You’re staring at the screen. One card—maybe a black seven—is buried under a pile of kings, and you’ve already cycled through the draw pile three times. It feels personal. You start wondering if the deck was stacked against you from the jump. Most of us have been there, late at night, clicking "New Game" because the current one feels like a dead end. But here is the cold, hard truth: are all solitaire games winnable? No. Not even close.
It’s a bit of a heartbreaker for the perfectionists out there. We like to think that if we just played better, or if we had a "Take Back" button that went all the way to the beginning, we could solve every layout. Mathematics and computer simulations have proven otherwise. Depending on the version of the game you're playing, the odds of a deal being "solvable" change drastically. Some games are almost always winnable, while others are basically a statistical middle finger.
The Klondike Problem: Why Most Deals Are Dead Ends
When people talk about solitaire, they usually mean Klondike. It's the one that came pre-installed on Windows for decades. In Klondike (Draw 3), the math gets messy fast. Because so many cards are face-down in the tableau, you’re playing a game of imperfect information. You don't know where the Aces are. You don't know if the red six you need is buried under three other cards.
Research by mathematicians like Persi Diaconis and various computer scientists has tried to pin down the exact win rate. It's tough. Why? Because a computer can "see" the whole deck and play perfectly, whereas a human is just guessing. If a computer plays with full knowledge of every card's location—what we call "Thoughtful Solitaire"—the win rate is estimated to be around 80% to 92%.
But you aren't a computer. You can't see through the cards.
In a standard game where the cards are hidden, your actual win rate is likely closer to 10% to 30%. This gap exists because you might make a move that looks right but actually blocks the only path to victory. You move a black five onto a red six, only to realize ten minutes later that the other black five was the one you needed to free up a buried King. You’re trapped. The game was winnable, but not by you, and not with the choices you made.
The Mystery of the Unwinnable Deal
Is it possible to have a deal that is 100% impossible, even for a computer? Absolutely. Imagine a deal where all the Aces are at the very bottom of the tableau piles, covered by cards that can't be moved because their foundation spots aren't open yet. It’s a literal stalemate from the first second.
Some estimates suggest that about 1 in 400 games are truly, mathematically unwinnable from the start, regardless of how "perfectly" you play. However, that number only applies to deals where you can see all the cards. In the real world of "hidden" cards, the number of games that feel unwinnable is much higher because you lack the data to make the right move.
FreeCell: The Outlier
If you hate losing, you should probably switch to FreeCell.
FreeCell is unique because almost every single hand can be beaten. In the original Microsoft Windows version, there were 32,000 numbered deals. For years, players tried to beat every single one. It became a community project. They found that only one—deal #11982—was truly, undeniably unwinnable.
Later, as the number of deals expanded to millions, computers found a few more duds, but the win rate stays incredibly high, usually cited at 99.99%. If you lose at FreeCell, it’s almost certainly your fault. That's a tough pill to swallow, but it makes the victory much sweeter. The "open" nature of the game—where you see every card from the start—removes the luck of the draw and turns it into a pure logic puzzle.
Why Some Apps Feel Like They're Cheating
Ever noticed how some mobile solitaire apps have a "Winning Deals" mode? That’s not a coincidence. Developers know that losing ten times in a row makes people close the app. To keep those engagement numbers up, they filter the random shuffles. They use an algorithm to check the deck against a solver before it ever hits your screen.
If you’re playing on a "Winning Deals" setting, then yes, all those solitaire games are winnable. But you’re playing a curated experience. It’s the difference between a wild hike and a paved path in a park.
- Random Shuffles: True randomness is chaotic. It doesn't care about your feelings or your win streak.
- Curated Shuffles: The app ensures at least one path to victory exists, even if it's a narrow one.
Tactics to Improve Your Odds
Since we know most games could be won if played perfectly, how do you get closer to that 80% computer-level success rate? It’s not just about moving cards because you can. It’s about moving them because you should.
First off, stop emptying spots just because they're available. In Klondike, an empty spot is useless unless you have a King ready to jump into it. If you clear a column and don't have a King, you've actually reduced your playing space. It’s a rookie move that ends more games than anything else.
Secondly, prioritize the biggest piles. You want to uncover the cards in the columns on the right side of the screen as fast as possible. Those piles are deeper. They hold more secrets. The more cards you flip over, the more information you have. Information is the only thing that beats the "unwinnable" odds.
Variations Matter
Not all solitaire is created equal.
- Spider Solitaire: If you’re playing four suits, your win rate is going to be abysmal—maybe 5-10% for a skilled player. One suit? You should win 99% of the time.
- Pyramid: This is notoriously difficult. Many deals are mathematically impossible because the cards you need to pair are buried under each other.
- Yukon: Much higher win rates than Klondike because you have more freedom to move groups of cards, even if they aren't in order.
The Psychology of the "Reset"
Why do we keep playing if the odds are sometimes zero?
🔗 Read more: Why Beyblade Burst QuadDrive Basically Changed How We Play the Game
There’s a psychological phenomenon at play here. Solitaire is a "low-stakes" way to impose order on chaos. Life is messy. Work is complicated. But a deck of cards? That's a closed system. When you hit a dead end and realize a game isn't winnable, there’s a strange relief in hitting "New Game." It’s a clean slate.
We forgive the game for being unwinnable because the cost of failure is zero. We aren't losing money; we're just spending time.
Final Verdict: Are They All Winnable?
The answer is a firm no. If you are playing a truly random shuffle of Klondike or Pyramid, you will eventually hit a deck that is a literal brick wall. No amount of genius or "Undo" clicks will save you.
However, in the most popular version (Klondike), about 80% or more are technically winnable if you knew exactly what was under every face-down card. Since you don't, you're going to lose a lot of winnable games. And that's okay. The mystery is part of the draw.
Next Steps for the Competitive Player
If you want to stop guessing and start winning, here is your path forward:
- Switch to FreeCell if you want to test your pure logic without the interference of "bad luck."
- Check your app settings. Look for "Random vs. Winning Deals." If you want the truth, go random. If you want a dopamine hit, stick to winning deals.
- Study the "Rule of Three" for Klondike Draw 3. Learning how to manipulate the order of the deck by changing how many cards you play from the waste pile is the difference between a 15% win rate and a 40% win rate.
- Use the Undo button as a learning tool. When you hit a dead end, go back ten moves and try the other branch. It’s the only way to see where you made the "wrong" choice in a "winnable" game.
Stop beating yourself up over a loss. Sometimes, the cards just aren't there. Move on to the next shuffle.