The short answer is usually a scoreboard. But if you’re asking are the New England Patriots winning, you aren't just looking for a win-loss record from last Sunday. You’re asking if the "Patriot Way" still exists or if it died in a parking lot in Foxborough the day Tom Brady packed his bags for Tampa. Honestly, it’s been a rough ride. Following the 2024 season and heading into 2025, the definition of "winning" for this franchise shifted from Super Bowl parades to "can we please just find a quarterback who doesn't throw three picks a game?"
Jerod Mayo stepped into the biggest shoes in professional sports. Replacing Bill Belichick isn't like taking over a normal head coaching job; it's like trying to paint over the Sistine Chapel with a roller brush. The 2024 season was a definitive "Year Zero." They were bad. Let's be real about it. They struggled with an offensive line that looked like a revolving door and a receiving corps that struggled to create separation. But the record doesn't tell the whole story of whether they are actually "winning" the rebuilding process.
The Drake Maye Factor and the New Metric for Success
When we talk about whether the New England Patriots winning is a reality, we have to talk about Drake Maye. The 2024 NFL Draft was the fork in the road. For years, the team tried to bridge the gap with Mac Jones—a move that started okay and ended in a total catastrophe of confidence.
Drake Maye changed the energy. He’s got the size. He’s got the arm. Most importantly, he’s got the "it" factor that the local media has been starving for since 2019. If Maye looks like a franchise cornerstone, the Patriots are winning, even if the final score says 24-17 in favor of the Jets. Success right now is measured in developmental leaps. Did the footwork improve? Is he seeing the backside safety? These are the tiny victories that fans are clinging to while the team sits near the bottom of the AFC East standings.
The offensive line, however, has been a nightmare. You can have Patrick Mahomes back there, but if your left tackle is getting beat in 1.8 seconds, you’re going to lose. It’s hard to say the team is winning when they lead the league in pressures allowed.
The Defensive Identity Under Jerod Mayo
Defense used to be the Patriots' calling card. Under Belichick, they’d take away your best player and make you play left-handed. Now? It’s different. Mayo and defensive coordinator DeMarcus Covington have kept the unit respectable, but the "Boogeymen" days feel like a lifetime ago.
Christian Gonzalez is the real deal. If you want to see a "win" for the front office, look at him. He’s a lockdown corner who treats elite wideouts like they’re JV players. But the front seven has lacked that consistent, game-wrecking pass rush since Matthew Judon’s departure. The defense is playing "winning" football in spurts, keeping games close enough to be frustrating, yet they often crumble in the fourth quarter because the offense can't stay on the field for more than four minutes at a time.
👉 See also: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
It’s a weird paradox. The defense is good enough to prevent blowouts, but not dominant enough to carry a stagnant offense.
Why the AFC East Has Become a Gauntlet
In the 2000s and 2010s, the AFC East was a joke. The Bills were inept, the Dolphins were mediocre, and the Jets were... the Jets.
That’s over.
Josh Allen turned Buffalo into a perennial powerhouse. The Dolphins built a track team with Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle. Even the Jets, despite their constant drama, have fielded elite defenses. Are the New England Patriots winning in this environment? Rarely. They went from being the big brother to being the team everyone wants to get their "revenge" wins against.
The lack of elite talent on the perimeter is the glaring issue. While other teams are out here collecting 1,000-yard receivers like Pokémon cards, the Patriots have relied on a "receiver by committee" approach that honestly hasn't worked since Julian Edelman retired. Demario Douglas has shown flashes. He’s quick. He’s twitchy. But is he a Number One? No. Until the Patriots land a true alpha receiver, their "winning" will be capped by a low ceiling.
The Post-Belichick Front Office Philosophy
Eliot Wolf is the man behind the curtain now. The philosophy has shifted from "finding undervalued veterans" to "draft and develop." It’s the Green Bay model. It takes time. It’s painful. It involves a lot of Sunday afternoons where you want to throw your remote at the TV.
