If you spent your summer watching the absolute chaos of Bachelor in Paradise Season 10, you probably have one couple burned into your brain: Allyshia Gupta and Sean McLaughlin. They weren't just a couple; they were the "strategic" duo that turned the beach into a chessboard. But as we've seen a million times before, what works in the humidity of Costa Rica often hits a wall once the plane touches down in the real world.
So, are Allyshia and Sean still together?
The short answer is no. They aren't. Honestly, it’s a bit of a bummer for those who thought their "us against the world" mentality would actually last. They left the show together, full of big promises about Tampa and buckets of popcorn, but the reality of 2026 looks a lot different for both of them.
The Strategy That Backfired (And The Exit)
Let's backtrack for a second because their exit was legendary—or at least, they tried to make it feel that way. Sean was basically the grand architect of "The Plan." He was so focused on that $500,000 prize that he started treating the other contestants like NPCs in a video game. It rubbed everyone the wrong way.
Allyshia was right there with him, though. She was his ride-or-die. When the rest of the cast started whispering about voting them off for being "there for the wrong reasons," they didn't wait for the axe to fall. They pulled the classic "you can't fire me, I quit" move.
🔗 Read more: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
They walked off that beach hand-in-hand, declaring that their love was worth more than any cash prize. Allyshia even told the cameras they were headed back to Tampa to "watch it all back" together. It felt like a solid ending. A little dramatic? Sure. But solid.
Why Allyshia and Sean Still Together Didn't Last
Life happens. Specifically, career opportunities happen.
By late 2025, the cracks were already showing. During the Bachelor in Paradise Unplugged reunion, the truth finally came out. It wasn't some massive, cheating-scandal blowout. It was just... distance. And ambition.
Allyshia got some major opportunities in Los Angeles. If you follow her on social media, you know she’s not the type to sit around waiting. She moved to L.A. to chase those career goals, and she was very vocal about it. She famously said she wasn't willing to compromise her professional dreams "for a heterosexual man." You’ve gotta respect the honesty there.
💡 You might also like: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Sean, meanwhile, stayed focused on his own path. He’s been running a sales team for an AI company—a job that has him traveling across the country constantly. Between her L.A. hustle and his corporate travel schedule, the "Tampa dream" just evaporated. They weren't in the same city anymore, and 26 days of filming isn't always enough foundation to support a long-distance relationship between two high-achievers.
Where They Stand Right Now in 2026
If you're looking for drama or "receipts" of them fighting, you won't find much. They’re actually on surprisingly good terms.
- The Friendship: Allyshia has mentioned in interviews that they still FaceTime. They consider themselves "best friends" and "teammates."
- The Social Media Factor: There was a weird moment where Sean posted a photo with a money bag over Allyshia's face—sorta trolling the fans—but she cleared it up quickly. They like to mess with the audience.
- New Ventures: Sean is diving deep into interior design lately, which is actually his background. He seems happy to be out of the "reality TV spotlight" for a bit.
It’s one of those rare cases where "we're just friends" might actually be true. They don't follow each other with the same intensity they did right after filming, and Allyshia has posted videos about "waiting for the man she needs," which is a pretty clear signal that the Sean chapter is closed.
A Quick Note on the "Other" Sean and Allyshia
Just to clear up some confusion that’s been floating around Google: don’t confuse this duo with Shawn and Alliya from 90 Day Fiancé. Different show, different spelling, different outcome. Those two actually got married and are still together as of their latest updates in 2025. Our Paradise pair? Not so much.
📖 Related: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The Reality Check
Look, the "villain edit" or the "strategic couple" trope usually ends this way. When your relationship is built on navigating a game show, it’s hard to transition into "who's doing the dishes?" and "how do we handle three time zones?"
Sean and Allyshia were the strongest couple in terms of gameplay, but maybe not in terms of long-term compatibility. They both seem much more invested in their individual careers than in forcing a relationship that required one of them to move across the country.
What to Watch for Next
If you’re still keeping tabs on them, keep an eye on:
- Allyshia’s L.A. Projects: She’s clearly building something big in the lifestyle/entertainment space.
- Sean’s Design Work: He might be transitioning away from sales and back into his creative roots.
- The Next Reunion: Don't be surprised if one of them shows up on a future season of Paradise or another spinoff. They're too good on TV to stay away forever.
Ultimately, they’re a classic example of "right person, wrong timing." Or maybe just "right person for a TV show, wrong person for real life." Either way, they’ve moved on, and honestly, they both seem to be doing better for it.
Actionable Insight: If you're following reality TV couples for relationship advice, remember that "strategic alliances" rarely survive the transition to a 9-to-5 life. Check their individual Instagram stories rather than looking for joint posts—that's usually where the real life updates happen these days.