:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/crop-A24_Potato_Cake_Pile_Rey_Slightly_Hero_b_FINAL99-94412bd701cf40289f4d04de5c71ce55.jpg)
They’re finally back. Seriously.
If you’ve spent the last three years staring mournfully at a pile of Curly Fries while wishing for those crispy, shredded-potato triangles of joy, your fast-food exile is over. For a bit, anyway. The question of are potato cakes back at Arby’s has been the single most aggressive query hitting the brand's social media mentions since 2021, and the company finally cracked under the pressure in the summer of 2024.
It was a weird move when they pulled them. Honestly, it felt like a betrayal to anyone who grew up with the "Hat" logo. When Arby's cleared the deck to make room for Crinkle Fries, the internet didn't just move on; it organized. We saw petitions. We saw Twitter (X) accounts dedicated to a single menu item. We saw people genuinely angry that their roast beef sandwich was lonely.
But here’s the thing you need to know: they aren't back forever.
The 2024 Return: What You Need to Know Right Now
Arby’s officially brought Potato Cakes back to the menu starting July 1, 2024. It wasn't a quiet rollout. They leaned into the nostalgia hard, even bringing in Kyle MacLachlan for a "Potato Cake Anonymous" marketing campaign. It was self-aware. It was funny. It was exactly what the fans wanted.
But don't get too comfortable.
This isn't a permanent addition to the roster. Arby's has categorized this as a "Limited Time Offer" (LTO). In the world of fast food, that’s code for "get them while the supply chain holds out." Usually, these windows last about six to eight weeks, depending on how fast a location burns through its inventory. If you walk into an Arby's today and they tell you they're out, it’s likely because the local franchise didn't expect the surge or the promotional window has officially slammed shut in that region.
You can get them in a 3-piece or a 4-piece. The price hovers around $2.39 to $3.49 depending on where you live—Manhattan prices are going to hit different than a drive-thru in rural Ohio.
💡 You might also like: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
Why Did Arby's Ever Remove Them?
It comes down to kitchen efficiency and the cold, hard numbers of the "fry station."
Back in May 2021, Arby’s decided to "streamline" the menu. At the time, they were pushing Crinkle Fries as a permanent staple alongside the legendary Curly Fries. Most fast-food kitchens are designed with a very specific amount of fryer space. Adding a third potato option—especially one that is shredded and pressed like a Potato Cake—creates a logistical nightmare during a lunch rush.
Potato Cakes take longer to cook than fries. They’re also more delicate. If you drop a basket of Curly Fries, they're pretty resilient. If you manhandle a Potato Cake, it breaks.
The company's logic was that most people were already buying the Curly Fries. They figured the Potato Cake fans were a vocal minority. They were wrong. The backlash was so consistent that it became a PR asset. By removing them, Arby's accidentally created "McRib Energy"—the kind of cult following that only happens when you take something away.
Are Potato Cakes Back at Arby's Permanently This Time?
Probably not.
Look at the business model of modern fast food. Brands like Taco Bell and Arby's have realized that "permanence" is actually less profitable than "scarcity." When something is always available, you buy it once a month. When it’s only available for 30 days, you buy it three times a week because you’re afraid of the FOMO.
The 2024 revival is a test. Arby's Brand President Rita Gilkas has been vocal about listening to the "passionate" fan base. But "listening" and "changing the supply chain for 3,400 restaurants forever" are two different things. If the sales numbers from this summer's return absolutely shatter records, there’s a slim chance they could return as a seasonal staple, much like the King's Hawaiian Fish Deluxe.
📖 Related: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
The Difference Between Potato Cakes and Hash Browns
Don't let the cashier try to pivot you toward a breakfast hash brown. It isn't the same.
Arby’s Potato Cakes are thick. They have that specific, deep-fried exterior that shatters when you bite it, leading into a soft, almost mashed-potato-like interior. They are seasoned with a very light touch of onion and salt, designed specifically to be dipped in Horsey Sauce or Arby’s Sauce.
