You’ve seen the razor blades in the caps. You’ve seen Cillian Murphy’s icy stare as Tommy Shelby, walking through the soot-stained streets of Small Heath with the swagger of a king. It’s a vibe. But honestly, are peaky blinders real or just a clever bit of historical fiction cooked up by Steven Knight?
The truth is a bit messy.
Yes, they were real. But they weren't exactly the dapper, organized crime syndicate you see on Netflix. If you bumped into a real Peaky Blinder in 1890s Birmingham, you probably wouldn't find a tortured soul who quotes poetry and navigates high-level political conspiracies. You’d find a violent, loud-mouthed street thug who was more interested in stealing your boots than running a multi-million-pound betting empire.
The Reality of the Birmingham Sloggers
Before the name "Peaky Blinder" became a household term, Birmingham was terrorized by "sloggers." These were groups of young men, often as young as 12 or 13, who lived for "slogging"—basically, just massive, unstructured street brawls. They were a product of the Victorian slums. Imagine living in a back-to-back house with ten other people, no plumbing, and no future. The gang was your family, your status, and your protection.
By the 1890s, the term "Peaky Blinder" started popping up in local newspapers. The first time the name actually appeared in print was after a brutal assault on a man named George Eastwood in March 1890. Eastwood, a teetotaller (he didn't drink), was having a ginger beer at a pub when a group of men started mocking him. They followed him out and beat him so badly his skull was fractured.
A letter to the Birmingham Mail later identified the attackers as members of the "Peaky Blinders" from Small Heath. So, when people ask are peaky blinders real, the answer is a definitive yes—but they were more "muggers in the park" than "international arms dealers."
Did They Actually Have Razors in Their Hats?
This is the big one. It’s the signature move of the show. In the series, they sew disposable razor blades into the peaks of their flat caps and use them to slash the foreheads of their enemies, blinding them with their own blood. It’s cinematic. It’s terrifying.
It’s also almost certainly a myth.
Historian Carl Chinn, who literally wrote the book on this (Peaky Blinders: The Real Story), has spent years debunking this. First off, safety razors were a luxury item in the late 1800s. They were expensive. A street gang member in Birmingham wouldn't have been able to easily get his hands on them, and even if he did, sewing them into a floppy hat wouldn't make a very effective weapon. The hat would be too light; the blade would likely just cut the wearer's fingers.
💡 You might also like: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
So, where did the name come from?
It’s likely much simpler. "Peaky" referred to the style of the flat cap they wore, which they’d pull down low over one eye. "Blinder" was common Birmingham slang for someone who looked particularly striking or well-dressed. If you were "looking a blinder," you looked sharp. These guys were vain. They wore silk scarves, bell-bottom trousers (yes, really), and brass-buttoned jackets. They wanted you to know who they were before they hit you with a belt buckle or a heavy-toed boot.
The Real Timeline: 1890 vs 1919
If you’re a fan of the show, you know it starts right after World War I, in 1919. Tommy Shelby is a war hero suffering from what we now call PTSD. This is where the fiction takes over.
The "real" Peaky Blinders were actually a Victorian-era phenomenon. By the time the 1920s rolled around, they were mostly gone. They had been supplanted by a much more powerful and organized gang: The Birmingham Boys, led by a man named Billy Kimber.
In the show, Kimber is a bit of a secondary villain, a loudmouth who gets dispatched by Tommy. In real life? Billy Kimber was the boss. He was the most powerful gangster in England. He controlled the racecourses, he had a massive network of bookies, and he didn't have a Tommy Shelby to contend with.
Why the Show Shifted the Dates
Steven Knight, the show’s creator, based the series on stories his father told him. His father had seen these men as a child and viewed them through a lens of mythic grandeur. By shifting the timeline to the post-war era, Knight was able to weave in the political turmoil of the 20th century—the rise of Communism, the IRA, and the British Fascists. It makes for better TV, but it blurs the lines when people ask are peaky blinders real in the context of the 1920s.
Who Were the Real Members?
We actually have mugshots of the real Birmingham gang members from the West Midlands Police archives. They aren't Cillian Murphy lookalikes.
- Harry Fowles: Known as "Baby-faced Harry," he was arrested at age 19 for stealing a bicycle. He looks like a kid, but he was a known member of the gang.
- Ernest Bayles: Arrested for stealing a bike as well. Most of their crimes were petty: shopbreaking, "bicycle larceny," and "assaulting police."
- Stephen McHickie: A man with a formidable reputation who was often in and out of the lock-up for violent offenses.
These men didn't live in mansions. They didn't have private chefs. They lived in the "Garrison Lane" area, and while they were feared, they were also frequently arrested for very minor things. They were more like the "foot soldiers" of a neighborhood gang rather than the masterminds of a criminal empire.
