You know the vibe. You’re standing on Virmire, the sun is beating down on the tropical sand, and the music swells into that agonizing, synth-heavy dread. Captain Kirrahe’s team is pinned down. The nuke is armed. Suddenly, BioWare forces you to make a choice that has haunted forum threads for nearly twenty years. For a huge chunk of the player base, the choice is easy. They leave Ashley Williams behind without a second thought.
But why?
Honestly, Ash gets a bad rap. If you look at the raw data from the Mass Effect Legendary Edition stats released by BioWare, about 60% of players chose Kaidan over her. It’s kinda wild when you think about it. She’s one of the most complex, grounded, and human characters in the entire trilogy, yet she’s often reduced to a single, ugly label: the "space racist." That's a massive oversimplification that ignores the actual writing. Ashley Williams isn't a caricature; she’s a professional soldier grappling with a legacy of failure and a galaxy that doesn't care about her family's name.
The Williams Family Curse and the First Contact War
To understand Ashley, you have to talk about her grandfather, General Williams. Most people skip the codex entries, but that’s where the meat is. Her grandfather was the first human ever to surrender to an alien race. During the First Contact War (or the "Relay 314 Incident" if you're a Turian), he surrendered the Shanxi colony to the Turians to save his people.
He did the right thing. He really did. But the Systems Alliance never forgave him.
Because of that surrender, the Williams name became mud. Ashley spent her entire career being shuffled to backwater posts like Eden Prime because high-ranking officers didn't want a "traitor's" granddaughter on their ship. When Shepard picks her up, she’s a Gunnery Chief with a chip on her shoulder the size of a Reaper. She’s spent her whole life trying to prove she's twice as good as everyone else just to get half the respect.
Does she actually hate aliens?
Let's address the elephant in the room. People point to her line about "not being able to tell the aliens from the animals" or her skepticism about the Council. It sounds bad. It is bad! But it's also realistic.
Think about her perspective. Humans are the new kids on the block. The Council treats humanity like a nuisance. Ashley’s worldview is "Team Human" because she believes—correctly, as it turns out in Mass Effect 3—that when the chips are down, the other races will prioritize their own skin. She even says it: "If you're parched, you don't give your last gallon of water to the dog; you drink it yourself." She isn't saying aliens are dogs; she’s using a metaphor for self-preservation. It’s cynical, sure. But in a universe where the Council ignores the Reaper threat for two whole games, was she really wrong?
Faith, Poetry, and the "Real" Ashley
One of the coolest things about Ashley is her faith. She’s one of the very few characters in the Mass Effect universe who openly discusses being a religious person. It’s subtle. She isn't preachy. She just mentions that she believes in God.
It makes her feel like a person you'd actually meet.
Then there’s the poetry. She quotes Tennyson. She quotes Browning. It’s this weird, beautiful contrast to her "grunt" persona. She’s a tough-as-nails soldier who loves Ulysses. Most people miss these conversations because they never take the time to talk to her in the cargo hold after missions. If you just treat her like a walking assault rifle, you miss the person underneath.
- She’s a middle child from a big family.
- She looks out for her sisters like a mother hen.
- She’s fiercely loyal to Shepard, even when she’s questioning your judgment.
That loyalty is exactly why her reaction in Mass Effect 2 on Horizon is so polarizing.
The Horizon Betrayal: Why She Was Right to Walk Away
A lot of players never forgive Ashley for her reaction on Horizon. You show up after being dead for two years, working for Cerberus—a literal terrorist organization—and she doesn't just jump into your arms. She’s angry. She’s hurt. She calls you out.
"I'm a soldier, Shepard. I'm not a fan."
That line is cold. But it’s also the most honest moment in the game. Kaidan does the same thing, by the way, but people seem to take it more personally with Ashley. Think about it from her point of view. She mourned you. She moved on with her career. Then you show up wearing the colors of the group that experimented on Alliance soldiers and killed Admiral Kahoku.
💡 You might also like: Why Peach in Super Mario 3D World is Secretly the Game's Best Character
Of course she's skeptical. She’s a professional. If she just joined you immediately, it would have been lazy writing. Her refusal to join Cerberus-Shepard proves her integrity. She stands for something bigger than a crush or a friendship. She stands for the Alliance.
The Makeover Controversy in Mass Effect 3
We have to talk about the "Barbie" look. When Mass Effect 3 launched, fans were baffled. Ashley went from a practical, bun-wearing soldier to a woman with flowing hair, heavy makeup, and a blue catsuit.
It felt like a weird move by the devs to "prettify" her. Even if you don't like the aesthetic shift, her character arc in the third game is actually quite strong if she survives the Citadel coup. Watching her go from a disgraced Gunnery Chief to the second human Spectre is a massive payoff. She finally cleans the "Williams" name. She achieves what her grandfather never could.
How to Get the Most Out of an Ashley Playthrough
If you’ve always saved Kaidan, I’m telling you: try the other side. Ashley brings a specific energy to the Normandy that is missing without her. She’s the grounded, skeptical voice that challenges the "we can all just get along" idealism of the early games.
To actually appreciate her, you need to:
👉 See also: Wii Sports Resort Flying: Why We’re Still Obsessed With Wuhu Island From Above
- Talk to her early and often. Don't just check in after major missions.
- Bring her on the Citadel. Her dialogue regarding the different races is spicy but offers a lot of insight into the political tensions of the era.
- Actually read the emails. In Mass Effect 2 and 3, the messages she sends Shepard are some of the most well-written bits of flavor text in the series.
Actionable Next Steps for your ME Run
If you're starting a new Legendary Edition run, don't just default to your usual choices.
- Commit to the Virmire Switch: If you always save Kaidan, save Ashley this time. See how her presence changes the tone of the third game.
- Challenge her views: You can actually "Paragon" her a bit. If you challenge her more "speciesist" comments in the first game, her dialogue subtly shifts. She grows.
- Watch the sisters: Pay attention to her dialogue about her sisters, Sarah and Abby. It humanizes the Alliance military in a way that no other character does.
Ashley Williams is a reminder that people are messy. They have prejudices based on trauma. They have family baggage. They don't always say the right thing. But she’s also a hero who is willing to die for a galaxy that spent her whole life spitting on her name. That's a character worth keeping around.