windows. Also, if a patch looks too good—like a 4-color piece of the logo in a $20 card—it’s probably a fake.
Why You Should (Or Shouldn't) Buy Now
Look, Matthews is already a legend in Toronto. He’s going to break every franchise record. From a "long-term hold" perspective, his jersey cards are some of the safest bets in hockey.
However, don't buy the hype during the playoffs. That's when prices are at their peak. The best time to buy an Auston Matthews jersey card is usually in the dead of July or August when everyone is thinking about baseball or the beach.
Actionable Advice for Collectors:
- Check the authentication: Ensure the card is from a reputable manufacturer like Upper Deck. Panini doesn't have the NHL license anymore, so "unlicensed" jersey cards (like Leaf brand) usually sell for much less.
- Go for the "Rookie" Year: If you have the budget, always prioritize 2016-17 cards.
- Condition is everything: Even if the jersey piece is cool, if the corners of the card are soft or the surface is scratched, the value drops by 50% or more.
- Look for "Prime": In many sets, "Prime" is the keyword for a patch. A "Series 1 Game Used Jersey" is okay; an "Artifacts Emerald Prime Patch" is elite.
Buying an Auston Matthews jersey card is about owning a piece of history. Just make sure you aren't paying "patch prices" for a "player-worn" scrap. Read the fine print, check the stitching, and always buy the card, not the hype.
Next Steps for Your Collection:
Check the back of any Matthews card you currently own. Look specifically for the phrase "Certified to have been used in an official NHL game." If it says "Player-Worn" or "Event-Used," consider trading up to a true "Game-Used" version to ensure better long-term value retention. If you are buying on a budget, look for "Jersey" cards from Upper Deck's SP Game Used set, as they provide the best balance between price and authentic game-worn provenance.