You’re standing in line at a TSA checkpoint in a small-town airport in the middle of the U.S. mainland. The agent looks at your ID, frowns, and asks to see your passport. You tell them you don’t need one. You’re from Puerto Rico. The agent looks confused.
This happens. More often than it should.
So, let's get the big question out of the way immediately. Are citizens of Puerto Rico citizens of the United States? Yes. Absolutely. 100%. If you were born in San Juan, Ponce, or a tiny mountain town in Utuado, you are a natural-born U.S. citizen. You have the same blue passport as someone born in Peoria or Phoenix. You don't need a visa to move to New York, and you don't need a green card to work in Florida.
But here is where things get messy.
While the citizenship part is a definitive "yes," the rights that come with that citizenship depend entirely on where you happen to be standing. It is a strange, often frustrating middle ground that most people on the mainland don't actually understand.
The Law That Changed Everything
We have to go back to 1917. Before that, Puerto Rico was a bit of a legal ghost. The U.S. had acquired the island from Spain in 1898 following the Spanish-American War, but for nearly two decades, the people living there weren't quite Spanish anymore, but they weren't exactly American either. They were "citizens of Porto Rico."
Then came the Jones-Shafroth Act.
President Woodrow Wilson signed this into law on March 2, 1917. It officially granted U.S. citizenship to anyone born in Puerto Rico. Some historians argue this was a generous move to integrate the island. Others, more cynical but probably right, point out that the U.S. was about to enter World War I. By making Puerto Ricans citizens, the government made them eligible for the military draft.
👉 See also: What Really Happened With the Women's Orchestra of Auschwitz
In fact, around 20,000 Puerto Ricans served in that war.
Since 1917, that citizenship has been protected by statute. This is a subtle but vital distinction. If you are born in one of the 50 states, your citizenship is guaranteed by the 14th Amendment of the Constitution. If you are born in Puerto Rico, your citizenship is granted by an Act of Congress. Could Congress take it away? Theoretically, yes, though legal experts say that would be a constitutional nightmare and highly unlikely.
Living in the "Unincorporated" Zone
Being a U.S. citizen in Puerto Rico is not the same as being a U.S. citizen in Ohio.
Puerto Rico is an "unincorporated territory." This is a fancy legal term that basically means the island belongs to the U.S. but isn't considered part of the U.S. in the way a state is. Because of this, the Constitution doesn't apply there in its entirety.
This leads to some wild contradictions.
If you live in San Juan, you cannot vote for the President of the United States in the general election. You have no voting representation in Congress. You have a "Resident Commissioner" in the House, currently Jenniffer González-Colón, who can speak and join committees but cannot cast a final vote on the floor.
Think about that for a second. Millions of American citizens have zero say in the federal laws that govern them.
✨ Don't miss: How Much Did Trump Add to the National Debt Explained (Simply)
However, if a Puerto Rican moves to Orlando, Florida, or Chicago, Illinois, they can register to vote that same day. Their rights "activate" the moment they establish residency in a state. It’s like a light switch. On the island? No vote. In a state? Vote.
The Tax Myth and the Reality of Federal Benefits
You've probably heard someone say, "Puerto Ricans don't pay taxes!"
That is mostly wrong.
While it's true that residents of Puerto Rico generally do not pay federal personal income tax on income earned within the island, they pay almost everything else. They pay Social Security taxes. They pay Medicare taxes. They pay import and export taxes, commodity taxes, and payroll taxes. In fact, Puerto Ricans contribute billions to the federal treasury every year.
The real sting comes from federal funding.
Because it's a territory, Puerto Rico receives significantly less funding for programs like Medicaid and SNAP (food stamps) compared to the states. In a landmark 2022 case, United States v. Vaello Madero, the Supreme Court ruled 8-1 that the federal government can legally deny Supplemental Security Income (SSI) to U.S. citizens living in Puerto Rico, even if they would qualify for it while living in a state.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor, whose parents were from Puerto Rico, was the lone dissenter. She argued that there is no "rational basis" for treating citizens differently just because of where they live. But the law, as it stands, says the government can.
🔗 Read more: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
The Insular Cases: A Dark Legal Shadow
Why is the law like this? It comes down to a series of Supreme Court decisions from the early 1900s known as the Insular Cases.
These rulings are, frankly, quite racist by modern standards. The Court at the time basically decided that the people living in these newly acquired territories—Puerto Rico, Guam, the Philippines—were "alien races" who might not understand Anglo-Saxon law. Therefore, the Constitution shouldn't fully apply to them until Congress decided they were "incorporated."
Shockingly, these cases have never been overturned. They still form the legal backbone of how the U.S. treats its territories today.
Common Misconceptions That Just Won't Die
Kinda crazy, right? Even with over a century of citizenship, the confusion persists. Let's clear up the most common ones.
- "Do they use the dollar?" Yes. It's the U.S. Dollar.
- "Is the mail the same?" Yes. The USPS treats Puerto Rico like a domestic zone. You can use a standard Forever stamp.
- "Is Spanish the only language?" No. Both English and Spanish are official languages. Most government business is bilingual.
- "Can they be drafted?" Yes. Puerto Ricans have served in every single U.S. conflict since 1917, often at higher rates per capita than many states. The famous 65th Infantry Regiment, the "Borinqueneers," was a segregated unit of Puerto Ricans that fought heroically in WWI, WWII, and the Korean War.
The Statehood vs. Independence Debate
This question of citizenship is at the heart of the island’s political struggle.
People are divided. Some want statehood because they want full voting rights and equal federal funding. They want that 14th Amendment protection. Others want independence because they feel the current "Commonwealth" status is just a polite word for a colony. Then there are those who want to keep the "status quo" because it allows for a unique cultural identity and certain tax advantages.
There have been several plebiscites (non-binding votes) over the years. The results usually lean toward statehood, but the turnouts and the way the questions are phrased always spark intense debate. Washington D.C. has generally stayed quiet on the matter, as admitting a 51st state would drastically shift the balance of power in Congress.
Real World Action Steps
If you are a U.S. citizen living on the mainland, the best thing you can do is stay informed about the territorial status of your fellow citizens.
- Check your ID knowledge. If you work in a position that requires checking IDs, remember that a Puerto Rican driver's license is a valid U.S. government-issued photo ID. It is Real ID compliant.
- Understand the voting gap. Recognize that when federal laws are passed regarding healthcare or disaster relief, 3.2 million Americans in Puerto Rico have no voting voice in that process.
- Support local Puerto Rican commerce. If you visit, realize that you are supporting a domestic economy. You don't need a currency converter, and your cell phone plan probably works exactly the same as it does at home.
- Advocate for the end of the Insular Cases. There is a growing legal movement to have the Supreme Court revisit these 100-year-old rulings to ensure that citizenship means the same thing everywhere the American flag flies.
The reality is that Puerto Ricans are as American as anyone born in New York or California. They share the same rights to travel, work, and serve. The only thing missing is the full weight of the ballot box and the equity of federal support—a gap that remains one of the most unique and complicated features of American law.