You know that feeling when a game is so over you start looking for the remote? That was basically the entire world on February 5, 2017. If you were watching the Atlanta Falcons vs New England Patriots Super Bowl (LI, for the Roman numeral buffs), you probably remember exactly where you were when the score hit 28-3. Honestly, most of us thought the Patriots were cooked. Done. Stick a fork in 'em.
The Falcons were flying. Matt Ryan was looking every bit like the league MVP he was. Devonta Freeman was slicing through the defense. Even the halftime show with Lady Gaga felt like a victory lap for the city of Atlanta. But then, the weirdest 17 minutes in sports history happened.
Why the 28-3 Lead Felt Like a Lock
Let’s be real: no one comes back from 25 points down in a Super Bowl. Before this game, the largest comeback in the history of the big game was just 10 points. The Falcons had a 99.6% win probability late in the third quarter. Think about that. You have a better chance of getting struck by lightning while winning the lottery than the Patriots had of winning that game.
Atlanta wasn't just winning; they were dominating. Robert Alford’s 82-yard pick-six on Tom Brady in the second quarter felt like the final nail. It was the first time Brady had ever thrown a pick-six in the postseason. You saw the look on his face. He looked old. He looked frustrated. The Patriots went into the locker room down 21-3, and it only got worse when Tevin Coleman caught a touchdown to make it 28-3 with 8:31 left in the third.
The Turning Point Nobody Saw Coming
The comeback didn't happen all at once. It was a slow, painful grind. It started with a 5-yard touchdown pass to James White. But even then, Stephen Gostkowski missed the extra point. Score: 28-9. It felt like a "too little, too late" moment.
👉 See also: Why the 2025 NFL Draft Class is a Total Headache for Scouts
But then the Falcons' offense, which had been a well-oiled machine, started to sputter. Kyle Shanahan, the Falcons' offensive coordinator at the time, has taken a lot of heat for his play-calling in the fourth quarter. Instead of running the ball to bleed the clock, they kept passing.
The biggest mistake? The Dont'a Hightower strip-sack.
With about 8:30 left in the game, the Falcons faced a 3rd-and-1 at their own 36. A simple run probably gets the first down or at least burns more time. Instead, they dropped back. Hightower came off the edge like a heat-seeking missile, blasted Matt Ryan, and the Patriots recovered. That was the moment the energy in NRG Stadium shifted. You could actually feel the panic setting in on the Atlanta sideline.
The Catch and the Collapse
Even after the Patriots cut it to 28-20, Atlanta had a chance to put it away. Julio Jones—who is a literal cheat code—made a sideline catch that defied physics. It put the Falcons at the Patriots' 22-yard line with 4:40 to go.
✨ Don't miss: Liverpool FC Chelsea FC: Why This Grudge Match Still Hits Different
All they needed was a field goal.
Matt Bryant was one of the most reliable kickers in the league.
A couple of runs, three points, game over.
Instead, a 12-yard sack by Trey Flowers and a holding penalty pushed them out of field goal range. They had to punt. It was a catastrophic sequence of events. Brady got the ball back at his own 9-yard line with 3:30 left. We’ve seen this movie before, right?
Then came the Julian Edelman catch. It’s easily one of the top five catches in Super Bowl history. The ball was tipped, it hit a defender's leg, and Edelman somehow trapped it an inch off the turf while three Falcons swarmed him. I still don't know how he caught that. Actually, I don’t think he knows either.
Overtime and the First-Ever Finish
When the game hit 28-28, it was the first time a Super Bowl ever went to overtime. Atlanta was gassed. Their defense had played 93 snaps compared to the Patriots' 46. They were literally running on fumes.
🔗 Read more: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
New England won the toss. In the NFL's postseason rules, if the first team scores a touchdown, it’s game over. Brady marched them down the field with the kind of cold-blooded precision that makes people hate him. James White eventually punched it in from two yards out.
Final score: 34-28.
Thirty-one unanswered points.
What We Can Learn From the Greatest Comeback
Looking back at the Atlanta Falcons vs New England Patriots Super Bowl, it wasn't just about talent. It was about situational football and mental toughness. The Patriots didn't panic when they were down 25; they just started checking off boxes.
If you're looking for actionable insights from this historic collapse (or triumph, depending on who you root for), here’s the breakdown:
- Clock Management is Everything: If Atlanta runs the ball three times after the Julio Jones catch, they win. Period. In any high-stakes situation, knowing when to "take the points" is better than being aggressive for no reason.
- Conditioning Wins Championships: The Falcons' defense fell apart because they were on the field for over 40 minutes. Efficiency on offense helps your defense stay fresh.
- The "One Play" Mentality: The Patriots didn't try to get 25 points in one drive. They focused on one completion, one first down, one stop.
The legacy of this game still haunts Atlanta. You’ll still see "28-3" memes every time the Falcons play. It serves as a permanent reminder that in the NFL, no lead is safe until the clock hits zero.
To really understand the gravity of this, you should look up the mic'd up footage of the Patriots' sideline during the fourth quarter. Seeing the transition from "we're losing" to "we're going to win this" is a masterclass in sports psychology. You can also dive into the specific "All-22" film of the Hightower sack to see how New England exploited Atlanta's pass protection. It’s a rabbit hole, but for any football fan, it’s the best one out there.