Walk into a grocery store in London and pick up a box of Skittles. Then, do the same in Chicago. They look almost identical, right? Wrong. If you look closely, the British version is duller. The reds aren't as aggressive. The yellows don't scream at you. That’s because of the artificial food dyes banned or heavily restricted across the European Union that are still perfectly legal—and everywhere—in American snacks.
It’s weird. Honestly, it’s kinda frustrating when you realize your favorite lime-flavored candy is essentially a different chemical cocktail depending on which side of the Atlantic you’re standing on.
For decades, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) have been playing a high-stakes game of "he said, she said" with synthetic colors. While the U.S. maintains that these additives are safe when used as intended, Europe has taken a "better safe than sorry" approach. They didn't just wake up one day and decide to hate Red 40. It started with a specific piece of research known as the Southampton Study.
The study that changed everything for artificial food dyes banned abroad
Back in 2007, researchers at the University of Southampton dropped a metaphorical bomb on the food industry. They published a study in The Lancet suggesting a link between certain synthetic colors and increased hyperactivity in children. We aren't just talking about a "sugar high." We’re talking about measurable behavioral shifts.
The "Southampton Six" became the primary targets. This list includes Sunset Yellow (Yellow 6), Quinoline Yellow, Carmoisine, Allura Red (Red 40), Tartrazine (Yellow 5), and Ponceau 4R.
The UK government didn't wait around. They pushed for a voluntary ban. The EU went a step further. They didn't technically "ban" all of them outright in every single category, but they did something much more effective: they mandated a warning label. Any food containing these dyes must carry the text: "May have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children." Think about that for a second. If you’re a parent in a supermarket, are you going to buy the cake mix that says it might make your kid hyperactive? Probably not. Most food manufacturers didn't want that label on their packaging, so they switched to natural alternatives like turmeric, beetroot juice, and spirulina.
📖 Related: Products With Red 40: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the FDA keeps Red 40 on the shelves
You’ve probably wondered why the FDA hasn't followed suit. It’s complicated.
The FDA’s stance is basically that the evidence isn't "conclusive" enough to warrant a total ban. They’ve reviewed the Southampton study and others, and they argue that the hyperactivity observed might only affect certain sensitive children rather than the general population. Plus, they point out that the doses used in some studies are way higher than what a normal human—even a kid with a serious sweet tooth—would eat in a day.
But things are shifting. California recently passed the California Food Safety Act, which effectively bans Red 3 starting in 2027. This is a huge deal. It’s the first time a U.S. state has broken ranks with federal guidelines to pull a dye off the shelves. Red 3 is already banned in the EU and even in cosmetics in the U.S. (because it was linked to thyroid cancer in rats), yet it’s still in your seasonal maraschino cherries. Make it make sense.
A closer look at the "Big Three"
- Red 40 (Allura Red): This is the king of food dyes. It’s in everything from soda to nacho chips. In Europe, it's often replaced with elderberry juice or carmine (which, fun fact, comes from crushed bugs).
- Yellow 5 (Tartrazine): Known for causing the most allergic-type reactions. People get hives. They get itchy. In the EU, if it's in your food, that warning label is mandatory.
- Yellow 6 (Sunset Yellow): Often found in processed cheeses and crackers.
It isn't just about hyperactivity anymore. There’s a growing conversation about the "cocktail effect." We don't just eat one dye. We eat Red 40 in our cereal, Yellow 5 in our lunch crackers, and Blue 1 in our evening sports drink. Scientists like those at the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) argue that the cumulative effect of these petroleum-derived chemicals hasn't been studied nearly enough.
The "Natural" transition isn't always easy
Food companies aren't just being stubborn for the sake of it. Switching from artificial food dyes banned in other regions to natural colors is a massive technical headache. Synthetic dyes are cheap. They are incredibly stable. You can put a Red 40-dyed candy in a clear jar in direct sunlight for six months and it will still be the exact same shade of fire-engine red.
👉 See also: Why Sometimes You Just Need a Hug: The Real Science of Physical Touch
Natural dyes? They're finicky.
Beet juice turns brown if you heat it too much. Spirulina (for blue) loses its color if the pH of the food is too acidic. Turmeric (for yellow) can sometimes make the food taste, well, like turmeric. It takes a lot of food science "magic" to make a natural dye behave like a synthetic one.
Yet, companies do it. Kellogg’s, General Mills, and Mars have all successfully reformulated products for the European market. They use paprika extract for oranges and copper chlorophyllin for greens. The fact that the exact same brand of cereal can be "cleaner" in Paris than it is in Peoria is what really fuels the fire for American consumer advocates.
What you can actually do about it
If you're worried about these additives, you don't have to wait for the FDA to catch up to Europe. You have more power than you think.
First, stop looking for "Red 40" and start looking for the phrase "U.S. Certified Color." That’s the giveaway. If the label says "Beet juice," "Annatto," or "Turmeric," you’re in the clear.
✨ Don't miss: Can I overdose on vitamin d? The reality of supplement toxicity
Secondly, be wary of "healthy" foods that aren't. Many people assume food dyes are only in candy or neon-colored sodas. Nope. They're in pickles (to make them look more yellow-green), microwave popcorn, and even some brands of yogurt and bread.
The reality is that artificial food dyes banned elsewhere are mostly there for "cosmetic" reasons. They don't add flavor. They don't preserve the food. They just make it look "prettier" or more "consistent." Once you realize that the bright orange color of your "cheese" snacks is just a psychological trick, it becomes a lot easier to put the bag back on the shelf.
Practical steps for a dye-free kitchen:
- Check the "Fruit Snacks" specifically: Many brands marketed to parents as "made with real fruit" still use Blue 1 or Red 40 to get that vibrant hue. Look for brands like Annie’s or YumEarth that use fruit and vegetable extracts.
- The Pickle Test: Real fermented pickles are naturally a bit dull. If your pickles look like they’re glowing in the dark, they probably contain Yellow 5.
- Dining Out: This is the hardest part. Restaurants aren't required to list every dye in their sauces or seasonings. If you're highly sensitive, sticking to "whole foods"—things that look like what they are (grilled chicken, steamed broccoli)—is the only surefire way to avoid hidden synthetics.
- Support Local Legislation: Keep an eye on bills in states like New York and Illinois, which are currently considering following California's lead in banning certain additives.
The debate over these chemicals isn't going away. As more states take independent action and more parents demand the same "clean" versions of snacks that Europeans get, the industry will have to pivot. It’s not about being "anti-science"; it's about asking why we’re using petroleum-based dyes when carrot juice works just fine.
Ultimately, the goal isn't necessarily to live in a world without color. It's to live in a world where the color in our food actually comes from food. Until then, keep an eye on those labels and remember that "bright" doesn't always mean "better."