If you go to a location that serves breakfast, you might see "Potato Triangles." Those are similar, but the texture is usually thinner and more "industrial." The true Potato Cake is a lunch and dinner side. It’s a distinct culinary experience that Crinkle Fries simply cannot replicate, no matter how much salt you dump on them.
Where to Find Them Before They Disappear Again
The rollout was nationwide across the United States. However, because Arby's is largely a franchised operation, some owners have more leeway than others.
- Check the App: This is the most reliable way. If the Potato Cakes aren't listed under the "Sides" category in the Arby's app for your specific location, they are either sold out or that franchise has opted out of the promo.
- The "Order Ahead" Trick: Don't just drive there. Pull up the website. If you can add them to your cart, they have the physical product in the freezer.
- Ask for "Well Done": If you’re a true connoisseur, you know that Potato Cakes are best when they've had an extra thirty seconds in the oil. It prevents them from being "soggy" if you're taking them to-go.
The Nutritional Reality (If You Care)
Let's be real: nobody goes to Arby's for a salad. But if you're tracking your macros, the Potato Cakes are actually a bit of a heavy hitter compared to a small fry. A 3-piece order clocks in at roughly 250 to 270 calories. Most of that is fat from the frying process.
They are vegan-friendly in terms of ingredients (mostly potatoes, oil, and binders), but keep in mind they share a fryer with everything else. If you're a strict vegan, the cross-contamination with the roast beef drippings and chicken tenders is a factor.
What People Are Saying on Reddit and X
The reviews for the 2024 return have been overwhelmingly positive, though some "OG" fans claim the cakes feel slightly smaller than they did in 2020.
👉 See also: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
- "They taste exactly the same. My soul is healing." - @FastFoodFanatic on X.
- "I bought four orders and put them in my air fryer the next day. Still elite." - Reddit user in r/Arbys.
- "Why are they only back for a limited time? Just kill the crinkle fries already." - Every comment section on Arby's Instagram.
The consensus is clear: the quality hasn't dipped during the hiatus. Arby's didn't "New Coke" the recipe. They kept the original profile, which is why the demand is so high.
How to Handle the "Sold Out" Heartbreak
If you arrive and the sign says they’re gone, you have a few options that aren't just "giving up."
You can try the "copycat" route at home. Several frozen food brands, like Cavendish or even some private-label grocery store "hash brown patties," come close if you deep fry them instead of baking them. But they lack that specific Arby's grease-to-potato ratio.
Alternatively, some fans have found that smaller, rural Arby's locations tend to keep the LTO items in stock longer than high-traffic city locations. If you're on a road trip, that's your best chance to find a "hidden stash" of Potato Cakes after the national marketing campaign ends.
The Future of the Arby's Menu
We are entering an era of "rotating favorites."
The return of the Potato Cake is a blueprint. Expect Arby's to do this with other discontinued items. It keeps the brand in the news cycle without the overhead of maintaining a massive, 50-item menu year-round. It’s frustrating for the loyalists, but it’s brilliant for the bottom line.
If you want the Potato Cakes to stay, you have to vote with your wallet. Buy them. Buy them often. Mention them in the surveys at the bottom of the receipt. Fast food executives don't care about tweets as much as they care about "attach rates"—the frequency with which a side item is added to a sandwich order.
Actionable Steps for the Potato Cake Fan
If you're planning a trip to secure the goods, follow this checklist to ensure you aren't disappointed:
- Update your Arby's Rewards app immediately. They often run "Free Side with Purchase" coupons that apply to Potato Cakes.
- Call ahead if you are driving more than 15 minutes. It sounds "extra," but these items sell out daily in suburban areas.
- Pair them correctly. The "Pro Move" is putting a Potato Cake inside a Classic Roast Beef sandwich. The crunch of the potato against the soft beef is a game-changer.
- Stockpile (within reason). Potato Cakes actually freeze surprisingly well. If you buy a dozen, you can keep them in your freezer and reheat them in an air fryer at 400°F for about 4-5 minutes to get that original crispness back.
The window is closing. These aren't a permanent fixture yet, and if history is any indication, Arby's will put them back in the "vault" by the end of the season to build up hype for 2025. Go get your fix while the fryers are still hot.