Walk into Arnold’s Bar and Grill on a Tuesday night and you’ll notice something immediately. It isn't just the smell of the Avril-Bleh beef hitting the grill or the sound of a fiddle tuning up in the courtyard. It's the floor. That uneven, dark wood under your boots has been there since the Civil War.
Honestly, in a city like Cincinnati that loves to tear things down to build luxury condos, Arnold’s is a miracle. It’s been sitting at 210 East Eighth Street since 1861. Or maybe 1856. Actually, if you talk to the local historians, they’ll tell you the "1861" date on the neon sign is technically a few years off, but nobody’s in a hurry to change it.
Most people think of it as just a "historic bar." But that’s a pretty lazy way to describe a place that survived Prohibition by turning into a "cafe" and hiding a bathtub full of gin on the second floor.
The Bathtub, The Bootleggers, and the 1861 Myth
Let’s clear something up. Simon Arnold didn't actually start the place in 1861. Research by folks like Mike Morgan and Greg Hand suggests George and Wilhelmina Weber were running a "coffee house" (read: saloon) there as early as 1856. Simon didn't take over the keys until 1877.
But who cares about a five-year discrepancy when there’s moonshine involved?
During the dark days of Prohibition, Hugo Arnold—Simon’s son—wasn't about to let the family business die. He moved the family up to the third floor and kept the second-floor bathtub busy. Legend says that tub was the epicenter of their "bathtub gin" operation. You can still see the tub today. It’s sitting upstairs, a cast-iron relic that’s probably seen more secrets than a priest’s confessional.
Hugo eventually got busted in 1922 for possession of bonded whiskey. He retired shortly after, probably because the stress of dodging feds while living above a literal crime scene gets old after a while.
Why the Courtyard is the Real Star
If you’ve never eaten in the courtyard, you haven't actually been to Arnold’s. It used to be a stable and a carriage house back in the mid-1800s. Jim Tarbell, the legendary former owner and Cincinnati icon, was the one who saw the potential. In 1976, he opened it up for outdoor dining—the first of its kind downtown in decades.
It feels like a secret garden in the middle of a concrete jungle. There’s a mural of Emilio Estevez (a regular) looking down at you, and the stage hosts everything from bluegrass to jazz. It’s cramped, it’s loud, and it’s perfect.
The Food: It’s Not Just "Bar Grub"
You’ve got to try the Greek Spaghetti. It’s been on the menu since 1957. Basically, it’s linguine tossed with butter, garlic, olives, bacon, and a mountain of Romano cheese. It’s simple. It’s greasy. It’s what 2:00 AM dreams are made of.
Then there’s the Yo Mama Burger. This thing is a local legend for a reason. You’re looking at:
- Avril-Bleh beef (the best in the city).
- A slab of goetta (it’s Cincinnati, what did you expect?).
- A hash brown.
- A sunny-side-up egg.
- Chipotle aioli.
It’s messy. You will need roughly fourteen napkins.
They also do a "Sean Evans" burger named after the Hot Ones host. It uses ghost pepper cheese and Grippo’s potato chips. If you aren't from around here, Grippo's are a local spicy chip that people treat like a religious relic. Putting them on a burger is a pro move.
Wait, is the place actually haunted?
Short answer: yeah, probably.
👉 See also: Why the Los Angeles Flower District Los Angeles CA is Still a Chaos You’ll Love
Staff members have been talking about "the girl in the dark blue dress" for decades. She’s seen on the second and third floors, usually just out of the corner of your eye. There are stories of fires roaring in the upstairs fireplace when nobody has lit a match, and chairs moving themselves into the middle of the aisle.
Some say it’s the spirit of a woman from the building’s rumored days as a brothel. Others think it’s just the "vibe" of a building that has absorbed 160 years of human drama. Either way, it adds a certain chill to your beer.
Why Arnold’s Still Matters in 2026
Business is tough for old-school spots. For a while, lunch was off the menu, then it came back, then it was "in danger" because people stopped working in offices downtown. But Arnold’s keeps swinging.
It’s one of the few places where you’ll see a guy in a $3,000 suit sitting next to a guy in a stained flannel shirt, both of them arguing about the Bengals. It’s authentic. You can't manufacture the "patina" on those walls. It’s a mixture of a century of tobacco smoke (from back in the day), spilled beer, and a million conversations.
How to do Arnold’s Right
If you’re planning a visit, don't just show up and expect a seat on a Friday night.
- Check the music schedule. The "Cincinnati Dancing Pigs" (a local jug band) have been playing here since the 70s. Catching them is a rite of passage.
- Go upstairs. Even if you’re eating downstairs, walk up and look at the bathtub. It’s a piece of history you can actually touch.
- Order the Goetta Poutine. It’s fries topped with goetta gravy and cheese curds. It is a heart attack on a plate and worth every second.
- Look at the art. The walls are covered in weird, wonderful local art and old photos. It’s better than most museums in the city.
Actionable Insight: If you’re a history buff, look for the "medallion" on the wall that marks the transitions from Saloon (1861) to Café (1890) to Grill (1933). It’s the easiest way to track how this place survived three different centuries without losing its soul. Go during a weekday lunch if you want to soak in the architecture without the crowd, or hit the courtyard on a Saturday night if you want to feel the pulse of the city.