It happens every time a new season of Invincible drops or a classic Ben 10 clip goes viral on TikTok. Someone, somewhere, posts a side-by-side of Samantha Eve Wilkins and Gwendolyn Tennyson. The comments immediately devolve into a chaotic debate about mana versus subatomic manipulation. It’s not just the pink energy constructs, though that’s the obvious visual link. It’s the vibe. Both girls are the "smart ones" of their respective trios, often carrying the emotional (and literal) weight of the team while the boys figure out how to punch things harder.
Honestly, the comparison is deeper than just aesthetic. You’ve got two of the most competent female leads in Western animation history who both happen to wield reality-warping powers that look like neon cotton candy. But if you actually look at the lore, the mechanics of how they work—and the trauma they carry—are worlds apart.
The Science of Atom Eve vs. The Magic of Gwen Tennyson
Let's get into the weeds. Atom Eve isn't magic. At all. In the Invincible universe, created by Robert Kirkman, Eve’s powers are purely scientific, albeit "comic book science." She was a government experiment, a literal living weapon designed to manipulate matter at the molecular level. She sees the periodic table the way we see a Lego set. If she wants to turn a brick wall into a pile of gold coins or a gourmet dinner, she just... does. Her brain is basically a supercomputer that perceives the building blocks of the universe.
Gwen Tennyson is a different beast entirely. Well, a different alien-human hybrid, anyway. In the original 2005 Ben 10 run, Gwen was just a lucky kid with a knack for "lucky girl" magic and ancient spellbooks like the Charms of Bezel. Then Alien Force came along and flipped the script. We found out she’s part Anodite. Her grandmother, Verdona, is a being made of pure life energy—Mana. Gwen doesn't rearrange atoms; she draws from the life force of the universe itself.
It’s a fun distinction. Eve is a chemist with a god complex; Gwen is a conduit for the metaphysical. When Eve makes a shield, she’s hardening the air molecules. When Gwen makes a "mana disc," she’s shaping raw soul-energy into a physical form.
The Mental Block Problem
One thing people always forget about Atom Eve is her mental governor. The scientists who created her, specifically Dr. Brandyworth, were terrified of what a god-tier matter manipulator could do. So, they put a psychic block in her brain. She can’t affect organic matter—living things. She can’t heal a wound or turn a villain into a puddle of water unless she’s under extreme, near-death mental stress. This is a massive nerf that keeps the story interesting. Without it, Eve could just turn Omni-Man into a cloud of hydrogen and go home for lunch.
Gwen doesn't have a "governor," but she has a learning curve. In Ben 10: Ultimate Alien, we see her struggle with the temptation of her "True Form." If she lets go of her humanity, she becomes a being of pure light, incredibly powerful but potentially losing her soul in the process. It’s a classic "absolute power corrupts" trope, but played with a lot more nuance than you’d expect from a Saturday morning cartoon.
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Why the Fanbase Obsesses Over the "Pink" Connection
It’s kind of funny that the two most powerful women in these shows are color-coded pink. Historically, pink was the "girly" color, the "soft" color. But Eve and Gwen reclaimed it. For Eve, the pink costume was a middle finger to her restrictive, conservative upbringing. It was her choosing her own identity after her "father" tried to control every aspect of her life.
For Gwen, the shift from the blue/white aesthetic of the original series to the magenta/pink of Alien Force signaled her maturation. It’s a visual shorthand for power. When you see that pink glow in a dark alley, you know someone is about to get their molecules rearranged or blasted through a wall by an Anodite.
The Burden of Being the Competent One
If you watch Invincible or Ben 10 closely, you'll notice a pattern. Mark Grayson and Ben Tennyson are the protagonists, but they are often... well, they're idiots. They’re impulsive. They’re learning on the job.
Eve and Gwen are the anchors.
- Atom Eve: She literally starts her own humanitarian relief effort because she realizes superheroing is just reactive. She uses her powers to grow crops in droubt-stricken lands. She’s thinking on a global, systemic scale while Mark is still worried about his secret identity.
- Gwen Tennyson: She’s the one who researches the villains. She’s the one who maintains the team's tactical discipline. In the Alien Force era, Gwen is frequently the only thing keeping Ben and Kevin from killing each other or making a catastrophic mistake.
Can We Talk About the "Death" Scenes?
Both characters have had some pretty gnarly brushes with the afterlife. In the Invincible comics (specifically the later issues, so spoilers ahead), Eve’s mental blocks break down when she’s near death. She literally rebuilds her own body from scratch. She achieves a form of functional immortality. It’s terrifying and beautiful.
Gwen hasn't died in the traditional sense as often, but she’s been erased from time, had her soul stolen, and been possessed by interdimensional entities like Charmcaster and Dagon. The resilience these two show is what actually connects them. They aren't just "the girl" on the team. They are the tactical centers of gravity.
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
The Versatility Factor: Who Wins?
The "Who would win?" debate is a staple of Reddit’s r/whowouldwin. It’s a tough one.
If we’re talking raw, unchecked potential? Atom Eve. If her blocks are down, she controls the fundamental laws of physics. She could theoretically stop the electrical impulses in Gwen’s brain before Gwen could even mutter a spell.
However, Gwen’s mana is magic-adjacent. In many fictional universes, magic bypasses standard physics. Gwen can track people across dimensions, shield against mental attacks, and absorb energy. If Gwen can out-mana Eve’s atomic restructuring, she has a path to victory.
But honestly? They’d probably just get coffee and complain about how their boyfriends keep getting beaten into pulp by various aliens.
Real-World Impact and Legacy
It’s worth noting that Gwen Tennyson paved the way for characters like Atom Eve to be taken seriously in mainstream animation. Before Gwen, the "magic girl" on a boy’s action team was often relegated to shields and bubbles—the "defense" role. Gwen started that way but evolved into a powerhouse offensive threat.
Eve took that template and added a layer of R-rated existential dread. She asks the question: "If I can do anything, why am I just fighting monsters?" That's the hallmark of a great character—when their conflict is internal rather than just physical.
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Takeaways for Fans and Creators
If you’re looking to dive deeper into these characters or even write your own "powerhouse" female lead, there are specific things that make Eve and Gwen work so well.
1. Give the powers a cost or a limit. Eve has her mental block; Gwen has the risk of losing her humanity to her Anodite side. Without these limits, the characters become boring. Conflict is born from what a character can't do, not just what they can.
2. Focus on the "Day Job" of a Hero. Eve’s best moments aren't her fights; they’re her using her powers to help people in ways that don't involve punching. Gwen’s best moments are often her using her intelligence to solve a mystery the boys are too thick to see.
3. Visual Branding Matters. There is a reason why "The Pink One" is a trope. Using a color traditionally associated with one thing (softness) and applying it to something else (unfathomable power) creates a memorable visual contrast.
If you haven't read the Invincible comics, go find the Atom Eve standalone specials. They give a much grittier look at her origin than the show has reached yet. For Gwen, revisit the Highbreed arc in Alien Force. It’s where her characterization really hits its stride, moving away from the "annoying cousin" trope and into a legitimate leader.
These characters aren't just copies of each other. They are two different answers to the same question: What happens when you give a teenage girl the power to reshape the world? One uses science, one uses soul, and both of them end up being the most interesting people in the room.
Next Steps for Deep Diving:
- Check out the Invincible: Presenting Atom Eve comic for her full, uncensored origin story.
- Watch the Ben 10: Alien Force episode "In Charm's Way" to see the peak of Gwen’s tactical brilliance versus magical rivals.
- Analyze the color theory used in modern superhero animation to see how pink has transitioned from a "support" color to a "power" color across various franchises.