You’ve probably seen them. The tan, overly enthusiastic recruiters standing outside a high-end resort in Cabo or Orlando, clutching a clipboard and promising a "free" breakfast or a pair of Disney tickets just for ninety minutes of your time. It sounds harmless. Then you get inside. Two hours later, you’re being pressured by a tag-team of sales managers to sign a contract for a property you’ll never actually own. It begs the question that’s launched a thousand lawsuits: are timeshares a scam or just a really misunderstood way to travel?
The answer isn't a simple yes or no. It’s messy.
👉 See also: Palo Pinto Mountains State Park: What You Need to Know Before You Go
Legally, a timeshare from a major developer like Marriott, Hilton, or Disney isn't a "scam" in the sense that they take your money and disappear into the night. You get the room. You get the points. But the gap between what the salesperson says and what the contract actually dictates is where things get ugly. Honestly, the industry survives on a very specific kind of math that rarely favors the buyer. If you define a scam as "an investment sold under false pretenses that loses value the second you buy it," then yeah, many people would say they’ve been had.
Why the "Investment" Pitch is a Total Lie
Walk into any sales presentation and you'll hear about "locking in today's prices for tomorrow's vacations." They make it sound like real estate. They use words like "deeded property" and "equity."
It’s nonsense.
A timeshare is a depreciating asset. Actually, "depreciating" is too kind. It's a financial rock that sinks to the bottom of the ocean. According to the American Resort Development Association (ARDA), the average price of a timeshare is around $24,000. If you try to sell that same unit on the secondary market—sites like TUG (Timeshare Users Group) or eBay—you’ll often see them listed for $1. Literally one dollar. Sometimes people even pay the closing costs just to get someone else to take the deed.
Why? Because of the maintenance fees.
You aren't just buying a week at a resort. You're signing up for a lifelong subscription you can't cancel. These fees average about $1,000 to $1,500 a year, but they never stay there. They go up. Every year. Usually faster than inflation. If the resort decides it needs a new roof or a fancy infinity pool, they hit you with a "special assessment." You have to pay it. You have no choice. That's the part they skip during the free breakfast.
The Psychological Warfare of the Sales Room
The reason people wonder are timeshares a scam usually stems from the "recruitment" process. It’s high-pressure. It’s exhausting. It’s designed to break down your logic.
They use a tactic called "The T.O." (Take Over). When your initial salesperson realizes you aren't biting, they bring in the "manager" who suddenly finds a "secret" discount or a "canceled" unit they can give you for half price. It’s a staged performance. They want you tired, hungry, and desperate to leave. They know that if you go home and Google the resort, you’ll find the thousands of disgruntled owners trying to offload their units for pennies.
They need you to sign now.
The "Points" Trap
Most modern timeshares aren't even for a specific week anymore. They use points. It sounds flexible, right? You can go to Hawaii this year and Vegas the next! But in reality, the "point values" for popular resorts often inflate, or the availability is non-existent unless you book 14 months in advance. You end up paying thousands in fees for a "home resort" you can't even get into during spring break.
Real Numbers: The Opportunity Cost
Let’s look at the math. If you spend $24,000 on a timeshare and pay $1,200 a year in maintenance fees for 20 years, you’ve spent $48,000. That’s assuming the fees never go up, which they will.
If you took that same $24,000 and put it into a basic S&P 500 index fund, and instead of paying maintenance fees, you just spent $1,500 a year on a high-end Airbnb or hotel:
- You’d have total flexibility.
- You’d never be stuck with a "deed" you can't sell.
- Your initial $24,000 would likely have tripled in value over those two decades.
When you look at it through that lens, the "financial sense" of a timeshare evaporates. You’re essentially prepaying for hotels for the rest of your life, but also agreeing to pay the hotel’s taxes and repair bills. It’s a lopsided deal.
Is Anyone Actually Happy With Their Timeshare?
Surprisingly, yes. Some people love them.
The people who enjoy timeshares are usually those who:
- Bought on the resale market. They paid $500 for something the original owner paid $25,000 for.
- Are creatures of habit. They want to go to the exact same beach in Destin, Florida, every second week of July for thirty years.
- Have large families. Having a kitchen and multiple bedrooms is better than booking three separate hotel rooms.
But even these "happy" owners will tell you: never, under any circumstances, buy from the developer. The "perks" like reward points or "first look" access aren't worth the $20,000 premium.
The Exit Scam: A Secondary Layer of Fraud
If the initial sale is the first trap, the "exit company" is the second. This is where the term "scam" becomes 100% accurate.
Desperate owners, burdened by rising fees, search for "how to get out of my timeshare." They find companies promising a "legal way out" or a "guaranteed exit." These companies often charge $5,000 to $10,000 upfront.
The Better Business Bureau (BBB) has issued countless warnings about these firms. Often, they just tell you to stop paying your fees—which ruins your credit—and then they disappear with your money. Huge firms like American Settlement Services or Timeshare Termination Team have faced massive legal shutdowns for these exact practices.
If a company asks for thousands of dollars upfront to "cancel" your contract, run. The only legitimate way out is usually through the developer's own "deed-back" program (if they have one) or by selling it for a dollar to someone else who wants the liability.
How to Protect Yourself
If you find yourself in a presentation because you really wanted those free show tickets, you need a strategy.
- Leave your credit cards in the hotel room. Don't even bring them to the building.
- Set a timer. Tell them you have exactly 90 minutes and you are leaving when the phone dings.
- Don't believe the "Today Only" price. It's a lie. That price will be there tomorrow, and an even lower one will be on eBay.
- Read the "Rescission" clause. Most states (like Florida and Nevada) have a "cooling off" period. If you did sign in a moment of weakness, you usually have 3 to 10 days to cancel the contract via a certified letter.
Final Verdict: Are Timeshares a Scam?
Technically, the big brands are selling a real product. You get the room. You get the pool. In that sense, it's a legitimate travel product.
But the business model is predatory. It relies on emotional manipulation, confusing math, and the fact that most people don't understand the long-term cost of maintenance fees. It's a "scam" in the way a 30% APR car loan is a scam—it's legal, but it's designed to drain your bank account for the benefit of a corporation.
If you want to vacation at these resorts, just go to Expedia or Booking.com. You can rent the exact same units from owners who are desperate to cover their maintenance fees. You get the "timeshare experience" without the $20,000 chain around your neck.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With the Royal Caribbean Cruise Norovirus Outbreak Sickening 70+ Passengers
What to do if you're already in one
If you own a timeshare and regret it, stop looking for "exit companies." First, contact the developer directly. Some companies, like Wyndham (Certified Exit) or Diamond Resorts, have official channels for owners to surrender their deeds if they meet certain criteria (like having the unit paid off). It’s not a guarantee, but it’s the only path that won't cost you an extra $5,000 in "consulting fees." If that fails, head over to the Timeshare Users Group (TUG) forums. It’s the oldest and most honest community of owners on the internet, and they will tell you exactly how to list your unit for sale—honestly—without getting ripped off again.
Next Steps for Potential Buyers:
- Check eBay and TUG Marketplace to see what your "dream resort" is actually selling for on the open market.
- Calculate 20 years of maintenance fees with a 5% annual increase.
- Read the "Timeshare Rescission" laws for the state where you are vacationing before attending any presentation.