If you spent your summer of 2024 shouting at your television screen every time Kaylor Martin forgave Aaron Evans for the seventeenth time, you weren't alone. It was the "fawking" heard 'round the world. Everyone wanted to know: would the Pennsylvania bubbly blonde actually stay with the British Traitors winner once the cameras stopped rolling and the reality of Casa Amor truly sank in?
Honestly, the answer is a hard no.
They are not together. They haven't been for a long time. In fact, by the time the Love Island USA Season 6 reunion rolled around in August 2024, the relationship had already imploded in spectacular, New York City-pavement fashion.
The Breakup: Not Quite a Fairytale Ending
It’s easy to think these couples just drift apart because of distance. After all, Pennsylvania to the UK is a long flight. But for Kaylor and Aaron, it was way messier than a simple time-zone issue. Kaylor basically "stood on business" once she got her phone back and actually watched the footage of what happened with Daniela Ortiz Rivera.
She realized that what Aaron told her in the villa wasn't the full story. Not even close.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Perfect Donny Osmond Birthday Card: What Fans Often Get Wrong
At the reunion, things got incredibly heated. Aaron admitted to lying about the extent of his physical connection with Daniela, confessing he "didn't have the balls" to tell Kaylor the truth face-to-face in the real world. Kaylor’s response? She called him "disgusting" and lamented wasting her entire summer on him.
Where They Stand in 2026
Fast forward to today, January 2026. If you're looking for a reconciliation, you're going to be disappointed.
Kaylor has moved on. Like, really moved on. In mid-2025, she "hard launched" a new relationship with a guy named Torin Dunn. Fans immediately pointed out that she clearly has a "type"—Torin shares some of that tall, athletic aesthetic Aaron had—but the vibe seems way more stable. No more crying every five minutes on TikTok.
As for Aaron, he took a massive step back from the spotlight. After the reunion backlash, which he described as "horrible" for his mental health, he actually deleted his social media apps for a while and retreated to the UK.
📖 Related: Martha Stewart Young Modeling: What Most People Get Wrong
The "Beyond the Villa" Reunion
You might have seen clips of them together in late 2025. That wasn't a romantic reunion. They both signed on for the Peacock spinoff, Love Island: Beyond the Villa.
Seeing them on screen again was awkward. Kaylor admitted she still found him attractive (because, let's be real, she's human), but she also revealed that he had blocked her and her entire family on social media after the initial split.
"I do think Aaron is a great guy. I know who he is—that's why I love him. But we're not together." — Kaylor Martin, Beyond the Villa (2025)
They managed to film the spinoff without a total nuclear meltdown, reaching a place of "civil" friendship. But the romantic spark? That's been dead and buried since the 2024 reunion.
👉 See also: Ethan Slater and Frankie Grande: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Why It Matters for Love Island Fans
The Kaylor and Aaron saga is basically a case study in "Villa Vision." In the bubble of Fiji, everything feels like destiny. Once you're back in Pennsylvania or London, and you're watching your boyfriend put his hands down someone else's pants on 4K resolution, the "destiny" part starts to look more like a red flag.
Most of the Season 6 cast has remained surprisingly close, but Kaylor and Aaron are the primary example of a day-one couple that just couldn't survive the transition to the real world.
What to watch for next:
- Check out Kaylor’s Instagram for updates on her life in LA; she’s transitioned fully into the influencer space.
- Keep an eye on Peacock’s "Beyond the Villa" for the full closure arc between the two.
- Don't expect an Aaron Evans comeback tour anytime soon; he seems much happier away from the American reality TV machine.
The bottom line is simple. Kaylor found her voice, Aaron found the exit, and they both seem significantly better off for it.