📖 Related: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
The Evolution into the Birmingham Boys and the Sabinis
By the time the show’s timeline kicks in, the era of the Peaky Blinder had faded into the era of the Racecourse Wars. This is where the real history gets fascinating.
Billy Kimber's Birmingham Boys were basically the evolution of the Peaky Blinders. They moved out of the slums and onto the racecourses of the South. This brought them into direct conflict with the Sabini gang, a London-based Italian-English group.
Charles "Darby" Sabini—who is a major character in the show—was very real. He was the "King of the Racecourse Gangs" and operated out of Clerkenwell. The war between the Birmingham Boys and the Sabinis was brutal, involving razors (actual ones, held in the hand) and massive brawls at places like Epsom and Ascot.
While the Shelby family is fictional, the world they inhabit is populated by these real-life titans of the underworld. The show uses "Peaky Blinders" as a catch-all name for what was actually a much more complex shifting of power between various regional gangs.
The Women of the Peaky Blinders
In the series, Aunt Polly (played by the legendary Helen McCrory) is the backbone of the business. She’s sophisticated, dangerous, and incredibly smart.
In reality, the women of the Birmingham slums were definitely tough—they had to be—but they weren't running criminal syndicates. However, they were integral to the gang "culture." The girlfriends and wives of the real Peaky Blinders had their own "uniform." They usually wore a lot of pearls, a long fringe (bangs) that covered their foreheads, and a silk handkerchief tied over their heads.
They were known for being fiercely loyal and would often participate in the street fights, using their own heavy purses or even stones wrapped in fabric as weapons. They weren't "CEOs," but they were definitely part of the violence.
What Happened to the Real Gangs?
They didn't just disappear. They were eventually "policed" out of existence.
👉 See also: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
A man named Charles Haughton Rafter was appointed Chief Constable of Birmingham in 1899. He was a reformer. He realized that the old-school way of policing—just hitting people with truncheons—wasn't working. He brought in more organized patrols, better training, and harsher sentencing for "slogging."
By the start of World War I, many of the young men who would have joined these gangs were sent to the front lines. The ones who came back were different. The world had changed. The "street gang" mentality of the 1890s didn't fit the more organized, corporate style of crime that was emerging in the 1920s and 30s.
Separating Fact from Fiction
So, when we look at the question are peaky blinders real, we have to separate the myth from the mud.
- The Name: Real. It came from 1890s Birmingham.
- The Style: Real. They were obsessed with their appearance and looked "sharp" compared to the average worker.
- The Razors: Likely fake. They used boots, belts, and clubs.
- The Shelby Family: Fictional. The real "bosses" were people like Billy Kimber and later, the Sabinis.
- The Timeline: The real Peaky Blinders peaked about 20-30 years before the show takes place.
Why Does the Myth Persist?
We love a good anti-hero.
The real Peaky Blinders were probably pretty unpleasant people to be around. They were bullies. But the idea of them—men who rose from nothing, who had a code of honor, who dressed like royalty in the middle of a wasteland—that’s powerful.
Steven Knight took the "bones" of Birmingham’s history and built a modern epic. He took the name of a local gang and turned it into a symbol of working-class rebellion. It’s not "true" history, but it’s "inspired" history.
If you visit Birmingham today, you can still see the remnants of this world. The Black Country Living Museum (where much of the show is filmed) gives you a sense of the scale of the industry. The narrow alleys of Digbeth still feel like they’re hiding secrets.
Actionable Steps for History Buffs
If you’re fascinated by the real history and want to go deeper than the TV show, here’s how you can actually explore the real story of the Birmingham gangs:
- Read Carl Chinn’s Research: If you want the most factually accurate account, pick up Peaky Blinders: The Real Story. He’s the leading authority and actually has family ties to the era.
- Visit the West Midlands Police Museum: They house the actual mugshots and criminal records of the Peaky Blinders. Seeing the faces of Harry Fowles and his crew makes the history feel much more grounded.
- Explore the Black Country Living Museum: While it’s a filming location, it’s also a remarkably preserved look at the industrial landscape that created these gangs.
- Walk through Digbeth and Small Heath: Much of the architecture has changed, but the layout of the streets still echoes the Victorian era. Look for the "old" pubs—some of them have been around since the days of the original sloggers.
The real Peaky Blinders didn't change the course of British politics or rub shoulders with Winston Churchill. They were just men trying to survive in a brutal city. But in their own way, they left a mark on the city of Birmingham that, thanks to a hit TV show, has now become a global legend.
The real story isn't as glamorous as the show, but in many ways, it’s more human. It’s a story of poverty, vanity, and the desperate desire to be "someone" in a world that treated you like "no one."