If you tuned into the Arizona vs Kansas State football matchup expecting a typical Big 12 conference brawl, you probably left the couch feeling a bit lied to. It’s weird. Here you have two programs that are, by every literal definition, members of the same conference. They share the same commissioner, the same TV deals, and presumably the same brand of overpriced stadium nachos. Yet, when they stepped onto the turf at Bill Snyder Family Stadium in 2024 and later at Arizona Stadium in 2025, the game didn't count toward the conference standings.
Basically, we witnessed a high-stakes "exhibition" between rivals who were already living in the same house but pretending to be strangers for the sake of a contract signed years ago.
The Big 12 Loophole That Confused Everyone
Sports can be dumb sometimes. The reason Arizona vs Kansas State football felt so disjointed in the record books is that these games were scheduled as a home-and-home series back when Arizona was still a cornerstone of the Pac-12. When the Pac-12 imploded and the Wildcats headed east to the Big 12, the schedule was already baked in.
Instead of cancelling and trying to find new opponents—which is a logistical nightmare for athletic directors—both schools just agreed to play the games as "non-conference" matchups. It’s like dating your roommate but telling everyone you’re just friends so you don’t have to change your Facebook status.
Kansas State made a massive statement in that first meeting on September 13, 2024. They absolutely dismantled Arizona 31-7. Avery Johnson, the K-State quarterback with the flowing hair and even faster feet, was the best player on the field by a mile. He threw for 156 yards and two scores, but it was his 110 yards on the ground that really broke Arizona's spirit.
📖 Related: Shedeur Sanders Draft Room: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Honestly, Arizona looked lost. They entered that game with the longest winning streak in the FBS (nine games), and it evaporated in the Kansas humidity. Noah Fifita, Arizona’s star QB, threw for 268 yards but couldn't find the end zone once. Even Tetairoa McMillan, who is a future first-round NFL draft pick and basically a human highlight reel, was kept in check. He caught 11 passes for 138 yards, which sounds great on paper, but he never actually threatened to change the outcome.
The Revenge of the Desert Wildcats
Fast forward to September 12, 2025. Different year, different vibe.
Arizona got their lick back. In a 23-17 victory in Tucson, Brent Brennan’s squad proved that the 2024 blowout was more of a fluke than a trend. This time, the defense actually showed up. They held K-State to a miserable 193 total yards.
- Arizona Total Yards: 412
- K-State Total Yards: 193
- Time of Possession: Arizona held the ball for nearly 37 minutes.
Ismail Mahdi was the engine for Arizona this time around, racking up 189 yards on 22 carries. He was hitting holes that weren't even there in the first half. K-State’s Jayce Brown tried to keep things interesting with a 75-yard touchdown run to start the third quarter, but it wasn't enough to overcome the constant pressure Noah Fifita put on the K-State secondary. Fifita finished with two rushing touchdowns of his own, showing he could play the "dual-threat" game just as well as Avery Johnson.
👉 See also: Seattle Seahawks Offense Rank: Why the Top-Three Scoring Unit Still Changed Everything
Why This Rivalry Matters More Than the Standings
Look, the "non-conference" label is going away soon. Starting in 2026, Arizona vs Kansas State football will finally be "official." According to the Big 12's four-year scheduling matrix, these two are set to play as true conference opponents in 2026 (in Manhattan) and 2027 (in Tucson).
There’s a real geographical and cultural friction developing here. You have the "Old Guard" of the Big 12 in Manhattan—tough, disciplined, defensive-minded—clashing with the "New Blood" from the desert that wants to play fast and loose.
Critics like to say Arizona isn't "tough enough" for the physical grind of the Big 12. The 2024 game supported that theory. But the 2025 rematch flipped the script. Arizona out-physicalled K-State, which is something you rarely see happen to a Chris Klieman team. It’s a fascinating contrast in styles that is going to define the middle-to-upper tier of the conference for the next decade.
Key Takeaways from the Series History
If you look at the all-time record, Arizona actually leads the series 6-2-1. But let's be real: games played in 1941 or 1953 don't mean much when you're trying to figure out who’s going to win a Saturday night tilt in 2026.
✨ Don't miss: Seahawks Standing in the NFL: Why Seattle is Stuck in the Playoff Purgatory Middle
The real story is the modern era. The teams are 1-1 over the last two seasons.
K-State’s win was a blowout; Arizona’s win was a grind.
This tells us that home-field advantage is massive in this matchup. Bill Snyder Family Stadium is one of the most underrated environments in college football, and Arizona Stadium under the lights in Tucson is a house of horrors for teams coming from the Midwest who aren't used to the dry heat.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Matchup
If you're looking ahead to the next time these two face off, keep these things in mind:
- Watch the Trenches: In both recent games, the team that won the rushing battle won the game. Arizona's offensive line was a sieve in 2024 but a wall in 2025.
- The Avery Johnson Factor: K-State's offense lives and dies by Johnson's ability to scramble. When Arizona contained him in 2025 (holding him to negative rushing yards), K-State's passing game couldn't compensate.
- Special Teams Matter: Don't forget Dylan Edwards' 71-yard punt return TD in 2024. Those 7 points were the momentum shift that ended Arizona's night early.
The next time Arizona vs Kansas State football kicks off, it won't just be for pride or a weird contractual obligation. It'll be for a spot in the Big 12 Championship. Both programs are trending upward, and neither seems willing to give an inch in what has quickly become the most interesting "accidental" rivalry in the country.
Keep an eye on the 2026 schedule release. That game in Manhattan is likely to be a night-game "blackout" or "EMAW" special, and you can bet the desert Wildcats will be walking into a buzzsaw.