Reach into your couch cushions. Check the cup holder in your car. Odds are, you’ll find a few copper-plated discs that are, quite literally, worth less than the effort it takes to bend over and pick them up. It’s a weird American quirk. We’re obsessed with efficiency, yet we cling to a coin that costs more to make than it can actually buy. People have been asking are pennies being phased out for decades, yet every year, the U.S. Mint churns out billions more.
It’s expensive. It’s heavy. It smells like metallic vinegar.
The reality of the penny is a mess of logistics, lobbying, and a strange brand of nostalgia that keeps our currency stuck in the 20th century. While countries like Canada, Australia, and Brazil have already ditched their lowest-denomination coins, the United States is lagging.
The Math Just Doesn't Work
Money is supposed to be a tool for exchange. But when the tool costs more than the value it represents, the system is broken.
According to the U.S. Mint’s 2023 Annual Report, it now costs about 3.07 cents to produce a single one-cent piece. Think about that for a second. The government is essentially running a business where they lose 2 cents on every "sale." Last year alone, this discrepancy resulted in a loss of over $90 million for the Treasury. This isn't a new problem, either. The cost of materials—specifically zinc and copper—has been climbing for years. Since 2006, the penny has been a "loss leader" with no upside.
We’re basically burning tax dollars to keep a coin in circulation that most people just dump into a glass jar at the end of the day.
Why? Because the zinc industry has a very powerful lobby. Companies like Jarden Zinc Products, which provides the blanks for pennies, have a vested interest in keeping the penny alive. They’ve spent hundreds of thousands of dollars lobbying Congress through groups like "Americans for Common Cents." They argue that the penny prevents inflation, but most economists think that's total nonsense.
What Happens if We Stop?
If you're worried that the economy would collapse without the one-cent piece, look North. Canada stopped distributing pennies in 2013. They didn't explode.
In Canada, they use a system called "rounding." If you pay with a card, nothing changes. You pay the exact amount down to the cent. But if you pay with cash, the total is rounded to the nearest five-cent increment. If your coffee is $2.02, you pay $2.00. If it's $2.03, you pay $2.05. It’s simple. It works. It saves the government millions in production and distribution costs.
💡 You might also like: Mississippi Taxpayer Access Point: How to Use TAP Without the Headache
Wait, doesn't that hurt the poor?
That’s the big argument. Proponents of the penny say that rounding would act as a "hidden tax" on low-income individuals who rely more on cash transactions. However, research by Robert Whaples, an economics professor at Wake Forest University, suggests that rounding actually balances out perfectly over time. Sometimes the consumer wins, sometimes the merchant wins. It’s a wash.
The "Lincoln Factor" and American Sentiment
We love Abraham Lincoln. He's arguably our greatest president, and his face has been on the penny since 1909. There’s a psychological barrier here. Removing the penny feels, to some, like a slight against Honest Abe.
But Lincoln is also on the five-dollar bill. He’s doing just fine.
Beyond sentiment, there's the "charity factor." Think about the "Pennies for Patients" drives or the little jars at gas station counters. Charities collect millions in pennies every year because people are willing to give away something they perceive as worthless. If the penny disappears, do those donations vanish? Or do people start giving nickels? It’s a valid question that keeps the "are pennies being phased out" debate alive in the halls of Congress.
The Military Already Did It
If you want a preview of a penny-less America, look at U.S. military bases overseas. Since the 1980s, the Army and Air Force Exchange Service (AAFES) has used a rounding system at their stores. Why? Because shipping heavy boxes of pennies to a base in Germany or South Korea is a logistical nightmare and incredibly expensive.
The military decided it wasn't worth the weight. And guess what? No one complained. The soldiers and their families adapted instantly. If it works for the Department of Defense, it can probably work for a Target in Ohio.
The Environmental Toll
It’s not just about the money. Mining zinc and copper is a dirty business. We’re tearing up the earth and burning fuel to transport tons of metal that eventually ends up sitting in a "Coinstar" machine or a landfill.
📖 Related: 60 Pounds to USD: Why the Rate You See Isn't Always the Rate You Get
Most pennies don't even circulate.
They move from the Mint to the bank, to the retailer, to the customer, and then... they stop. They go into jars. They get lost in the wash. The velocity of the penny is incredibly low compared to the quarter or the dime. We are essentially manufacturing trash.
So, Are Pennies Being Phased Out Right Now?
The short answer is: No. There is currently no active legislation that has a real chance of passing in 2025 or 2026 to kill the penny. While various "COIN" acts have been introduced over the years—notably by Senators like John McCain in the past—they usually die in committee. The political will isn't there. No politician wants to be the one who "raised prices" by eliminating the penny, even if that's a misunderstanding of how rounding works.
However, the "stealth" phase-out is happening.
More and more businesses are becoming "cashless" or encouraging digital payments. When you pay with Apple Pay or a credit card, the penny is already irrelevant. We are moving toward a digital economy where the physical denomination of a cent is becoming a ghost. The market might eventually do what Congress won't: make the penny so useless that banks stop ordering them.
Real-World Costs for Small Business
Talk to a small business owner. Ask them about "rolling" pennies. It takes time. Time is money.
- Counting: Employees have to count down drawers.
- Transport: Business owners have to lug heavy bags of coins to the bank.
- Fees: Some banks actually charge businesses to take large amounts of coin.
For a mom-and-pop shop, the penny is a nuisance. It slows down the checkout line. It adds weight to the safe. Honestly, most clerks would be thrilled if they never had to count out 99 cents in change again.
The Future of the Cent
Eventually, the math will become so lopsided that the government will be forced to act. If the cost to make a penny hits 5 cents, the absurdity will be impossible to ignore. We've done this before, by the way. In 1857, the U.S. stopped making the half-cent. At the time, the half-cent had more purchasing power than the penny does today.
👉 See also: Manufacturing Companies CFO Challenges: Why the Old Playbook is Failing
We didn't miss it then, and we won't miss the penny now.
Until that day comes, you’re stuck with them. You can't even melt them down for the metal value—that's a federal crime punishable by five years in prison. Don't try it.
Your Next Steps with Your Pennies
Since the penny isn't going anywhere legally just yet, you might as well make the most of what you have. Sitting on $50 worth of pennies in a five-gallon water jug isn't helping your bank account.
1. Use a Coinstar, but be smart. Most machines take a hefty percentage (usually around 11-12%) if you want cash. However, if you choose a gift card option (like Amazon or Starbucks), they often waive the fee entirely. You get the full value of your "trash."
2. Check for "Wheaties." Before you dump your coins, look for "Wheat Pennies" (minted between 1909 and 1958). While most are only worth a few cents, certain rare dates like the 1943 Copper Penny or the 1955 Doubled Die can be worth thousands of dollars. It’s a long shot, but it’s the only way a penny will ever make you rich.
3. Pay in exact change. If you’re a cash user, stop hoarding. Use those four pennies at the bottom of your pocket to round out your transaction. It keeps the line moving and keeps your pockets light.
4. Donate to "Micro-Charities." Many local schools and animal shelters still run penny drives because they are easy ways for people to contribute without feeling the "pinch." It’s the one place where the penny still has a high social value.
The penny is a relic of a different era. It’s a piece of copper-plated zinc that tells a story of American inertia. We know it’s a bad deal, we know it’s wasteful, but we just can’t seem to let go of the change. For now, the penny stays. Just don't expect it to buy you anything.