✨ Don't miss: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
People forget how spoiled New England was. Two decades of dominance isn't normal. What we’re seeing now—the 4-13 or 5-12 seasons—is what the rest of the league calls "reality." The front office is finally admitting the roster was depleted. They’re no longer trying to "reload" for a playoff run that isn't coming. They’re tearing it down to the studs. In that sense, they are winning the long game by being honest about their suckage.
Misconceptions About the New England Culture
There’s this idea that the "Patriot Way" was just about being mean and wearing hoodies. It wasn't. It was about an obsessive attention to detail. Lately, the penalties have crept up. The mental errors in the red zone are glaring. These are things that used to be non-negotiable in Foxborough.
When you ask if the New England Patriots winning is happening, you have to look at the "hidden yards."
- Special teams blunders.
- Missed tackles on third-and-long.
- Delay of game penalties coming out of a timeout.
These are the symptoms of a team that has lost its identity. Mayo is trying to build a "player-friendly" version of the culture, but there’s a fine line between being a players' coach and losing the discipline that defined the franchise for twenty years.
The Financial Situation: Cap Space vs. Talent
One area where the Patriots are objectively winning is the balance sheet. They have consistently headed into recent offseasons with massive amounts of cap space. But money doesn't catch touchdowns.
They’ve struggled to attract the biggest free agents. Why would a superstar receiver come to New England when they could go to Kansas City or Cincinnati? The "tax" of playing in the cold for a rebuilding team is high. The Patriots have to overpay for B-tier talent just to fill the roster. That’s not winning; that’s surviving.
🔗 Read more: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Real-World Fan Sentiment
Walk into any bar in Southie or a diner in Worcester. The vibe is... patient, but thin. Fans who grew up with Brady and Belichick don't know how to handle a rebuild. They expect the playoffs every year. There is a segment of the fanbase that believes the team is "winning" because they finally have a high-upside QB in Maye. Then there’s the other half that thinks the Krafts are being too cheap.
The truth is somewhere in the middle. Robert Kraft is desperate to prove that the success wasn't just Bill. He wants to win his way. But "winning" in the NFL requires a level of ruthlessness that the team hasn't quite recaptured yet.
What Needs to Change for Real Winning to Return
You can't just wish for a winning record. You have to build it.
First, the offensive line needs a total overhaul. Not just one or two guys—the whole philosophy. They need a left tackle who can protect Maye’s blindside for the next decade. Second, they need to hit on a mid-to-late round wide receiver. The great Patriots teams always had a Troy Brown or a Deion Branch—guys who weren't necessarily first-round picks but were absolute technicians.
Finally, the coaching staff needs to settle. Constant turnover in the offensive coordinator spot has killed the development of every young player they’ve had. Stability is the foundation of winning.
Actionable Insights for the Path Forward
If you're tracking the progress of this team, stop looking at the win-loss column for a moment. Instead, focus on these specific markers to see if the Patriots are actually turning the corner:
- Quarterback Protection Rates: If Drake Maye's "time to throw" increases by even half a second on average, the front office is winning the battle in the trenches.
- Red Zone Efficiency: Scoring touchdowns instead of settling for field goals is the fastest way to flip 3-point losses into 4-point wins.
- Third-Down Defense: Watch how they handle mobile quarterbacks. In the modern NFL, if you can't contain a scrambling QB, you aren't winning anything meaningful.
- Draft Hit Rate: Monitor the 2024 and 2025 draft classes. If more than three players from each class become multi-year starters, the rebuild is officially ahead of schedule.
- Discipline Metrics: Look for a reduction in pre-snap penalties. A disciplined team is a team that is coached well, regardless of the talent level.
The road back to the top is long. It’s paved with ugly losses and "learning moments." But for the first time in a long time, the Patriots have a clear direction. They aren't winning the Super Bowl tomorrow, but they are finally playing the game that leads to winning one eventually.