He’s the guy everyone loves to hate. If you grew up reading the books or watching the movies, you probably remember Argus Filch as the wheezing, bitter old man lurking in the shadows of Hogwarts, desperately hoping to catch Harry, Ron, or Hermione out of bed after hours. He’s the antagonist who doesn't use a wand. He’s the man with the dust-colored skin and the cat with the glowing, lamp-like eyes.
But here’s the thing. Most people actually get Argus Filch wrong.
We see him through the eyes of eleven-year-olds who think a night-time stroll to the Owlery is a harmless adventure. To Filch, it’s a violation of the rules he spends eighteen hours a day enforcing. He is the only non-magical person—a Squib—living in a castle literally built on magic. Imagine working at a five-star bakery when you’re allergic to gluten and everyone else is eating croissants for free. That is the daily reality for the Hogwarts caretaker.
The Squib Struggle Nobody Talks About
Being a Squib in the Wizarding World isn't just a "bummer." It’s a social death sentence. In the Harry Potter universe, J.K. Rowling makes it clear through characters like Arabella Figg and Filch that Squibs occupy a painful middle ground. They aren't Muggles, so they can't really fit into the non-magical world, but they lack the one thing that gives them status in their own world.
Think about the "Kwikspell" course Harry finds on Filch’s desk in The Chamber of Secrets. It’s heartbreaking. Here is a man in his late sixties or seventies, desperately trying to learn "Beginner's Magic" from a correspondence course because he’s ashamed. He's trying to fix a life that felt broken from the moment he was born.
When Harry stumbles upon that letter, Filch’s reaction isn't just anger. It’s pure, unadulterated humiliation. He knows that if the students find out he can’t cast a simple Scouring Charm, his last shred of authority vanishes. He isn't just mean for the sake of being mean; he’s overcompensating for a massive, gaping hole in his identity.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Why Filch Actually Stayed at Hogwarts
Why did he stay? Honestly, it’s a question that fans debate constantly in forums like r/harrypotter. If he hated the students so much, why not leave?
Hogwarts was likely the only place that would take him. Albus Dumbledore is famous—or notorious, depending on who you ask—for hiring the "unhireable." He gave a home to Hagrid after he was expelled. He gave a job to Remus Lupin when no one would hire a werewolf. Hiring Argus Filch as the caretaker was an act of charity, but for Filch, it was a double-edged sword. He got a roof over his head, but he had to spend every waking moment watching children do things with a flick of a wrist that he could never do in a lifetime.
It’s a recipe for bitterness.
The man has to clean up magical messes by hand. When a prankster sets off Fanged Frisbees or leaks Dungbombs in the corridors, Filch doesn't get to use Scourgify. He gets a bucket. He gets a mop. He spends his life scrubbing floors that could be cleaned in two seconds by a second-year student. If you had to mop a castle that size while teenagers laughed at you, you’d probably want to bring back the "old punishments" like being hung by your wrists in the dungeon, too.
Mrs. Norris: More Than Just a Cat
We can’t talk about Argus Filch without talking about Mrs. Norris. Their bond is the only genuine affection Filch shows in the entire seven-book series. It’s weird, sure. But it’s also the only thing keeping him sane.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
There’s an old fan theory that Mrs. Norris is a Maledictus (like Nagini) or a Part-Kneazle, but Rowling has clarified she’s just a highly intelligent, albeit deeply unpleasant, cat. She is his partner. She’s his eyes and ears. When she is Petrified in The Chamber of Secrets, Filch’s grief is the most "human" we ever see him. He isn't just mad his "snitch" is gone; he’s devastated. He loses his only friend.
- Fact check: Contrary to some fanfiction, Filch is not married to the cat.
- Context: He views her as an equal, which says a lot about how isolated he feels from the rest of the faculty.
- The Peeves Factor: The poltergeist Peeves is Filch’s true nemesis. While the students are a nuisance, Peeves represents the chaos that Filch, as a non-magical man, can never truly control.
The Battle of Hogwarts: A Surprising Turn
By the time The Deathly Hallows rolls around, most people expected Filch to either hide or join the side that promised order—even if that order came from Voldemort. But he didn't. During the Battle of Hogwarts, he helped evacuate the younger students.
Did he do it because he loved them? Probably not. He did it because Hogwarts is his home. Even though he’s a "bitter old Squib," he is part of the fabric of the school. There is a deleted scene in the films (and a brief mention in the books) of him trying to "sweep" the rubble during the battle. It’s played for laughs, but it’s actually deeply symbolic. In the face of ultimate magical destruction, the man with the broom keeps sweeping. It’s the only way he knows how to fight back.
Misconceptions and Forgotten Details
People often forget that Filch actually had a decent relationship with Severus Snape. Or, at least, as decent as two miserable men can have. Snape treated Filch with a level of professional respect that the other teachers didn't always provide.
There's also the matter of the "Confiscated and Highly Dangerous" drawer. This is where the Marauder’s Map lived for years. Filch didn't know how to use it, obviously, but he had the instinct to take it. He had a knack for finding trouble even without a wand. That’s an underrated skill. If he had been born a wizard, he likely would have been a top-tier Auror or an elite investigator. Instead, he’s the guy yelling about muddy boots in the Great Hall.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Understanding the "Villain"
Was Filch a good person? Not really. He was cruel, he advocated for physical torture of children, and he took way too much joy in the misery of others. But he wasn't a Death Eater. He wasn't evil in the way Bellatrix Lestrange was evil. He was a man broken by a system that valued magical blood above all else.
In the end, Filch is a cautionary tale about what happens when you keep someone in an environment where they can never succeed. He’s the reminder that Hogwarts wasn't a paradise for everyone.
How to Appreciate the Filch Arc Today
If you’re revisiting the series or introducing it to someone new, try looking at the scenes in the corridors differently. Don’t just see the villain. See the man who has spent thirty years trying to keep a magical castle clean with a bottle of Mrs. Skower’s All-Purpose Magical Mess Remover.
- Pay attention to the background: In the movies, David Bradley plays Filch with a limp and a wheeze that emphasizes his physical vulnerability.
- Read the subtext: Look at how the teachers treat him. They tolerate him, but he’s never truly invited into their circle. He eats in the Great Hall, but he is always on the periphery.
- Acknowledge the Squib legacy: Realize that Filch’s presence at Hogwarts was a radical political statement by Dumbledore, even if it made Filch miserable.
The best way to "use" this knowledge is to apply it to character analysis or creative writing. Understanding the "why" behind a character like Argus Filch makes the world of Harry Potter feel much more grounded and less like a simple fairy tale. He is the grit in the gears of the magical world. Without him, the castle would be cleaner, sure, but it would also be far less interesting.
Stop viewing Filch as a caricature and start seeing him as the tragedy he is. It changes the entire tone of the early books. Next time you see him on screen, remember: he’s the only one there who has to do everything the hard way.
Next Steps for Potter Fans:
To get a deeper understanding of the "non-magical" side of the wizarding world, research the history of the Muggles' Protection Act and the specific legal status of Squibs in the Ministry of Magic. This context explains why characters like Filch feel they have no choice but to cling to whatever scraps of the magical world they are offered. You can also look into the behind-the-scenes casting of David Bradley to see how he developed the character's unique physicality, which wasn't fully detailed in the original text.