Music history usually happens by accident. A late-night jam session, a chance meeting at a bar, or a songwriter finding a scrap of paper in a trash can. But "Forever Country" was different. It was calculated, massive, and honestly, a bit of a miracle that it didn't collapse under its own weight.
When the Country Music Association (CMA) realized they were hitting their 50th anniversary in 2016, they didn't just want a cake and a "best of" montage. They wanted something that felt like a tectonic shift. What they got was Artists of Then, Now & Forever, a group of 30 legends and modern stars who somehow turned three iconic songs into a single four-minute fever dream.
✨ Don't miss: Spider-Man and Woman: Why the Multiverse is Getting Way More Complicated
The Pitch No One Thought Would Work
You've probably heard the story of how Shane McAnally, the super-producer who basically owns Nashville's airwaves, was "scared to death" of this project. The original idea from the CMA board was simple: pick one song and have everyone sing it. Boring, right?
Enter Joseph Kahn. If you don't know the name, he’s the guy who directed Taylor Swift’s "Bad Blood" and basically every high-gloss pop video of the last twenty years. He wasn't a country guy. Maybe that’s why he had the audacity to tell the CMA that one song wasn't enough. He wanted a mashup.
Nashville is a town of songwriters who treat lyrics like scripture. Cutting into a Dolly Parton song to wedge in a piece of Willie Nelson is usually considered sacrilege. McAnally admitted he was skeptical. He told The Boot that country music is about storytelling, and you can’t just "cut into them and take a piece." But then he started playing the chords of John Denver’s "Take Me Home, Country Roads" and realized Dolly’s "I Will Always Love You" fit over the top like a glove. Throw in the chugging rhythm of Willie’s "On the Road Again," and you had the DNA of the genre in one track.
Who Actually Made the Cut?
It wasn't just a random list of whoever was in town that Tuesday. To be part of Artists of Then, Now & Forever, you had to be a CMA winner. Period. That’s the "Then, Now & Forever" part.
💡 You might also like: La ciudad y los perros: Why Vargas Llosa’s Brutal Debut Still Bites
The lineup was a literal Hall of Fame roster:
- The Legends: Willie Nelson, Dolly Parton, Reba McEntire, Charley Pride, Ronnie Milsap, and Alan Jackson.
- The Power Couples: Tim McGraw and Faith Hill (who, fun fact, insisted on being placed together in the video).
- The Modern Heavyweights: Carrie Underwood, Brad Paisley, Luke Bryan, Miranda Lambert, and Keith Urban.
- The Outliers: Kacey Musgraves brought a bit of that "new traditionalist" edge before she went full cosmic country.
There’s a moment in the video where Randy Travis appears. If you remember, he was still heavily recovering from a stroke at the time and couldn't record vocals. He doesn't sing a word. He just stands there, looking into the camera with that unmistakable Randy Travis presence, and it's probably the most emotional three seconds of the whole thing.
Why "Forever Country" Felt Like a Fever Dream
The music video is weird. Let's just be honest. It’s a lot of green screen. You’ve got Willie Nelson singing under the Eiffel Tower and Kacey Musgraves walking down a CGI version of Lower Broadway.
Joseph Kahn’s vision was to show that country music is universal, but it always comes back to the "country." They shot the whole thing in three days during CMA Fest in Nashville. Imagine the logistics. You have thirty of the biggest stars in the world shuffling in and out of a studio, most of them never even seeing each other because their schedules were so tight.
Brad Paisley, a West Virginia native, was the only choice to open with the John Denver lines. It felt right. Then you have the "big" moment—Carrie Underwood hitting the high notes of Dolly’s classic. It’s the kind of production that usually feels corporate and soulless, but because the source material is so deeply embedded in our collective memory, it actually worked.
The Chart Stats and the "Haters"
When the song dropped on September 16, 2016, it didn't just climb the charts; it broke them. It debuted at No. 1 on Billboard’s Hot Country Songs. That had only happened twice before in history (Garth Brooks and a Voice winner named Craig Wayne Boyd).
But not everyone was buying the hype.
If you look back at reviews from sites like Saving Country Music, the purists were... well, they were annoyed. The critique was that it felt like an "infomercial" for the awards show. There was a lot of grumbling about the CGI and the fact that artists like Luke Bryan or Jason Aldean were sharing airtime with Charley Pride.
Was it "CGI bullshit" as some called it? Maybe. But it also raised a ton of money for music education through the CMA Foundation. It’s hard to stay mad at a project that puts instruments in kids' hands, even if you hate the way the Eiffel Tower looks behind Willie Nelson.
What We Learned from the Mashup
Looking back from 2026, Artists of Then, Now & Forever serves as a time capsule. It caught the genre at a moment when it was trying to bridge the gap between the "bro-country" era and a return to roots.
✨ Don't miss: Why Abigail Deveraux Still Matters to Every Days of Our Lives Fan
Why It Still Matters
- Technical Achievement: Arranging three different keys and tempos into one cohesive song is a nightmare. Shane McAnally’s work here is basically a masterclass in music theory.
- Legacy Bridging: It forced younger fans to listen to John Denver and older fans to acknowledge Carrie Underwood.
- The "One-Off" Factor: They haven't tried to do it again. There’s no "Forever Country 2." That keeps the original special.
How to Experience the Legacy Today
If you're looking to dive back into this era of country music, don't just stop at the mashup. The best way to understand why these 30 artists were chosen is to go back to the source.
Start by listening to the three original tracks in a row: John Denver’s 1971 version of "Country Roads," Dolly’s 1973 "I Will Always Love You," and Willie’s 1980 "On the Road Again." You'll start to hear the "pockets" where McAnally found room to layer them.
Next, check out the "Behind the Scenes" footage on YouTube. Seeing the artists in their street clothes on a green screen makes the whole "superstar" thing feel a lot more human. You see the skepticism in their eyes change to genuine excitement when they hear the rough cut. It’s a reminder that even for people with twenty Grammys, being part of something this big still feels cool.
Ultimately, "Forever Country" wasn't just a song. It was a statement. In an industry that is constantly fighting over what is "real" country and what isn't, for four minutes in 2016, everyone just agreed to sing the same tune. That's a rare win in Nashville.