It’s been years. Yet, if you drop a single mention of Attack on Titan Ch 139 into a group chat or a subreddit, you’re basically pulling the pin on a thermal grenade. People just can't let it go. Whether you think Hajime Isayama delivered a poetic masterstroke or you're still mourning the "Chad Eren" theory that never came to be, the final chapter remains one of the most polarizing pieces of fiction in modern history.
It changed everything.
Honestly, looking back at the raw scans from April 2021, the chaos was immediate. The chapter, titled "Toward the Tree on That Hill," didn't just end a story; it recontextualized 11 years of character development in about 45 pages. It was messy. It was emotional. It was, for a lot of people, deeply confusing.
🔗 Read more: Argentina National Anthem Song: What Most People Get Wrong
What Actually Happened in Attack on Titan Ch 139?
Eren Yeager is dead. Mikasa Ackerman is the one who did it. That’s the baseline, but the "why" is where things get complicated. The chapter opens with a path-walk between Eren and Armin, occurring chronologically during the boat trip in Chapter 131 but revealed to us only after Eren's death.
Eren explains his master plan—or lack thereof. He tells Armin he pushed everyone away to turn them into heroes. By becoming the ultimate villain and initiating the Rumbling, he forced the Alliance to kill him, theoretically making the surviving Eldians look like the saviors of humanity in the eyes of the remaining 20% of the world.
It’s a grim gamble.
We also get the reveal that Ymir Fritz, the founder, was actually in love with King Fritz. This part? It’s still a huge sticking point for fans. Isayama suggests Ymir was bound by a "twisted love," and she needed to see someone—Mikasa—kill the person they loved for the sake of the world to finally free herself from the Paths.
Then comes the breakdown. Eren, the man who moved forward until his enemies were destroyed, cries on the ground because he doesn't want Mikasa to find another man. "I want her to think about me and no one else for a while! Ten years at least!"
👉 See also: Why That New Movie About A Christmas Carol Isn't Just Another Scrooge Retelling
That single panel launched a thousand memes.
The Fallout of the Rumbling
The titans are gone. Every Pure Titan reverts to human form. Jean, Connie, Gabi—they all get their humanity back. Even the Power of the Titans evaporates from the world, leaving the Shifters with normal lifespans.
But peace? Peace is a different story.
The world isn't suddenly "fixed." The 20% of humanity that survived is terrified and furious. Paradis Island, now under the control of the Yeagerist faction, is militarizing for a potential counter-attack. The final pages show our main cast—Armin, Jean, Reiner, Annie, Pieck—acting as ambassadors for the Allied Nations, sailing back to Paradis to tell their story.
It’s an ending that refuses to give you a "happily ever after." It tells us that as long as there are two people left on earth, there will be conflict.
Why People Hate It (and Why People Defend It)
The backlash against Attack on Titan Ch 139 wasn't just about the plot. It was about the "vibe shift." For years, the fandom had built up this image of Eren as a cold, calculating god. When he reverted to a pathetic, crying 19-year-old, some felt it was a betrayal of his growth.
- The Pro-Ending Argument: Fans argue this was the "real" Eren. He was always a "crybaby" (his own words from early chapters). He was a kid burdened with the power of a god, trapped in a deterministic timeline where he saw his own future and couldn't change it. His breakdown was human.
- The Anti-Ending Argument: Critics feel the "Ymir loved King Fritz" plot point came out of nowhere and felt gross. They argue that Eren killing his own mother (revealed in this chapter via the Dina Fritz twist) was an unnecessary shock factor that undermined his original motivation.
Isayama himself admitted in interviews, specifically with Bessatsu Shonen Magazine, that he felt the themes of the ending were difficult to express and that he struggled with the final execution. This led to the "Extra Pages" in the Volume 34 release.
The Extra Pages: A Final Twist
If the original 139 felt a bit too hopeful, the added pages in the final volume fixed that real quick. We see a montage of the future. Mikasa lives a long life (seemingly with Jean, though it’s never explicitly stated). She dies of old age.
🔗 Read more: Why the One Piece Anime Flag Matters More Than You Think
Then, we see Shiganshina.
It grows into a modern metropolis with skyscrapers and SAM sites. And then? It gets carpet-bombed. Totally destroyed. The cycle of hatred didn't end; it just hit the reset button. The very last panel shows a boy and his dog walking toward a massive, familiar-looking tree—the same kind of tree where Ymir originally found the "source of all living matter."
It’s a cynical, haunting loop.
Technical Mastery or Narrative Fatigue?
From a technical standpoint, Isayama's art in Attack on Titan Ch 139 is some of his most detailed. The way he mirrors the first chapter—"To You, 2,000 Years From Now"—with the finale is structurally brilliant.
But you can feel the weight of the series.
Ending a global phenomenon is an impossible task. Just ask the Game of Thrones writers or the Lost creators. Isayama had to tie up the Marley-Eldia conflict, the Titan origin story, the Eren-Mikasa-Armin trio dynamic, and the philosophical question of freedom.
He chose to focus on the tragedy of Eren Yeager.
Eren didn't win. He didn't lose. He just... ended. He became a "slave to freedom," as some fans put it. He was so obsessed with the concept of being free that he followed a path of genocide because he saw no other way to ensure his friends' survival.
Key Takeaways for Your Next Rewatch
If you’re going back to look for clues that lead to Attack on Titan Ch 139, keep these things in mind:
- Eren’s Eyes: Notice how often Eren’s eyes are clouded or shadowed after the time skip. He’s not in the driver's seat; he’s a passenger to his own memories.
- The Bird Imagery: The bird that wraps the scarf around Mikasa isn't just a metaphor. In the world of AoT, birds have always represented the freedom Eren craved.
- The Falco Connection: Falco’s name and his Jaw Titan (which has wings) were the biggest hints that the final battle would move to the sky, symbolizing a departure from the "earthbound" nature of the Titans.
The ending isn't perfect. The pacing in Chapter 139 is breakneck, and some dialogue—like Armin thanking Eren for becoming a mass murderer—was so poorly received that it was actually changed in the anime adaptation to be more nuanced. In the anime, Armin says, "We'll go to hell together," which feels much more in line with their bond.
Actionable Steps for AoT Fans
To truly appreciate (or properly critique) the conclusion, you have to look beyond the surface level of the "ending war."
- Read the "Attack on Titan Guidebook": It contains interviews where Isayama clarifies Eren’s mental state during the final chapters. It helps bridge the gap between "Sigma Eren" and "Whiny Eren."
- Compare the Manga to the Anime: Watch the final special. The MAPPA adaptation makes several small but vital script changes that clarify Eren's motivations and the timeline of the "Paths" conversations.
- Analyze the "School Castes" Previews: The "High School AU" pages at the end of previous volumes actually have a meta-conversation about the ending of the series itself. It’s Isayama talking directly to the readers.
The legacy of Attack on Titan Ch 139 isn't that it gave everyone what they wanted. It’s that it remained true to its core theme: the world is cruel, but it is also very beautiful. It didn't offer an easy escape. It offered a mirror to human nature, showing that even after the monsters are gone, the humans remain. And humans? We never change. We keep moving forward, for better or worse.